The Recipe for Disaster [Shadowvanilla] - xoxotoast - Wattpad

Story cover for The Recipe for Disaster [Shadowvanilla] by xoxotoast

The Recipe for Disaster [Shadowvanilla]

Reads 192
Votes 13
Parts 2
Time 53m

Reads 192
Votes 13
Parts 2
Time 53m

Pure Vanilla and Shadow Milk have brought life into the world. A daughter.

She is small, fragile - and they are not ready for a responsibility like this.

Still, they'll do whatever it takes to keep her safe - even if it means getting hurt in the process.All Rights Reserved

Table of contents

2 parts

Sign up to add The Recipe for Disaster [Shadowvanilla] to your library and receive updates

or

#235shadowmilkcookie

Content Guidelines

You may also like

"It all Started with a Bet..." / ShadowNilla PureMilk / PhantomPlayz140 by PhantomPlayz140

A bet Shadow Milk lost to led him to 'rethink' his relationship with his counterpart. Shenanigans ensue! ▼Cover Art by PhantomPlayz140 (Reference used!) ▼Characters belong to Cookie Run Kingdom, DevSisters ▼Notice: If there is a story similar to mine in Archive Of Our Own under the name experimental_recluse, that's me! This is just an advanced notice in case there are claims it was stolen off of Wattpad or AO3. ▼ Started: April 02, 2025 ▼ Ended: May 15, 2025

"Fated to Last, or Fated to Pass?" / ShadowNilla PureMilk / PhantomPlayz140 by PhantomPlayz140

Pure Vanilla is marked with Hanahaki Disease; a fate he has to decide as time ticks closer to his permanent doom. ▼Cover Art by PhantomPlayz140 (Reference used!) ▼Characters belong to Cookie Run Kingdom; DevSisters ▼Notice: I have a similar story in AO3 under the name @ experimental_recluse ! If there's any other copies from different sites and user, they do not belong to me unless otherwise! Report if you must. Thank you! ▼ Started: May 17, 2025 ▼ Ended: June 16, 2025

Illusion by elxyine

SHADOWVANILLA STORY!! Shadow Milk Cookie plans to deceive Pure Vanilla Cookie, In order to keep the soul jam for himself. But what will happen if he ends up falling for his own tricks? What if his illusion isn't thick enough?

Falling for You was Anything but a Mistake by Identityy_Theft

Shadow Milk Cookie is not soft. He isn't kind, and he doesn't tell the truth. Pure Vanilla Cookie would beg to differ. A sappy story following our favorite cookie duo, from redemption and patience, to love and understanding. And then of course, let's spice it up ;) Top Shadow Milk Cookie in this economy!? Wow, that's insane! Word Count: 10,420 Cover Art by @fruitsjellies on X

"Loneliness is Interpreted in Different People." / ShadowNilla / PhantomPlayz140 by PhantomPlayz140

Pure Vanilla thinks he's overthinking his recent observation on his husband Shadow Milk, until he wasn't. Someone's feeling a little unfaithful lately... ▼Cover Art by PhantomPlayz140 (No reference used. /srs) ▼Characters belong to Cookie Run Kingdom; DevSisters ▼Notice: I have a similar story in AO3 under the name @ experimental_recluse ! If there's any other copies from different sites and user, they do not belong to me unless otherwise! Report if you must. Thank you! ▼ Started: July 02, 2025 ▼ Ended: July 11, 2025

Lucid Dreaming by EvelinSmithwp

Pure Vanilla Cookie has a naughty dream about Shadow Milk only to find out it wasn't in fact, one hundred percent a dream.

Absorption by EvelinSmithwp

Behind all the layers of goodness, Pure Vanilla Cookie's Soul Jam yearns to be fused again with its evil other half. He and Shadow Milk Cookie begin sharing dreams, memories, and fragments of suppressed feelings-feelings that were never meant to come to light. Feelings that could mean the ruination of all cookie kind.

