Story cover for The Matchlists by TanTan25
The Matchlists
TanTan25
  • WpView
    Reads 13
  • WpVote
    Votes 0
  • WpPart
    Parts 1
  • WpHistory
    Time 8m
  • WpView
    Reads 13
  • WpVote
    Votes 0
  • WpPart
    Parts 1
  • WpHistory
    Time 8m
TanTan25
Complete, First published Oct 17, 2025
1stpersonbanterboyfriendfantasyfirstflirtingflufffriendshipgirlfriendkeeperofthelostcitieskotlclostcitiesmomentsrandomromanceshannonmessangersliceoflifesokeefe
Hi ppl! This is just my head canon that after defeating the Neverseen, Sophie picks up her Matchlists just to see who the council wants to pair her with. She tells herself its just for entertainment, but a part of her wants Keefe's name on hers, and her name on Keefe's.

She's already facing scorn for dating someone before even having a winnowing gala, so will these lists further make her question her choices, or prove she's right where she needs to be?

PS: Cover art is not mine
All Rights Reserved
1stpersonbanterboyfriendfantasyfirstflirtingflufffriendshipgirlfriendkeeperofthelostcitieskotlclostcitiesmomentsrandomromanceshannonmessangersliceoflifesokeefe
Table of contents

1 part

Sign up to add The Matchlists to your library and receive updates
or
#149moments
Content Guidelines
You may also like
The Best Match (unfinished sorry :/) by lavenderibbons
22 parts Complete
disclaimer: i wrote this story in fifth grade and the only reason i haven't deleted it is because people seemed to enjoy it a lot. this isn't a reflection of my current writing and if you're new to my page PLEASE don't start with this or The Sleepover, because it's honestly not my best work. thanks for reading! :) Somehow, Biana has convinced Sophie to get her matchmaking scroll, along with the rest of the group. Sophie thinks she has it all figured out-- she's dating Keefe, and she's happy. But her list changes everything. Hearts are broken, matches are made, and friendships are tested in... The Best Match. Sequel to "The Sleepover," Sokeefe
Keeper of the Lost Cities: Forgetten by CresentMaiden
22 parts Complete
Betrayal after betrayal after betrayal. Three weeks since Keefe was seen by Sophie and her friends. Three weeks since Sophie's best friend turned his back on her. Three weeks since Sophie's heart was shattered. One day, a horrific incident happens and the Neverseen are to blame. But will Keefe be with them? Will he be his normal, fun loving self? Or someone completely different? Read this small fanfiction set between Shannon Messenger's Book 4 (Neverseen) and Book 5 (Lodestar). (This is my story set between Neverseen and Lodestar. I just imagined what the characters would do while they wait a year to get their next adventure and wrote it. Please don't steal it from me, it's not good enough to steal anyways.) *WARNING* TYPOS AND RUN ON PARAGRAPHS. READ AT OWN RISK. Cover by @ElvenNoir/SioCynder (tumblr)
The Aftermath by fumiguro
19 parts Complete
This story takes place after Sophie has defeated the Neverseen and before the elite levels. They have also never met Lihn and Tam. Sophie has defeated the Neverseen. But what happens when the universe decides it wants Sokeefe to happen? How many coincidences? How many accidents? At what cost will it take for the universe to get what it wants? new cover 2/20/2022 {|||||||||||||} #3 in sophiefoster 12/10/18 #2 in sophiefoster 12/11/18 #1 in sophiefoster 12/13/18
Continued Decisions by SarcasticRoastMaster
19 parts Complete
***ALL CHARACTERS AND PLACES BELONG TO SHANNON MESSENGER* THEY ARE NOT MINE* THIS IS JUST A FANFICTION BASED OFF OF THE BOOK SERIES, KEEPER OF THE LOST CITIES* This is the sequel to Forced Decisions, the first ending. Sophie and Fitz broke up a while back, and now Sophie is about to get her Match Making Scroll. Who will be her #1? Whose #1 will she be? And what happened/will happen between her and the gang? I know: still cliche, but you can... wait for it... SUCK IT UP! ;P :D I hope you enjoy! @rosabbit MADE THAT GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRREAT COVER! THANK YOU! :D
He Left Me - KotLC fic (after Unlocked) by featherlightfirefly
