The Familiar Face✅

The Familiar Face✅

  • WpView
    Reads 1,475
  • WpVote
    Votes 17
  • WpPart
    Parts 19
WpMetadataReadOngoing1h 20m
WpMetadataNoticeLast published Fri, Oct 24, 2025
Liv Foster and Noah Fisher were the kind of childhood friends who could finish each other's sentences and steal fries off each other's plates without asking. Summers meant baseball dirt under Noah's nails, sunburn on Liv's shoulders, and some kind of unspoken promise that they'd always be in each other's orbit. Cut to college-new freedom, same heartbeat-and somewhere between study sessions and late-night drives, friendship twisted into something heavier. They fell, hard. Until Noah did the one thing Liv thought he never would: he cheated. No drama explosion, no cinematic screaming. Just quiet devastation. She walked away and built walls out of professionalism and caffeine. Years later, Liv gets an email that looks like the universe playing a cruel joke: she's just been offered a job as assistant to the new athletic director for the Party Animals. The same chaotic rival team that loves glitter, pranks, and unhinged celebrations. The same team where Noah Fisher-number 12, golden-boy outfielder, heartbreak incarnate-now plays. Liv walks into that stadium like she owns her composure. Noah sees her for the first time in years, and every apology he rehearsed evaporates. Their dynamic turns into this tightrope walk between old habits and unresolved tension. He tries humor, she gives him silence. He makes a catch mid-game, and she refuses to look impressed. But rivalry has a strange way of making sparks dangerous again. Forced to collaborate for charity events, media shoots, and player discipline reports (because Noah definitely pulls pranks that end up on TikTok), they start peeling back the layers-resentment, guilt, that stupid old warmth that never really died. It's friends to lovers to strangers to lovers again, but this time older, warier, and more real. The question isn't whether they'll fall again-it's whether they can trust each other not to break what's already been rebuilt.
All Rights Reserved
#10
bananaball
WpChevronRight
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
Illustration

You may also like

  • Scored
  • The Bad Boy Falling In Love
  • 𝐂𝐄𝐂𝐈𝐋𝐈𝐀 | ✔️
  • Book 4 Of The Playlist Series: We Hug Now✅
  • The Bad Boy and Me
  • the coaches sister
  • Running Back To You ( Noah Fisher x Reader )✅
  • Where We Left Off ( Noah fisher x Reader ) ✅
Scored

Kaydence was just trying to join a hockey league that looked down on her for being a girl when she met Noah. Noah was a player on an opposing team then her boyfriend and made it very clear he didn't like how she was spoken too. Kaydence has to decide between the boys while also trying to prove her worth to stay on the team. "It's too hard to write the truth. So I'll write about who you see me as. Maybe one day I'll come to terms with being the villain, when I was just your victim" *Author's note I am dyslexic and also typing this on a phone. So if there are typos you can leave a comment at the typo and I will get to it. Or I will later go back and edit chapters in the future

More details
WpActionLinkContent Guidelines