Questionable Love
- Reads 29
- Votes 0
- Parts 4
Ongoing7m
Last published Sat, Sep 27, 2025
Travis Phelps was always an aggressive kind of guy calling people f*ggots (rude word for gay) to hide the fact that even though he was a Christian that he was gay, then Y/N came a sweet and quiet girl who turned the aggressive Christian bisexual, will he work up the courage to ask her out or will she have to?... (I would add a picture but it won't load, also leave a thanks to my editor in the comments, the chapters will be edited a little after they are posted)
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Real Care : A Sal x Travis Fan Fiction
People at Nockfell high have rumored that Travis Phelps was a homo, a fag. When A beating goes too far and a young mind breaks down in a unfair world, nobody could help him... Or so he thought. (all characters are owned by the portable moose company, credits to artist on first page, I do not know who you are but this is amazing artwork, and I do not claim it as my own.)Complete
Don't judge a book by it's cover
(Art cover not mine) Travis X Larry Fan fiction "Larvis"-SallyFace This is my very very first fanfic I've ever written in my life, so don't hate on it too much. If you like this, I'll make more stories. Warning ! This story has:⚠️Inappropriate language, abuse, drugs and alcohol, slurs, sexual innuendos, sex actions, drama, and romance⚠️ Growing up in a strict Christian household, Travis has always known that marriage is supposed to between a man and a woman and if you were gay, you would go to hell. Travis has always known that ever since he was young but once he saw a boy named Larry Johnson who was friends with another boy named SallyFace, Travis has a crush on Larry but since he was raised, he doesn't know how to feel. Read this and find out to see what'll happen.Complete
not who i thought you were-larvis✝️🤘
Larry knows Travis Phelps is the worst. he's a self absorbed, hateful, judgmental, Bible thumping, church boy... or is that how he chooses to be seen, when Larry overhears something that makes Travis sound.. less hateful then usual, he gets curious. Travis Phelps and his church friends are.. horrible, or at least that's what their parents say. instead of being themselves they take their anger out on those who can be themselves, but what happens when they're finally forced to confront their own feelings?
Unfaithful
COVER'S NOT MINE __________________________________________ Travis Phelps is the local preacher's - Kenneth Phelps - son. though, ironically enough, he's a sinner. a filthy, grime-covered, sinner. his blood is not and never will be pure. ...That's until he meets Sal Fisher. ___________________________________________ TW/CW ⬇️ Eating disorders suicide suicide attempts abuse implied abuse self harm religious topics religious trauma Sexual assault Implied sexual assault underage drinking underage smoking slurs ___________________________________________ #1 in Travisphelps 10/23/25, 11/17/25, 1/19/26 🎉🎉 #2 in Christianity 12/22/25 #3 mlm 12/24/25 #1 Larryjohnson 12/30/25 ___________________________________________ I am not planning on writing smut, though there MAY be a few like kissing scenes or something like that. Most of this is angst. ___________________________________________ OKAY SO I JUST NOW REALIZED MY TITLE AND LIKE... SUMMARY THINGY IS VERY SIMILAR TO ANOTHER FIC "SINNER" THAT I'VE READ. I SWEAR THIS WAS SOLELY BASED ON MY OWN EXPERIENCE WITH RELIGION AND MY OWN INTERNALIZED HOMOPHOBIA AND PROBLEMS WITH SEXUALITY. HALF OF THIS FIC IS ME PROJECTING ONTO TRAVIS, AND SOME IS BASED ON SONGS AND MY OWN OCS. I FELT THE NEED TO STATE THAT.
