Since That Day {Creepypastas}

Toby joins as a new proxy of Slenderman. Right away, Jeff hates him and plots to kill him, leaving him in a bear's cave. Toby comes out alive (obviously) and he follows a stranger named Zalgo to another part of the woods. Jeff and Slenderman try to rescue him, but Slenderman gets captured by Zalgo. It's up to Jeff to try and save Toby with the others, but when Toby is rescued, another problem arises. Along the way, the creepypastas find new people and uncovers someone's past. And Jeff? He's thinking differently about Toby.

Sorry about the cover I used my finger to draw it.