The Feelings I Shouldn't Have...
- Reads 62
- Votes 17
- Parts 6
Ongoing10m
Last published Sun, Oct 19, 2025
•Setting: Middle-earth during Sauron's rise.
•Garadiel: A mysterious being (I'll leave them a bit open so you can picture them however you like - ally, rival, or reluctant lover).
•Tone: Dark, atmospheric, laced with desire, danger, and inevitability.
•Plot Threads:
while she was dying. everything was upside down
The pull of attraction vs the clash of wills.
An uneasy alliance in battle.
A tragic twist - because with Sauron, doom is never far.
One-shot written in 5 parts.
Don't judgee me its from my old notes app
All Rights Reserved
#221
watty
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
On Your Side (Thranduil Fanfiction-- The Hobbit & The Lord Of The Rings) Part 1
A girl from the 21st century, Jannidriel Smith came to Middle-earth for saving it to the Dark Lord, Sauron and to rewrite the prophecy written in this world. What would happen if this girl will meet the great elvenking who's heart had grown cold. Can she melt the elvenkings heart? Will they be friends, enemies or lover? Will she accomplish her mission?Complete![A Silver Lining (Lord of the Rings) [Legolas]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/20954953-256-k245789.jpg)
A Silver Lining (Lord of the Rings) [Legolas]
**Now featured on Wattpad's Official Lord of the Rings Fanfic Reading List!** The War of the Ring may be over, and Sauron may be defeated, but that does not mean that the very thought of evil has been erased from Middle-earth. Though they may not be as threatening as the Dark Lord had once been, evil beings still lurk, waiting to cause trouble. Meet Nimalia, an Elf who has, sadly, spent a lot of her time with the said evil beings. After a long time in her captors' hands, she manages to break free, only to be rescued by a random Man who happens to be riding along her path. She is then taken to Minas Tirith, acquainted with the Queen of Gondor, and introduced to an Elf who will forever change her life.Complete
Who Knew? ~ LOTR FanFic
Alana Quicksilver has a choice before her, one that could mean impending doom. When she chooses to go along with the Fellowship to try and destroy the one ring. As she sets off on her new journey, her dark past follows her. When she feels all alone there is someone looking out for her. Will she find true love and help the success of the mission? Or will her dark past consume her causing the casualties of everyone around her? Book One of the Chronicles of the Ring ~Watty Awards 2013 ~ *** Note: I do not own any of the characters (Excepting: Alana and her family and Mirima and her brother) The rights belong to J.R.R Tolkein. I also do not own the picture that was used to create the cover.***Complete
Bound By Starlight ~ Thranduil x Reader
Hidden away in an ancient tower, Y/N has lived her entire life in solitude, her only companion a sassy little gecko named Lómin. Bound by duty and the whispered warnings of her guardian, she has never stepped beyond the walls that confine her. Her gift, the power to heal wounds and reverse decay, flows through the long silver strands of her hair, but it comes at a cost. To use it, she must recite an ancient Elven prayer, a song of starlight that could make her either a savior or a target. The outside world is dangerous. She has been told this all her life. Kings would seek to control her. Thieves would try to take what is not theirs. And once her secret is known, she will never be free. But when fate sends an unexpected visitor to her tower, Y/N must make a choice: remain a prisoner of safety or risk everything for a chance at freedom...perhaps, even love. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ⚠️ Warnings ⚠️ • Violent Scenes • Graphic Descriptions • Sexual Themes • Age Gap • Strong/ Offensive Language ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Status: Ongoing • Started: 07/03/25 • Finished: ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Disclaimer • I don't own TLOTR/The Hobbit or its characters. • I do own Y/n + some extra added characters
An Angel As Queen; A Thranduil love story.
*Updated all chapters and changed the storyline a bit on 26-02-24 so if you're confused I do recommend rereading the previous chapters* Amdiriel was only four when her single mother was killed. For years she wanders around with the Dunedain rangers, and encounters Lady Galadriel, who teaches her how to use her powers. One day Galadriel comes to her with a rather unusual assignment, she needs to protect Thorin Oakenshield's company at all costs. That's how she ends up in The Battle of the Five Armies. When she uses her powers to save a rather handsome Elven-king, her life takes an unexpected turn. *All original characters belong to Tolkien *Amdiriel and the storyline belong to me #1 galadriel on 22/09/22 #1 thranduil on 23/10/22 #1 elrond on 02/02/23 #1 elvenking on 14/03/23 #1 elrond on 16/11/23Complete
Of Shadows and Starlight | E. Peredhel
Set in the world of Middle-earth, during the time of The Rings of Power, Melisane, the youngest sister of Finrod and Galadriel, unlike her sister's mind-reading abilities, possesses the divine gift of prophetic dreams, able to glimpse the future, past, and unseen realms. As a child, she was captivated by tales of dragons-creatures of wind, sky, and fire-and often dreamed of them, their power and grace haunting her thoughts. In the aftermath of the Elves' flight to Middle-earth, the loss of her brother Finrod, and Galadriel's departure to hunt Sauron, Melisane is left battling grief and feelings of abandonment. Despite her skill as a deadly commander and warrior, she struggles to find purpose, withdrawing from those who care for her as her dreams grow stronger. One fateful day, she stumbles upon a newly hatched, abandoned dragon-just as her dreams had foretold. Believing this moment signals a change in her destiny, Melisane takes the creature under her care. Concerned by her reclusive nature, Elrond, the Half-elven, and an old family friend, seeks her out and is shocked to find her raising the dragon. Agreeing to help her, he assumes she will eventually let it go, but their shared bond over the creature slowly rekindles their long-lost friendship-and something deeper. As shadows loom once again over Middle-earth, Melisane and Elrond must navigate the growing darkness, all while facing the uncertain futures that their hearts and dreams reveal. Will their newfound connection withstand the threats closing in, or will the starlight of their bond be consumed by the shadows? _ "You sleep coiled; tightly wound. Hands made fists beneath the pillows, clenched above cotton sheets. You are at war, even in your dreams, cenedril af fae nín. Let me help you."
