What She Didn't Kill
- Reads 42
- Votes 3
- Parts 2
MatureOngoing16m
Last published Sun, Oct 19, 2025
Wednesday Addams was supposed to kill Tyler Galpin.
He asked her to. Begged her to.
But she missed the blow, deliberately.
Now Tyler lives haunted by the monster that destroyed him... and by the girl who spared him.
Broken, without a master, without a purpose, he drifts in the wreckage of what he used to be.
Wednesday tells herself that leaving him alive was a logical decision, nothing more.
From enemies to something far more dangerous. A story about monsters, redemption, and the kind of love that should never have existed.
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Redemption and Love: A Wednesday x Tyler Story
After the defeat of Laurel Gates and Joseph Crackstone, life returns to normal. For everyone, except Wednesday Addams. She can't stop thinking about him. After everything they went through, Tyler couldn't be a villain, right? The last thing he said before being carted away still rang in her ears. "I meant every word that day." The feelings she had for him were real. Maybe the real Tyler was still in there somewhere. She had to find out.. A new threat has emerged within the of bounds Nevermore, new bodies emerging and the ever growing threat of ravens on the horizon. Wednesday may be reuniting with Tyler sooner than she thinks. Welcome back to my stories everyone! I know it's been sometime, but with the release of Wednesday Season 2, I figured it was time to put my writing hands back to work! I hope you all enjoy as much as I enjoy making these stories for you all❤️
To lose ~ Wednesday x Tyler
Tyler is falling for Wednesday yet he knows they can never truly be together because of his qualities of being a Hyde. He knows Wednesday well enough to know she will eventually find out, but he wants to make the most of what he has with her now ... I need to express my love for this show in a more healthy way rather than writing Wattpads on it... but here we are ;)
His Hyde's Jekyll
"You hesitated. Why didn't you kill me?" Tyler Galpin is nothing else than a huge enigma-and there's nothing Wednesday Addams despises more than a problem she can't solve. Her obsession has nothing to do with the aching, asthma-like sensation in her chest every time she thinks of Tyler. Nothing at all. This is my first story ever so I'm sorry if there are any mistakes of any kind :,) I'm a very big fan of the Netflix show Wednesday and my heart belongs to the Wednesday x Tyler ship. This is an alternate ending I tought about and continuation of season 1 because I really hope Tyler will get a redemption arc. Tyler x WednesdayComplete
The Psychic (World of woe I) #weyler
After the abrupt end of her first term at Nevermore, Wednesday returns home to face a relentless stalker and a monster-ex-boyfriend hell-bent on her destruction. Is she merely a new piece on the board, or the true player?Complete
You Cant Hyde From Me. (Tyler Galpin X OC)
Rhea Addams, daughter of the elusive Ophelia Addams and cousin to Wednesday, arrives at Nevermore Academy with a past shrouded in unanswered questions. Raised by her father after her mother's disappearance, Rhea carries not only the weight of her Addams heritage but also the rare ability to bend shadows to her will, a gift inherited from his outcast bloodline. Alongside her raven visions, cryptic glimpses of death and omens, her powers set her apart, even in a school filled with the strange and supernatural. As she settles into life at Nevermore, Rhea finds herself balancing her school life with the allure of mysteries far darker than she imagined. Drawn to the charm of Tyler Galpin, the local barista who seems to understand her outsider's heart, Rhea becomes entangled in a dangerous connection. But beneath his disarming smile lies a monstrous truth, one that threatens to consume them both and pull her deeper into the shadows than she ever intended to go.Complete
Nothing but Trouble
When your younger brother Rowan is brutally murdered you team up with none other than Wednesday Addams to solve the case behind it. But are you just a prime witness? Or is Wednesday starting to take a liking to you? Is Tyler just your friend? Or is he something more? Read to find out.....Complete
TOXIC TILL THE END| WEDNESDAY x TYLER Weyler
(This story is semi-canon compliant. This means you will see some things that differ from what happened in the show but still make sense for the general storyline as told in it. Hope you enjoy!) They called him a monster. She called him a warning. But when fate throws them back together, Wednesday Addams discovers that monsters are never simple. Tyler Galpin was supposed to be locked away, buried with the sins of his Hyde bloodline. Yet he walks the shadows again, broken, dangerous, and tethered to her in ways she refuses to admit. Every step he takes is a reminder of the kiss that shouldn't have happened, and every secret he carries drags them closer to truths that could unravel both of their worlds. Haunted by visions, hunted by family legacies, and stalked by enemies that wear familiar faces, Wednesday must decide: Is he the boy who betrayed her...or the only one who can save her? Darkness binds them. Desire tempts them. And in Jericho, nothing stays buried for long.Complete
BITE THE HAND : TYLER GALPIN X OC
COMPLETED UNTIL SEASON 3 Samantha Parker had always felt broken. She'd blame her anger on her deadbeat father or the bullying she went through it was better than the truth. She was a black hole of time and energy just sucking it all up. She never felt like the people around her until she met Tyler Galpin. They were both skipping class the day they met. He quickly became the only person who Sam felt actually seen by. But peace never really lasted long in Jericho. When Tyler starts pulling away and animal attacks sweep through town, Sam knows something's wrong. Then comes Outreach Day, and a brutal fight changes everything. Tyler is sent away, and Sam is left clinging to what little stability she has left. Now he's back, calmer, different. But just as things start to feel normal again a new girl named Wednesday Addams arrives and with her chaos. And Sam's world it's about to shatter all over again. COVER BY : @purpletulips04Complete
After the defeat of Laurel Gates and Joseph Crackstone, life returns to normal. For everyone, except Wednesday Addams. She can't stop thinking about him. After everything they went through, Tyler couldn't be a villain, right? The last thing he said before being carted away still rang in her ears. "I meant every word that day." The feelings she had for him were real. Maybe the real Tyler was still in there somewhere. She had to find out.. A new threat has emerged within the of bounds Nevermore, new bodies emerging and the ever growing threat of ravens on the horizon. Wednesday may be reuniting with Tyler sooner than she thinks. Welcome back to my stories everyone! I know it's been sometime, but with the release of Wednesday Season 2, I figured it was time to put my writing hands back to work! I hope you all enjoy as much as I enjoy making these stories for you all❤️
More detailsContent Guidelines