33 parts Complete Mature
This fanfic takes place after Unlocked, which ends (spoiler alert) with Keefe leaving. Sophie's heartbroken about him being gone, maybe forever, but the Neverseen is still a threat to her and her friends and family. After losing Keefe, Sophie's not here to play their games anymore. This is rated as mature because I'll occasionally reference something more graphic or use stronger language. (Sassy kinda-psycho Sophie?????) Please do NOT offer unsolicited criticism. I wrote this several years ago and it is a fanfiction. If you dislike any continuity errors, plot holes, etc., STOP READING. The cover is by soso_doodles on Tumblr--which you should totally check out, her art is awesome! All characters belong to Shannon Messenger.
Just Another Story- kotlc fanfic by _Chlocaine_
26 parts Complete
"This isn't funny Keefe!" "Mommy? Daddy?" A little girl asks My head whips around the I point to myself. "Me?" Sophie wakes up in an alternate dimension. Married to Keefe with 2 kids. To make matters worse she doesn't know how to get back home. This takes place between book 9 and 10 credits to @hunterofartemis109 and @TeamFosterKeefe195 for making the OG book this is just my version I do not own the characters only the kids all of the character rights go to Shannon Messenger
Awakening (a kotlc story) by Thesocialbookworm
41 parts Complete
Keefe is in a coma and won't wake up. And if he does, will he still be Keefe? Mysterious clues start showing up, each one pointing to one thing. Keefe's legacy. Who can Sophie trust? And how far will she go to save Keefe from his legacy? This is a kotlc fanfiction. All the characters/places/things/world were created by Shannon Messenger. The story happens after the events of Legacy, although some of the events were changed. I found the cover art online. This will forever be unfinished cause unlocked came out and now I have AP tests to study for. Also, I'd rather not return to being my middle school self. Credit for cover goes to @Emma_The_Pyrokinetic 🥉3rd place in Kotlc/Pjo competitions
Too Real: a Sokeefe Fanfic by AndPeggy_Schuyler
16 parts Complete
"You're not mad?" "You just kissed me, Foster. I don't think that's a reason to be angry." ------ This is a Sokeefe story! Sophie is captured by the Neverseen and given a drug that makes her tell Keefe everything. Ship: Sokeefe, background other ships Disclaimer: All characters come from the Keeper of the Lost Cities books and therefore belong to Shannon Messenger
𝗦𝗢𝗣𝗛𝗜𝗘 + 𝗞𝗘𝗘𝗙𝗘 𝗢𝗡𝗘𝗦𝗛𝗢𝗧𝗦 by keefescabin
20 parts Complete
sophie x keefe oneshots
You may also like
Slide 1 of 9
The Best Match (unfinished sorry :/) cover
Keeper of the Lost Cities: Forgetten cover
The Aftermath cover
Continued Decisions cover
He Left Me - KotLC fic (after Unlocked) cover
Just Another Story- kotlc fanfic cover
Awakening (a kotlc story) cover
Too Real: a Sokeefe Fanfic cover
𝗦𝗢𝗣𝗛𝗜𝗘 + 𝗞𝗘𝗘𝗙𝗘 𝗢𝗡𝗘𝗦𝗛𝗢𝗧𝗦 cover

The Best Match (unfinished sorry :/)

22 parts Complete

disclaimer: i wrote this story in fifth grade and the only reason i haven't deleted it is because people seemed to enjoy it a lot. this isn't a reflection of my current writing and if you're new to my page PLEASE don't start with this or The Sleepover, because it's honestly not my best work. thanks for reading! :) Somehow, Biana has convinced Sophie to get her matchmaking scroll, along with the rest of the group. Sophie thinks she has it all figured out-- she's dating Keefe, and she's happy. But her list changes everything. Hearts are broken, matches are made, and friendships are tested in... The Best Match. Sequel to "The Sleepover," Sokeefe

More details