Unspoken ( A Legolas Love Story )
AFTER the Battle of Five Armies, an elf prince journeys to the north of Middle Earth in search of the mysterious Strider. But to also escape the grief of a 'love unspoken' as well as the oppressive regime of his father, King Thranduil. There among the Dúnedain, Legolas finds friendship, adventure, a sense of humor and a female ranger who is not quite what she seems. Is he fated to forever love another unrequited? And what of the broken relationship with his father, will the prince's choices drive a deeper wedge between them? A classic love story, filled with adventure and intrigue, but ALSO a journey into the unwritten years of the beginning of an epic friendship with Aragorn; all set prior to 'The Lord of the Rings'. *Feb 2018: 2nd in The Middle Earth Awards* *June 2018: 2nd in Arkenstone (The Hobbit) category, The Tolkien Awards* *July 2018: Official Featured Wattpad Fanfiction* *Jan 2019: #3 in Romance Hotlist (181k stories) -0-0-0-0-0- I may have nicknamed this story 'Pride and Prejudice for Elves', our silver-haired princeling has several centuries of repression he needs to work through, as well lighten up - before he can become the elf that we know and love in LOTR! The story is COMPLETE! All votes and comments greatly appreciated. I'd be absolutely thrilled to have you join me on this journey of self-discovery in Middle Earth. The best writing in this story belongs to @GreenScholarTales, who kindly allowed me to weave my romance into her story, 'Starting Anew.' Please go and see her other works and her original series on Wattpad, The Book of Terrus. The beautiful painting on the cover was kindly loaned by the highly talented Irishmellow, see her awesome work at https://irishmellow.deviantart.com/ Copyright: Tolkien owns all the familiar characters, Jackson & Co. own Tauriel and the starting premise, Green Scholar owns several significant events and almost all of the rangers ... but one, Wren, she is all mine!Complete
《 Skip a Beat 》
𝔹𝕆𝕆𝕂 𝟙 | When an unforeseen attack from Grindelwald leaves Newt fighting for life, his five companions struggle to cope with the fact that they could lose him forever. Lines are sketched, love is tested, and everyone is drawn closer together as Newt battles to get back on his feet. ~~ ● 1 in #newtina 24/09/2019 ● 1 in #leta 20/09/2019 ● 1 in #jakweenie 20/09/2019 ● 1 in #queeniegoldstein 7/12/2019 ● 1 in #letalestrange 2/02/2020Complete
Only Time
(An Official Wattpad Fan fiction) Follow Hedraliel, Legolas' wife as she gives a first hand account on how they met, the multiple love triangles that nearly separated them for eternity, and the life they led after the wars for Middle Earth were won. Get ready for twists and turns that will have you breathless for more! Welcome to Only Time..... Cover was created by @Jells_; it features both Rivendell and Lothlorien in the background blending into one as the main character is a Princess of both lands. ***I do not own or have any affiliation with JRR Tolkien, Peter Jackson, or the production companies or characters created by them. However, all other characters and non Hobbit and LOTR storylines; All rights reserved © by Olga Pinsky***Complete
Home | Legolas x OC | LOTR Fanfiction
[Completed] PS. If you love the story, can you please leave votes on each chapter and comments so others may come and read it too🥰 Thank you! "Home" fanfiction follows Lunara Rainheart, a half-elf born to a hobbit mother and an elf from Mirkwood, as she struggles to find her place in a world where she never truly fits. Growing up in the Shire, Lunara faced rejection from the other hobbits, with only Frodo Baggins and the eccentric Bilbo Baggins offering her friendship. After her mother's passing, Frodo invites her to join his perilous journey, offering a chance to find the father she has never met and the home she has always longed for. Along the way, Lunara encounters Legolas Greenleaf, the Mirkwood prince, and discovers unexpected connections, dangers, and hope. This story follows the events and setting of the Lord of the Rings movies. All characters and the original story setting belong to their rightful creator. ®️ The original character Lunara Rainheart Raisen, her journey, and the story elements surrounding her are my creations. Reposting or using ideas and content from this story without consulting me is not permitted. P.S. There won't be any smut since I have readers under 18 even though it was marked Mature. I hope you'll shower it with love and support along the way! ❤️ 💙 A heartfelt thank you goes to my wonderful cousin for being a dedicated reader and for offering valuable feedback, helping me improve every step of this journey with her constructive criticism.💙 ⚠️I don't own the pictures except those created by AI Ranked: #1 LOTR #1 woodlandrealm #1 legolaslovestory #1 Thranduil #1 legolasgreenleaf #1 Mirkwood #2 Tolkien #2 legolasfanfiction #4 Legolas #4 Lotrfanfiction #4 Frodo #5 lordoftherings #8 elves #19 FantasyFictionComplete
A girl from the 21st century, Jannidriel Smith came to Middle-earth for saving it to the Dark Lord, Sauron and to rewrite the prophecy written in this world. What would happen if this girl will meet the great elvenking who's heart had grown cold. Can she melt the elvenkings heart? Will they be friends, enemies or lover? Will she accomplish her mission?
More detailsContent Guidelines