Incompatible // BFDI fic
- Reads 2,230
- Votes 76
- Parts 11
Complete Sun, Feb 22, 20262h 14m
The flame and the leaf who supposedly make up on the hang glider.
A crash completely flips their fate, as the impact seems to change Firey's mindset. He forgets Leafy, seeing her as a threat to his own reputation as she becomes a wanted criminal, acting indifferent like she was a stranger.
But was he always pretending?
[Takes place after BFDI 25]
//bfdi AU//
may contain graphic detail
plot holes/repetitive patterns
may have blood/vomit
headcannons
not perfect writing
dec 2025 edit: cover art has been updated
All Rights Reserved
#24
fireybfdi
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Brought Together by Music (2021 Version)
"Ah! Fire Boy!" Firey is a Senior in Object High. All his life he's been the semi popular kid. This changed once he started dating Puffball, as his popularity spiked even higher. But with popularity, comes consequences. And with consequences, comes disaster. Leafy is a Junior who's also attending Object high. She doesn't care about popularity, all she's wanted was true Friends. She knows that behind the mask of someone who is stuck up, is someone who is just afraid deep down on the inside. Firey and Leafy cross paths again this year, and instead of arguing and fighting, they instead talk things out, becoming friends, and maybe even more. Started - November 4th, 2019 Ended - April 22, 2021 Heavily inspired by - Irreplaceable, a Fireafy fic that I think is lost to time. If you are that writer, please republish the book it was peak Authors Note - This book is not perfect. A lot of it was written based on my experiences as well as dreams I wanted to come true during high school. A lot of chapters do not make sense and I wrote Firey and Leafy how I saw them back then.Complete
Obsessive Little Flame
this is my bfdi au! so basically what if Firey and Leafy went into TPOT and not in BFB!! But! Firey misses Leafy and become OBSESSIVE!! That's all! I don't want to spoiled the story even more! English is not my first language so I might be spelling or writing something wrong. So sorry about that! Also this has some ships in it but mostly fireafyComplete
What About Me...? A Fireafy Angst Story
"HEY! YOU LEFT YOUR-" Slam. The owner of the bar stared at the door, then back at the IDs. "Leafy A'Blaze..." A figure appeared behind him. "And a Firey A'Blaze. Weird combination for a married couple." "Don't judge. I'm not intervening. She is looking a little blue though... like... h i m. " "WE DON'T TALK ABOUT HIM!" "He's the one who actually left because of his insecurities, not my fault he murdered a ton of objects. At least he recovered them back before leaving." "JUST SHUT UP AND WATCH! FIRST MARRIAGE FIGHT OF THE WEEK!" Book One of several Imma make of this series.Complete
Dreams (A Fireafy Ship Story)
Firey and Leafy aren't the perfect couple by any means. Now, nobody's perfect, especially these 2. Firey is lovable, but he is quite impulsive and irresponsible. Leafy is cute, but she has a short temper and holds grudges. On their luxurious trip to Las Vegas, these issues are thrusted into the spotlight. Firey cant help but go to the casino and Leafy cant help but get furious at Firey. Flower and Lolipop tag along to try and fix things, but Lolipop is stressing over the heaping amount of creeps in Las Vegas. Will Flower help Lolipop? Will Firey fix his gambling addiction? Will Leafy fix her temper? Why not read and find out? STORY IS HUMANIZED!!!
