Mistaken Hearts
- Reads 2
- Votes 0
- Parts 2
They say love heals-but for Ava and Avery, love only leaves scars.
Twin sisters bound by blood yet divided by secrets, envy, and the haunting shadow of a man who couldn't tell them apart.
Ava-the quiet one, the giver, the dreamer-has spent her whole life fading into Avery's light. But when a tragic twist binds their fates to the same man, the line between love and hate begins to blur.
One mistaken moment.
One betrayal too deep to forgive.
And one heart that may never recover.
In a world where beauty defines worth and love demands pain, Mistaken Hearts is a story of shattered trust, twisted affection, and the desperate search for who you are when everyone has already decided for you.
All Rights Reserved
#60
psychologicalromance
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
When Love Finds Its Way Back
When Liam Carter returns to the small town he once called home, whispers stir and old memories resurface-especially for Ava Knight, the woman he left behind. Years have passed, but the spark between them never truly faded. Ava, now rooted in the life she rebuilt without him, is torn when Liam walks back into her world with that familiar smile and a heart full of apologies. But Liam didn't come back just for love. He's carrying secrets-ones that could shatter the fragile hope he's reigniting in Ava. As the truth comes to light, the pain is undeniable. Trust is broken, hearts are bruised, and Ava is left questioning everything she thought she knew about the man who once held her heart. Still, deep down, she sees the man he can be-the man she knows he wants to become. And maybe, just maybe, love deserves a second chance. A story of forgiveness, redemption, and the kind of love that refuses to give up-Even When It Hurts.Complete
Shattered Vows, Stolen Hearts
Layla and Olivia's friendship is put to the ultimate test when ambition, neglect, and betrayal unravel their lives. As Layla becomes obsessed with proving herself as her father's heir, she pushes away her husband, Spencer. Only to unwittingly bring him closer to her best friend, Olivia. One night of weakness sparks a scandal that shatters their friendships, relationships, and reputations. When Layla discovered them, her fury destroyed Olivia's engagement with NFL star Darnell. But revenge offers no solace, and Spencer ultimately reconnected with Olivia, forcing Layla to confront the bitter truth. Shattered Vows, Stolen Hearts is a gripping tale of betrayal, revenge, and the price of ambition, where love is tested and hearts are broken, but second chances emerge from the ashes. In a story of false accusations, fractured friendships, and unexpected love, Spencer and Olivia must navigate the ruins of what Layla destroyed, proving that the truth always finds a way.Complete
"Remnants ||
She thought she had already loved once and lost forever. The memories still cling to her like shadows-warm, painful, impossible to forget. But fate is cruelly kind. Two strangers under the same roof, two hearts quietly circling each other. He isn't the man she loved, yet he stirs feelings she promised she'd buried. Now she stands at the edge of choice: hold onto the remnants of a love that defined her, or risk everything on a future that might finally heal her.
Mirror Hearts
BUY NOW ON AMAZON https://a.co/d/1ufvD6z Mirror Hearts Two faces. One love. A truth that changes everything. Ethan Carter thought he knew his girlfriend-until the night her identical twin showed up on his doorstep, drenched from the rain and ready to shatter everything. Savannah Blake wasn't supposed to fall for Ethan. She was only helping her sister cover up a messy affair. But lies have a way of taking root, and what started as a deception turns into something heartbreakingly real. Now, caught in the wreckage of a relationship built on falsehoods, Ethan must face the past, the woman who betrayed him-and the one who stayed to rebuild what she never broke. In a story of twin identities, emotional scars, and love born in the most unexpected way, Mirror Hearts asks: Can love survive when the truth is the greatest betrayal of all?Complete
Say I'm Yours
She spent two decades waiting on Spencer James to open his eyes and see her, and her heart. That didn't work. Spencer is great at many things but cops out when it comes to love. He keeps himself sheltered to the world, hides his heart and affections, even if the object of that is begging him not to. He let her walk away, proving her time and efforts to be an loss and waste. She was tired of being unseen, and decided to move on, she needed to move on, because he was never going to love her the way she wanted, or needed. One single dance at an wedding gave her an new reality with an new guy, her best friend's brother, Chris. He's sweet, charming, sexy, emotionally and physically attentive, pretty much every girl's dream. She believed she got it right this time around. This way her heart would heal and mend from what was broken, and be happy again, or could she? But when hearts are on the line, there are just some things you just can't shake and are almost too impossible to walk away from. Love story with an AAU twist.Complete
Quiet Chaos
She was already his long before she knew it- and when she finally did, it was too late to run. - - - Ava Avery was never made for love. Malakai Kane never saw the point in it. But when their darkness collides, everything shifts. Doubt turns to fascination. Fascination to obsession. And somewhere between control and chaos, the lines start to blur. Who's the predator? Who's the prey? Who's saving who-if anyone still can? When love becomes the game... losing might be the only way to win.
