Love Lives In Dark Corners

The Creepypastas were approached by the Operator one day, offering them a new life. From untold circumstances, the Pastas that could pass as human were given amnesty and the forgiveness to reenter society.

But they're not given an easy escape from their appearances.
Their bodies need time to revert to a more mortal state. Their unnatural abilities have been ripped from them, leaving their physical bodies in need of medical care. They're no longer unbeatable monsters... they're now just mere mortals. (Jeff sure likes to think he's still invincible)
Though, they'll never be given an escape from their pasts.
Mortal minds work in stranger ways than those of monsters. The weight of the lives they've taken hangs heavy on their shoulders. Not only were their minds scrambled with newfound human emotions, but being around these humans day to day reminds them of the peace they often destroyed.

Some Pastas went their separate ways, but most ended up rooming with others that they got along with. Finding work while looking like them is rather difficult, let alone in the turmoil of what they've done.. Having someone to help with finances and be nonjudgmental is a blessing to all of them.

Jeff and Ben find themselves roomed together; job hopping, smoking, drinking, having the time of their lives! Jeff finds himself unfulfuilled, though... Murdering was fun to him, and he'd only taken the Operator's offer because he didn't want to be left alone in the manor with "the freakazoids".
What could he do that would safely satiate his aggressive tendencies while being cathartic?

A rock band, perhaps...? He'd need more members than just him and Ben, though!