Your lips, my sweetest ambrosia

"She doubted she was Luz's anything, and, frankly, did she deserve to be? She was the perfect pastors' daughter, the host of all fundraisers, the head of the student council, practically the poster child of tidy, pristine, republican Gravesfield. And yet, here she was, battling terrible feelings as neat as Luz's room for her closest friend when she was supposed to have a boyfriend. If she ever told Luz what she thought of her, she was certain she'd scare her off forever."

OR

Amity Blight just wants to show her true self. But, when her parents run a church and believe her love is a sin, she's forced into a relationship with Hunter Wittebane. Neither of them want to be in this "relationship," but the pressure their family puts on them to maintain their flawless image is too strong to overcome.

It's difficult to act like a girl who wants and loves her boyfriend when her best friend, Luz Noceda, just won't leave her alone. Twinkly eyes, glimmering smiles, laughs that replay in Amity's mind until she can't hear anything else. And now, she's playing Luz's love interest in Hexside High's musical theatre production. How long can Amity quell her feelings for Luz before the tension snaps and they bubble to the surface?

Human world AU.