Vitality (Vitality Series #1)
A violent passion. A dangerous bond. A nightmare that will change everything. To Ava, love is about as real as fairytales. But it might be that fairytales, myths, and magic have some truth to them after all - as well as the monsters that lie in the shadows. Or she could just be completely out of her mind. After a mental breakdown and a move to a new town, everything changes when Ava clashes with a stranger with eyes as black as midnight and a terrifying sinister air. Her wishes to feel something again become granted. But Ava soon learns that not only is he as cold as he is beautiful, but he brings something out of her, stronger than ever, like fuel to fire - something she's desperate to bury. He haunts her dreams and waking life, and staying away becomes harder than she could have ever imagined, risking her life, her humanity, and the people that she cares about. Not to mention the fate of the world. She's fighting for life. He's fighting for death. What does it take to live? What does it take to love?Complete
The Wrong One Right
"The Wrong One Right" She loved in silence. He chose someone else. But fate had a different plan. A story of unexpected love, unspoken pain, and the twist that changed everything. Sometimes... the wrong one is just the right one in disguise. Please it's my first story I hope you sport me and I hope you like it or if I did any mistake ... 🙏 but I really work hard ✍️
Lovers Endgame
Love. I was such a fool for falling in love. All it gave me was pain and suffering. -------------------- 6 years ago he broke my heart and left me all alone. Now he's back and he expects an explanation? Fuck him. My name is Ava Vitiello and I learned the truth about the world the hard way. People say love is complicated? You're wrong. Love is either endgame, or a destruction of everything you've ever dreamed of.Complete
Two Years Too Late
They were strangers bound by an arranged marriage neither of them wanted. She, a quiet dreamer who had secretly loved him for years. He, a pragmatic man who saw marriage as an obligation, not an emotion. For two years, they lived as roommates - her world revolving around him, and his life quietly orbiting her without realizing it. Until one night, a phone call could have changed everything - if only he had picked up. That night changed her. The woman who once waited for love now wanted freedom. But by the time he finally saw what she meant to him... she was already gone. And some mistakes take years to heal - even if love never really leaves.Complete
When Liam Carter returns to the small town he once called home, whispers stir and old memories resurface-especially for Ava Knight, the woman he left behind. Years have passed, but the spark between them never truly faded. Ava, now rooted in the life she rebuilt without him, is torn when Liam walks back into her world with that familiar smile and a heart full of apologies. But Liam didn't come back just for love. He's carrying secrets-ones that could shatter the fragile hope he's reigniting in Ava. As the truth comes to light, the pain is undeniable. Trust is broken, hearts are bruised, and Ava is left questioning everything she thought she knew about the man who once held her heart. Still, deep down, she sees the man he can be-the man she knows he wants to become. And maybe, just maybe, love deserves a second chance. A story of forgiveness, redemption, and the kind of love that refuses to give up-Even When It Hurts.
More detailsContent Guidelines