Trust Was The First Mistake
- Reads 471
- Votes 25
- Parts 5
MatureOngoing53m
Last published Fri, Jul 10, 2026
This is an SMG4 fanfic where a stranger called SLG3 works with Mr.Puzzles and cause a lot of trouble in the SMG4 crew, oh btw he needs to kidnap the crew ☺☺
Created by: Xen0ly__ (Rache1ku_)
Released in: 28th October 2025
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
𝙱𝚊𝚍 𝙲𝚑𝚘𝚒𝚌𝚎𝚜 𝚆𝚎𝚛𝚎 𝙼𝚊𝚍𝚎. (𝚂𝚞𝚗/𝙼𝚘𝚘𝚗 𝚡 𝚁𝚎𝚊𝚍𝚎𝚛)
You're a college student and we're looking for a job-your friend Vanessa helps you with that, but at what cost? Sun/Moon x Reader Security breachComplete
Connectivity
In hindsight, Four should've seen this coming. Now SMG1 and 2 are at his doorstep, demanding to see his non-existent progress in meme training. Now that Three has been dragged into it as well, all he can do is hope that it'll be over soon. (Spoiler alert: It won't). However, as their powers and guardian connection grows stronger, so will their bond.Complete
SMG4 and The War Against Light
The cast are just having a good time when all of a sudden a magical entity of light appears and attacks them. This entity seems hellbent on getting rid of all of them to fix the world as it views the SMG4 cast as the biggest mistake the world made. The gang will have to band together and use all their strength to defeat this god-powered monster.Complete
SMG4: The Proditio Arc
???: "All you've done is ruin people's lives..." SMG4: "Look I'm sorry! I didn't mean-" The ground around the two begins to crumble. ---------------------------------------------------------------- This story contains: Swearing Mentions of gambling Mentions of alcohol Spoilers for several SMG4 arcs If any of these are a problem do not read. Also I suck at writing, so if you get confused I'm sorryComplete
One Room
The SMG4 crew +Mr Puzzles are on their way to a convention they have been invited to as esteemed guests! But since it's a long journey, the gang decide to stay overnight at a nice hotel! However, things get interesting when it's revealed that SMG4 and SMG3 changed the room-plan so that Mario and his +1, Mr Puzzles, are actually SHARING!! Now the Italian has to find a way to get through a night of sleeping directly next to his crush. Perhaps this could be his chance to get one step closer to dating the man?Complete
001 Imagines
001/Henry Creel/Peter Ballard Oneshots/imagines -Smut -fluff -angst -etc WARNING: my writing is not the greatest! Also sorry for the spelling errors 😂💀
Not much bro how bout you?
Note: This takes place after the confession A figure from Smg3's past has come back to haunt him. Today did not go as planned for him. He was stuck in here with no way out. And it all started with the stupid internet going down.Complete
No Reflection | LesEmExly
It was all fun and games until we made the biggest mistake that changed us forever.Complete
Haunted (A smg34 fanfiction)
From nightmares to self-hatred, smg4 seems to have problems with his self-esteem. Lucky for him, he has smg3 but will things end well? (Might change up the description and tags rahhh) ___ First time writing about these two and first time writing from taking a big break so go easy on meComplete![SMG4 in Schmicago [A Marware and SMG34 Fic]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/376895040-256-k610290.jpg)
SMG4 in Schmicago [A Marware and SMG34 Fic]
After escaping Schmigadoon, SMG4 and SMG3 return to find answers, alongside Mario and unknowingly pursued by Mr. Puzzles. But after a mysterious fog engulfs the four of them, they find themselves trapped in a gritty musical city in the 1920's called Schmicago. Their only hopes of escape? Well, Mr. Puzzles and Mario need to find true love. SMG4 and SMG3 need to make a "happy end," whatever that is. But after a dead body turns up... things start to look to be a lot more difficult than they originally thought. Will they be able to make it out of this strange musical city before they too become victims of a mass murderer?Complete
You're a college student and we're looking for a job-your friend Vanessa helps you with that, but at what cost? Sun/Moon x Reader Security breach
More detailsContent Guidelines