We'll Meet Again (Don't Know Where, Don't Know When) by Identityy_Theft

Pure Vanilla regretted touching that orb. Admittedly, it was beautiful. A bright, cerulean blue orb. It looked like the ocean - no, like space. Both? It didn't matter; it was breathtaking. And oh, the way it was wrapped in shimmering gold, adorned with delicate little flowers. It was mesmerizing. Pure Vanilla couldn't help himself- He had to touch it. Pure Vanilla Cookie finds himself back in time time, in The Spire of Knowledge. The Fount of Knowledge takes interest in his pretty little time-anomaly. Aka 23k+ words of porn with lots and lots of plot. You're welcome! This was NOT beta read! NOT!!! There will probably be some mistakes- I'm only human 💔 Word Count: 23,516 Cover Art by lycheenfruit on tumblr

The Land Of Deceit Of Beast-Yeast | CRK | PureShadow by rinxxmilky

There's a few hc you should know for this book. HC for my shadow milk cookie in this fanfiction : - Have an adopted daughter named Candy Apple Cookie & 𝘢𝘥𝘰𝘱𝘵𝘦𝘥 𝘴𝘰𝘯 𝘯𝘢𝘮𝘦𝘥 𝘉𝘭𝘢𝘤𝘬 𝘴𝘢𝘱𝘱𝘩𝘪𝘳𝘦 𝘤𝘰𝘰𝘬𝘪𝘦 - Would have mood swings when trying to do his work/job etc. (𝘚𝘢𝘴𝘴𝘺 much🙄) - Has a fragile & weak body but doesn't tell other cookies abt it - Talking to himself.. a few cookies would think he's crazy or just..sick.. - 𝘈 𝘎𝘦𝘯𝘥𝘦𝘳𝘧𝘭𝘶𝘪𝘥 cookie :3 - Prefer to use she/him for himself or his family to call smc.. Just a few cookies doesn't know about it. - Has a lot of forms including a female form since... It was his past self. •┈┈┈••✦ ⚜️ ✦••┈┈┈• 𝑬𝒏𝒋𝒐𝒚 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒔𝒉𝒐𝒘, 𝒍𝒂𝒅𝒊𝒆𝒔 & 𝒈𝒆𝒏𝒕𝒍𝒆𝒎𝒂𝒏!

This wasn't the plan but I like it. (SHADOWVANILLA) by FaerieOfGays

(Picture isn't mine and all the credit goes to the creator of the art and Devsisters for CRK. Art; https://www.newgrounds.com/art/view/thesparkledash/shadowvanilla) . After being tricked and defeated by Pure Vanilla Cookie and his allies-Gingerbrave, Wizard Cookie, and Strawberry Cookie-Shadow Milk Cookie was revengeful, having half of his Soul Jam in possession. Shadow Milk Cookie wants to destroy Pure Vanilla Cookie, his allies, and Earthbread. Pure Vanilla Cookie wants to redeem Shadow Milk Cookie and give the Beast of Deceit a second chance at being good. Will Shadow Milk Cookie succeed or will Pure Vanilla Cookie? Will Shadow Milk be a foe, friend, or something more? Only time shall tell..

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

"It all Started with a Bet..." / ShadowNilla PureMilk / PhantomPlayz140 cover

"Fated to Last, or Fated to Pass?" / ShadowNilla PureMilk / PhantomPlayz140 cover

Falling for You was Anything but a Mistake cover

"Loneliness is Interpreted in Different People." / ShadowNilla / PhantomPlayz140 cover

Lucid Dreaming cover

Absorption cover

We'll Meet Again (Don't Know Where, Don't Know When) cover

The Land Of Deceit Of Beast-Yeast | CRK | PureShadow cover

This wasn't the plan but I like it. (SHADOWVANILLA) cover

"It all Started with a Bet..." / ShadowNilla PureMilk / PhantomPlayz140

A bet Shadow Milk lost to led him to 'rethink' his relationship with his counterpart. Shenanigans ensue! ▼Cover Art by PhantomPlayz140 (Reference used!) ▼Characters belong to Cookie Run Kingdom, DevSisters ▼Notice: If there is a story similar to mine in Archive Of Our Own under the name experimental_recluse, that's me! This is just an advanced notice in case there are claims it was stolen off of Wattpad or AO3. ▼ Started: April 02, 2025 ▼ Ended: May 15, 2025