"Outlaw Hearts
- Reads 31
- Votes 0
- Parts 4
Ongoing15m
Last published Fri, Oct 3, 2025
Life among outlaws is never simple. Loyalties are tested, blood is spilled, and every decision can mean the difference between life and death. For Arthur, the code of the gang has always come first-protect the family, follow Dutch, and never let emotions cloud judgment. Yet, with Melody's arrival, the old rules begin to fray. Her laughter is a balm to his weary soul, her intelligence a match for his wit, and her courage a beacon in the darkest hours. As Melody's relationship with Arthur deepens, it threatens to unravel the fragile peace of the gang and exposes them both to risks neither could have foreseen.
can there love make it
All Rights Reserved
#315
oldwest
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Thorned Rose, A Red Dead Redemption 2 AU
What if Arthur had a daughter and Micah had a son and they accidentally fell in love on a quest for revenge? When Rosemary Morgan (OC) watches her father, Arthur, die at the hands of Micah Bell at just 13 years old, she is forever changed. Consumed by grief and anger, she sets out on an obsessive manhunt with the help of Sadie Adler, determined to make Micah pay for everything he did to her and her father. 8 years pass, and Rosemary has yet to find him. Hope is slipping away, leaving her more cynical and impulsive by the day. But her luck hasn't completely run out, as one night in a saloon, a handsome stranger named Chase Blaire approaches her, claiming to know something about Micah's whereabouts. As they embark on their quest for vengeance, Rose finds herself falling for Chase as they open up to each other and let their guards down, but she is unaware that he is hiding a dark secret, one that could tear them apart and jeopardize everything.Complete![Ghosts of the Past [ RDR2 - Arthur Morgan ]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/378179321-256-k297219.jpg)
Ghosts of the Past [ RDR2 - Arthur Morgan ]
COMPLETE When Arthur met Rosemary at the young age of 25, he was pretty much a goner. It seemed Arthur had a thing for kindly little women. Maybe because deep down all he really wanted was an honest life on a ranch, with a lady he could worship and provide for like a real man should. And in his short time with Rosemary he allowed himself to play make believe that that could ever happen. But like most good things in Arthur's life - that came to a crashing end when Dutch uplifted the gang from that town to move on again. But people from the past always have a way of showing up when you least expect it.Complete
Arthur Morgan X OC | Red Dead Redemption 2.
Gotta say, never once had a man been able to make me go loose like this. Never once had a man make me feel weak at the knees. Until I met Arthur. A simple yet dignified man. I didn't much like being on the run so much but this man had made it seem bearable. ---- Warningggg Swearing Probably some sexual shit This is an OC i made off the top of my head. Her name is Robin Downgreen. Alright read on... ALSO THE COVER IS NOT MINE ALL RIGHTFUL SHIT GOES TO THE RIGHTFUL OWNERS!!!Complete
Arthur Morgan x Reader
You own a saloon in a town you wish to leave for good. One day, a group of outlaws decides to settle nearby. You decide to use them to your advantage to get out. Driven by his greed and the hunger for prestige, Dutch takes the deal you offer and puts his most trusted man, Arthur, up for your protection. However, even though Arthur seems like a fine fella, he has issues of his own and a lifestyle he can't seem to shake off.Complete
Under The Eyes of The Wolf (an rdr2 Arthur Morgan x oc story)
Following a botched robbery attempt in the town of Blackwater, the van der Linde gang now took shelter from the harsh, unforgiving elements in an old abandoned mining settlement known as Colter, deep in the snowy mountains. They are cold, hungry and unsure of what their futures hold. As Arthur Morgan is out desperately trying to track down game to bring back and feed to the starving gang he stumbles across an animal unlike any even he, in all of his travels, has ever seen before. As he crouches in the snow, his focus in its entirety directed at the animal before him, a stranger catches him by surprise. A WOMAN. As she cautiously holds him at gunpoint she explains the story behind the incredible animal before allowing him to go on his way. In the hours and days following the encounter he can't