The Other Gilmore Girl
- Reads 961
- Votes 46
- Parts 6
Ongoing32m
Last published Tue, Oct 21, 2025
'Identical' is the word that most people use to describe us. But the truth is, we couldn't be more different. Rory's on her way to modern Shakespeare status, while my only bet at getting published would be through a scientific journal. My sister flits through life with her easy charm and effortless grace, while I've had to rely on my hard won grit and resilience.
Yes, scientifically speaking, Rory and I are twins. But between her and mom, I'm always the odd one out.
Gilmore Girls Fanfiction
All Rights Reserved
#272
starshollow
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Kisses of Fire
A Gilmore Girls Fanfiction In the small, coffee-fueled town of Stars Hollow, life has always been delightfully chaotic for Lorelai Gilmore. But between running the Independence Inn and raising her two daughters - the quick-witted Rory and her twin sister Lyra, the dreamer with a heart full of mischief - things are about to get even more interesting. When both girls are accepted into the elite Chilton Preparatory School, the Gilmore household faces a new chapter filled with early mornings, crisp uniforms, and endless caffeine. Rory sees Chilton as a stepping stone to Harvard; Lyra sees it as a story waiting to unfold - one that might just include poetry, stolen glances, and the quiet boy who writes songs no one else hears. Enter Theo Dugray, Tristan's younger brother: shy, observant, and devastatingly sincere - the complete opposite of his charming but arrogant sibling. While Tristan teases, Theo listens. While Rory studies, Lyra feels. And somehow, amid the chaos of exams, coffee cups, and Lorelai's rapid-fire humor, Lyra starts to discover who she really is - not just a twin, not just a Gilmore, but her own constellation entirely. A story about sisters, stars, and second chances, Stars Hollow Twins blends the fast-talking warmth of Gilmore Girls with the tenderness of first love - and a touch of stardust. • OC x OC •
The Other Gilmore
What if Lorelai Gilmore had twin girls? Frankie and Rory, fraternal twins with very little in common. Rory is quiet, Frankie is loud. Rory loves school, Frankie hates it. Rory is accepted to Chilton, Frankie didn't even apply. With Frankie left to her own devices while Rory is off at Chilton, what pranks and shenanigans can she stir up in Stars Hollow? And will her dreams of leaving the sleepy town and pursuing dance come to fruition? Disclaimer: I do not own any characters from Gilmore Girls. I only own Frankie and any other OC's.Complete
Mirrorball
Lorelai will always only love Lorelai. Claire has always known that. In fact she made peace with it and has been building a life that doesn't revolve around the name that brings her pain. But now her twin sister is going to Chilton and trying to be in a world that Claire built without her. Rory always thought that no matter what Claire would always only be her twin, Claire Stassi Gilmore. Claire, has always wished she was more than Rory's twin. There is too much pain that comes with being a Gilmore, Claire will make sure the world remembers her as Claire Stassi Danes.Complete
That's Not My Name ┃Gilmore Girls
Rory Gilmore was raised to dream. Charlotte Hayden was raised to win. Two daughters, two families, two very different worlds. That's Not My Name is a story of identity, legacy, and the spaces between the lives we live and the ones we might have had.
SOMEDAY, tristan dugray
IN WHICH the shipped-off twin sister of jess mariano finds life in stars hollow boring until she falls for a certain troublemaker at the private school of her dreams and starts looking at life a bit... differently, to say the least... or.... On Jess and Tessa's 10th birthdays, the twins' mother, Liz Danes came home from her date with some nutjob of a boyfriend, saying how he gave her a great idea. Jess wasn't expecting to hear the words, "Your sister is going to be moving to Connecticut with my brother, and your uncle, Luke." Nobody in any world outside of the Danes-Mariano family would ever be able to understand why on Earth Liz Danes would want to send her only daughter away, and separate her from her twin brother, but, hey!, that's just Liz Danes for you; famous for being the all-over-the-place wackjob that everyone in New York City knows her as. She'll never change... or will she? Tessa and Jess keep in contact through phone calls as often as possible, but eventually it just got impossible, since they both have their own lives to live. Although, no matter what, they always called each other to celebrate their birthdays together, over the phone. 7 years later, when Jess Mariano is 17, and starting to run with the wrong crowds, Liz can think of nothing else to do, but to simply send him to live with his uncle, as well. But is it really that simple? We'll see... Seasons 1-??? ~~Nat #5 in yale! #28 in Luke Danes #6 in Liz Danes
Beyond The Surface
What if Rory Gilmore had a twin sister? What if Lorelai had two daughters? Meet Delilah Gilmore, navigating life in Stars Hollow while quietly struggling with changes she can't fully explain - missed sounds, fading edges, and a growing sense that something isn't right. As Rory throws herself into Chilton and first love, Delilah learns to adapt in silence, relying on routines, instinct, and a growing bond with fellow Chilton student Alfie Calder. Set against the familiar rhythm of Stars Hollow, Beyond the Surface is a story about family, first love, and the things we don't always see - until we have no choice but to face them.Complete
𝐓𝐄𝐄𝐍𝐀𝐆𝐄𝐃𝐈𝐑𝐓𝐁𝐀𝐆
Lorelai had twins Rory and Romeo. Obviously one of them was her favourite, the other being their father's favourite. Resulting in both twin's being jealousy of each other. Romeo didn't hate his mother but he also didn't like her. It was more the fact he was like her in so many ways. That was the problem she couldn't love something so like herself.
STOLEN DANCE || GILMORE GIRLS
She was the perfect small town girl. She was smart, kind, and polite to everyone she met. But she had big dreams, dreams that went far beyond the town of Stars Hollow. That's how she and her sister ended up at one of the best high schools in Connecticut, but they didn't realize how much their lives would change when they walked into that school. Cassidy Gilmore would find herself questioning everything she thought she knew. She'd make friends and enemies, and she might even find love. But none of that would matter as long as she had her sister and mother by her side. [OC X Gilmore Girls] [Season 1-]Complete
A Gilmore Girls Fanfiction In the small, coffee-fueled town of Stars Hollow, life has always been delightfully chaotic for Lorelai Gilmore. But between running the Independence Inn and raising her two daughters - the quick-witted Rory and her twin sister Lyra, the dreamer with a heart full of mischief - things are about to get even more interesting. When both girls are accepted into the elite Chilton Preparatory School, the Gilmore household faces a new chapter filled with early mornings, crisp uniforms, and endless caffeine. Rory sees Chilton as a stepping stone to Harvard; Lyra sees it as a story waiting to unfold - one that might just include poetry, stolen glances, and the quiet boy who writes songs no one else hears. Enter Theo Dugray, Tristan's younger brother: shy, observant, and devastatingly sincere - the complete opposite of his charming but arrogant sibling. While Tristan teases, Theo listens. While Rory studies, Lyra feels. And somehow, amid the chaos of exams, coffee cups, and Lorelai's rapid-fire humor, Lyra starts to discover who she really is - not just a twin, not just a Gilmore, but her own constellation entirely. A story about sisters, stars, and second chances, Stars Hollow Twins blends the fast-talking warmth of Gilmore Girls with the tenderness of first love - and a touch of stardust. • OC x OC •
More detailsContent Guidelines