When Only I Knew You (Tyler Joseph x reader) - Cookie - Wattpad

Story cover for When Only I Knew You (Tyler Joseph x reader) by Snickerdoodledog

When Only I Knew You (Tyler Joseph x reader)

Snickerdoodledog

Reads 11
Votes 1
Parts 1
Time <5 mins

Reads 11
Votes 1
Parts 1
Time <5 mins

Snickerdoodledog

alternateuniverse fetusjosh fetustyler fluffprolly highschool joshdun love nosmut top twentyonepilots tylerjoseph tylerjosephxreader tylerxreader xreader

In the movies, reality shifts cause catastrophe; they destroy cities, shake the world, and rip holes in the space-time continuum. However, in real life, reality shifts are subtle rewrites of the timeline. They appear suddenly, and it's hard to notice when they happen. But me? Oh, I noticed. I noticed when my favourite band vanished from existence. I noticed when my friends didn't know who I was talking about. And, most importantly, I noticed when one of the band's members started attending my school.




I need to make the most of it.All Rights Reserved

alternateuniverse fetusjosh fetustyler fluffprolly highschool joshdun love nosmut top twentyonepilots tylerjoseph tylerjosephxreader tylerxreader xreader

Table of contents

Prøløgue
Fri, Sep 19, 2025

1 part

Prøløgue
Fri, Sep 19, 2025

Sign up to add When Only I Knew You (Tyler Joseph x reader) to your library and receive updates

or

#614twentyonepilots

Content Guidelines

You may also like

wide awake//[t.j.] by thesoftestwords

it started with a dream. but what happens when you're wide awake? SEQUEL TO "dream boy//[t.j.]" {i will put a warning before any triggering subjects are brought up} ------------------------- thesoftestwords 2021® --------------------------

Searching for Purpose (Twenty One Pilots) by bulletproof-daydream

Tyler was sad. He was hurt, confused, angry, and scared, too, but most of all, he was sad. He didn't know if it was because he had been stuck in the same town for his entire life or it it was something a bit more serious, but that little uncertainty didn't stop him from applying to colleges all throughout the country and going to the one the furthest away from where he grew up. It wasn't the best choice he had made in his life, but suddenly there's this kid that shows up who dyes his hair a different color almost every month, and maybe, just maybe, he's the cure to Tyler's, well, whatever it is. This story is for all of you who don't know how strong and amazing you are, and for those of you who do. You have the power to do anything you can imagine. Use that power well.

Once Upon A Time [2p!Canada x Reader x 1p!Canada] by TheCrazyLittleGirl20

[Please read Book 1: Once Upon a Summer before reading this, so you would understand. Thank you.] Last summer was quite a ride for you. You met Matt Williams, met his brothers and had a crazy summer adventure. You even managed to fall in love with Matt. It was a lot to handle but you kept strong. Now that summer has ended, you decided that it was time to move on from last summer. It was time for a whole new adventure as Matt Williams' girlfriend. However this adventure wasn't what you expected. In fact, it was something you would never expect to happen. Who would've thought that you'd find a secret pentagram that would teleport you to a whole different dimension? Sounds crazy right? It almost sounds impossible for someone with a life like yours. Almost. Considering how crazy last summer was, something like this had the possibility to happen. Now you've got to find a way back home. You have to get back to the world you've lived in for all of ypur life. You need to get back to the love of your life. Or maybe you don't have to. Maybe you can stay. Maybe certain Matthew Williams will convince you to stay.

✔Celestial Beauty by teaweeeee

Growing up, I always thought that there was something terribly wrong with me. Because while everyone else had no problem blindly following orders, I had always been more curious. I realized I wasn't the only one when I met my friends. We came up with a whole plan to wait until graduation and then leave. We were so close, until it all went backwards. All this time we thought that it was unlivable atmosphere outside of the barriers. That no one else dared to be curious. Turns out there was a real good reason for that. As they used to say, curiosity did kill the cat.

Promises by blurry-fics

You and Tyler were inseparable as kids, often regarded as the dynamic duo of the small town that you grew up in. As teens, you often fantasized about leaving your small town to pursue your dreams in other parts of the country. Your plans are suddenly put on hold when your father falls sick shortly after your high school graduation. Meanwhile, Tyler moves away from your hometown, leaving his past, and you, in the dust. Ten years later, there's talk that Tyler, now a successful musician, has returned to your hometown. Will you and Tyler reunite? Or are your differences too much to overcome?

The Dip and the Resurface by delaber

A Tyler Joseph story in 27 parts. Updated daily. If you're dipping under don't ever hesitate to reach out. And if you don't have a physical Josh, my dm is always open. You will resurface - I promise

The Run and Go (Josh Dun X Reader) by strangelyastonished

Having a crush on one of your closest friends is not easy. You want to tell them how you feel but what if they don't feel the same? Will your friendship be ruined forever? Why do crushes have to be so complicated? Three words could either change your whole life in a good way or a bad way. (I'm bad at writing descriptions, I know.)

Almost, Always 🍁🥀 by _velvetverse_

"Almost, Always" 🍁🌹 Some people enter your life like whispers...soft, sudden, and gone before you can hold on. She didn't expect to see him again. Not after years, not like this. Not when she had finally learned how to forget the boy who never truly left her mind. But fate isn't loud..it's quiet, casual... cruel. In a classroom filled with noise, their glances screamed stories. A slow-burn connection, unsaid words, and almosts that could've been everything. This is not a fairytale. This is a memory rewritten..with the ending she deserved.

You may also like

Slide 1 of 8

wide awake//[t.j.] cover

Searching for Purpose (Twenty One Pilots) cover

Once Upon A Time [2p!Canada x Reader x 1p!Canada] cover

✔Celestial Beauty cover

The Dip and the Resurface cover

The Run and Go (Josh Dun X Reader) cover

Almost, Always 🍁🥀 cover

wide awake//[t.j.]

it started with a dream. but what happens when you're wide awake? SEQUEL TO "dream boy//[t.j.]" {i will put a warning before any triggering subjects are brought up} ------------------------- thesoftestwords 2021® --------------------------