A Salvis Story
Sal and Travis's story take a turn for the worst.... or for the better? tw: self-harm, child abuse, mentions of death, boy x boy, homophobia, racism READ WITH CAUTIONComplete
The Secretive Friendship(Salvis)
Sal, a teenage boy who can be misunderstood. He makes a connection with the one who hates him most. But will it forever last? Travis, a lonely teenage boy. Confused over sexuality. Mistreated, misunderstood, confused emotions, hatred. He had to be partners in a chemistry project with the one he hates most. They slowly connected. But will it last when Sal "disappears"? Warnings: Cussing Abuse Mentions of blood Smoking Growing ED Maybe more? #1 for salfisherxtravisphelps on 2/28/22. Thank you all 🙏❤ #1 on salvis on 3/16/22 #1 on sallyxtravis on 5/30/22 #1 on travisphelps on 5/22/24Complete
~Roses and guitars~ (Salvis)
- Honestly, i reread this and it's pretty cringe imo... READ AT OWN RISK!!! 😭 - ( FINISHED ) Travis Phelps is known as the 'bully' of the school, he picks on every kid for 'sinning' or just.. For being 'different'. An example is Sal Fisher, a boy who has to wear a prosthetic mask due to an accident that happened in the past. What could happen when the bully befriends the victim? And what will happen with the cult? ! COVER IS NOT MINE ! ~ This story is highly based off of a rp me and my friend did, so credits to them! ~ - My friend @cl0s3your3y3s has helped me with this fic the most, so a special thanks to them!! - ! WARNING, THIS STORY MAY INCLUDE ! - Trauma. - Mental/Physical abuse. - Kenneth. (Gotta put the warning for the scary things ykyk) - Homophobia/Slurs. - Heavy angst. - Bullying. - Self harm/Suicidal thoughts. This is my first ever fanfic, so i apoligize if this may be bad. ! ALL OF THESE CHARACTER AREN'T MINE, THEY'RE FROM A GAME CALLED 'Sally Face', THESE CHARACTERS ARE OWNED BY STEVE GABRY. ! Enjoy reading!Complete
Worth sinning for(Salvis)
Kenneth Phelps is the lead priest at the local church and has strict rules for his family. This leads to his son Travis Phelps to hate his whole being. His problems with his father are bad but he gets to escape at school being the one who pushes people around. Until he meets Sal Fisher or "sally face" a boy with a mask who Travis often fantasizes about despite thinking it's a sin. Due to his love hate for Sal he bullies him and his friends. But Travis and sal get to know each other better and Travis might find someone who is worth sinning for. Sal fisher or "sally face" just moved to the Addison apartments over the summer. He met Larry Johnson his now best friend who introduced him to all his friend's. When school started everything was going smoothly until Travis Phelps the local priests son started bully Sal and his friend's calling them homos and an array of awful things. Despite Travis awful attitude towards sal and his friend's sal tries to befriend Travis and get to the core of his problems After they get close sal might just help Travis find someone who is worth sinning for. [contents warning *abuse, homophobia, the F slur, self harm, smut but not until part 18]Complete
Butterflies Aren't Sinful (Salvis)
TW: violence, PTSD, child abuse, substance use, cannibalism, SH, depression, suicidal thoughts, NO SMUT. I REFUSE. Take care of yourself! <3 Sally face wants to offer assistance kindness to Travis Phelps, despite his aggressive demeanor. Sal knew there was more to Travis than what meets the eye, but he never expected to be able to see it. I'll try my best to keep this story accurate to the games timeline 🫡
God, Do You Love Me?
---UNDERGOING EDITING!!!---- Cw: gore, abuse, scars, blood, underage alcohol/drug usage, foul language, ect No smut. Fluff only. I spoke before he could hurt me again. "I know what's under the church, father." His face twisted with anger, but I kept going, tightening my grip on his wrist. "And I'm fascinated with it." "What do you mean, boy?" I looked him dead in the eyes. "I want to join the Devourers of God." (This story actually has a plot:) None of these characters, art, ect belongs to me. All rights go to the creator of the sally face games :)Complete
People at Nockfell high have rumored that Travis Phelps was a homo, a fag. When A beating goes too far and a young mind breaks down in a unfair world, nobody could help him... Or so he thought. (all characters are owned by the portable moose company, credits to artist on first page, I do not know who you are but this is amazing artwork, and I do not claim it as my own.)
More detailsContent Guidelines