decide if this woman's presence in the same desolate, snow covered wilderness as he and the gang are in is mere coincidence or if there's more behind it than she's letting on. If it is pure coincidence that she's there than what is she doing alone on this frozen mountain? Whatever has brought her into his life he isn't sure but what he does know is he can't get her image out of his mind. Her intense red hair along with her piercing gaze that seems to stare right through him. As he attempts to find out more about her he convinces himself it's strictly out of caution. It's his responsibility to make sure that she's harmless and poses no threat to them but somehow deep down he already knows the only thing she poses a threat to is his heart. Warnings: will contain adult themes, adult language, sexual situations and dialogue, smut, violence, mentions of sexual abuse and other topics not suitable for children under 18. MATURE CONTENT. 18+ only. All characters besides my own are property of Rockstar Games. I do not claim ownership of any of the characters in this story other than K, Tacoma and Orion and I thank Rockstar for their amazing creative team and all of their work.Complete
silent love { Dutch Van Der Linde x Reader } / rdr2
ever since your family was killed by a gang of outlaws, you've lived your life on the run. you had to learn to survive on your own and protect yourself. never staying in one place for long lead you up into the Grizzlies where you got stuck in a snowstorm. freezing and starving, you thought you were going to die, until one day when two outlaws found you and took you back to their gang. there, you were introduced to their charismatic leader. you quickly fall for the wise leader, but how will you react when he wants to keep your relationship a secret?Complete
The wild, wild West (Arthur Morgan x f!Reader)
And finally, through the first snowflakes that started tumbling through the harsh wind, I spotted two silhouettes. Clad in thick winter coats, guns strapped to their backs. Each step filled with grim determination as they waded through the knee-high snow towards us. They stopped a few feet away. The taller man's eyes met mine. He carried himself with silent confidence, evident in the expression on his weathered, undeniably handsome face. Sky-blue eyes framed by thick brows, chapped, full lips, a crooked nose. An association lingered in the back of my head, but I couldn't quite grasp it, until I asked: „Who are you?" {-}-{-}-{-}-{-}-{-}-{-}-{-}-{-} Oh, the hatred that she holds for Dutch van der Linde. While running with the O'Driscolls for over ten years, this man had been the bane of her existence. Now, three years after leaving the gang, she gets lost up in the Grizzlies on the run from the bounty on her head. When she saves one of Van der Linde's men from a wolf attack and gets taken in by them as an ally, she has to face that hatred again. And then there's also Arthur Morgan, Dutch's right hand man, who won't let her forget either that they were enemies once. ❗️Currently undergoing heavy editing❗️ This story is a reader insert, but I avoid uses of (Y/n) as much as I can. Enjoy!Complete
A Quiet Time (Arthur Morgan x Reader)
Dutch had sent you and Micah to go out scouting and after nearly escaping an arrest in Strawberry, Arthur decides to take you to Valentine for a few drinks. Is this the chance to finally have your friendship grow into something more or will you ruin it all?Complete
What if Arthur had a daughter and Micah had a son and they accidentally fell in love on a quest for revenge? When Rosemary Morgan (OC) watches her father, Arthur, die at the hands of Micah Bell at just 13 years old, she is forever changed. Consumed by grief and anger, she sets out on an obsessive manhunt with the help of Sadie Adler, determined to make Micah pay for everything he did to her and her father. 8 years pass, and Rosemary has yet to find him. Hope is slipping away, leaving her more cynical and impulsive by the day. But her luck hasn't completely run out, as one night in a saloon, a handsome stranger named Chase Blaire approaches her, claiming to know something about Micah's whereabouts. As they embark on their quest for vengeance, Rose finds herself falling for Chase as they open up to each other and let their guards down, but she is unaware that he is hiding a dark secret, one that could tear them apart and jeopardize everything.
More detailsContent Guidelines