Stranded
After 12 years of silence Leafy sends a letter to 13 of her friends, Taco, Needle, Golfball, Tennis Ball, Pin, Coiny, Match, Pencil, Bubble, Loser, Teardrop, Flower, and Firey. The letter is calm, yet ominous, and invites them to all expense payed Vacation to a resort in Yoyle Land. People are skeptical, but everyone takes the offer. But once they arrive, they can't leave. Leafy seems missing, and it seems totally obvious... They're stranded. (This story only contains hints of violence, and does involve major character death.)Complete
FREEKILLINGS (A BFDI FANFIC)
"So many eyes in a small space, and none of them saw the slaughter." February 1, 2026. Yoyle Needy. 5:23 PM Pin finally reaches her breaking point when Freesmart subjects her to public humiliation. Determined, she decides that Freesmart will be dismantled that very night, whatever the cost. Even if she has to make all the members disappear when there are thousands of eyes everywhere in an enclosed space. A single mistake can cost everything... #1 in yoylecity tag! #1 in needle tag! #1 in pencil tag! #2 in leafy tag! #4 in coinpin tag! #6 in match tag! "FreeKillings" is a fanfic written in the style of a visual novel and an RPG Maker video game, mostly inspired in the visual novel and RPG game called "Married in Red" by RachelDrawThis, Ekrix and Studio Investigrave. This story took a month to complete its first draft and takes place in a single location (Plus some flashbacks). It has a minimum duration of approximately 4-5 hours. None of the characters shown are my property; all rights belong to jacknjellify, creators of Battle for Dream Island.Complete
seasons. : a fireafy fic
[human au] Leafy, a college student, meets a trouble-making boy who wrecks havoc on her once simple life...Complete
I'm Accidentally in Love (Fireafy)
I'm getting bored of writing that zombie story so here's a Love Story and if you want more of the zombie story, then Call Me Maybe. I Swear this story is going to be pretty good just like the Shape of You. I'll make this Whenever, Wherever and you'll be quite Amazed with this story and there's probably going to be a few Photograph of things happening, this story is going to be Perfect. I need to stop with these song references, I just made 8 references like damn, wait change that, it's 9 with the title of this story but also technically 10 because there's two songs called Photograph. The characters are in high school and there's some random audition for some random love story and why? Because we need this story to be as cliché as possible. Firey wants to join 'cause he's got nothing better to do but then he finds out Leafy is also trying to audition and with the fact they encounter each other in a game, both are now Accidentally in Love. Is that cliché? In Human Form If this story was a movie, it would be rated PG-13, why? here's why: Mild swears (damn, crap) and mild romantic themes (Kissing and maybe some make out, who knows?) These ar
TPOT19C: Shattered Bonds
DISCLAIMER: this is book 2 of TPOT 19: Continued! The apocalypse is over. The contestants have been restored. The moon holds One in her eternal prison. For the first time in ages, the world feels... safe. But peace is fragile. Old wounds don't heal overnight. Book struggles to forgive Pencil. Firey watches Leafy fight to remember a life she's forgotten. FreeSmart isn't the same, its members drifting in directions no one expected. And when the algebraliens decide their godlike powers must be sealed away forever, one desperate choice threatens to shatter everything again. Hidden in the shadows, Pencil takes the unthinkable risk: stealing the Stellapris, freeing One, and hiding her from the world. Friendship, trust, and loyalty will be tested. Bonds will break. Some may never be repaired. Nobody becomes a monster all at once. They just keep choosing the wrong solution. Written by: Dolly Cover by: NOCTULLA _______ Battle For Dream Island: The Power of Two and its characters are owned by JacknJellify on YouTube.
(not my best work) Infection: A BFB Fanfiction
edit: hey. this fanfiction is very old and doesnt reflect my writing skills anymore. if youre interested, heres a link to one of my newer fanfictions! (trust me its way better) https://www.wattpad.com/story/347165902-colors-a-bfb-fanfiction What happened between the wait from BFB 12 to 13 remains a mystery to the outside world. Only the contestants know what happened... or at least two of them. No-one would have expected a virus outbreak among all of them. Firey and Leafy fought for their lives as the rest of them slithered through the shadows, coming up with plans to take them down and make the two become one of them. #1 In BFDIA - September 2nd 2019Complete![[DIA] The Flame and The Leaf](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/326432162-256-k62230.jpg)
[DIA] The Flame and The Leaf
(NOT HUMANIZED, It's an object heads type of AU) Firey and Leafy seem very close to each other despite the differences they have, and Leafy's weird behavior. How is that possible you ask? Well this story give you a little insight as to Leafy's backstory as well as how she and Firey met. [This story takes place in the same BFDI x II AU as A Black Hole living on Earth] (DISCLAIMER: None of the art used in this book is mine!)Complete
melodies of the heart: a fireafy fanfic
[Human AU] Leafy is enjoying a great life. She's in the last year of high school. Living with her best friend, doing well in school and living the life, until she meets a trouble making boy, Firey. But she can't get him out of her mind no matter how much she hates him. Even though he bombed her during her performance an left her at the side of the road.Complete
Be my Valentine (FIREAFY FANFIC)
10 years of age and up MATURE READERS as there is VIOLENCE (BLOOD & GORE THEMES) MILD ROMANCE (KISS AND MAKEOUT) Fireafy fanfic for you guys! It's about a Valentine's dance. The bfdi cast is in human form and Firey and Leafy become friends at the beginning of the 8th grade semester, and comes the first popular event of the term, the semi-formal v-day dance. I drew the cover. Enjoy the story! Plus Book 2 is already out, "We're still here."Complete
Haunting memories | BFDIA AU
Haunting Memories is a bfdia au!! There is shipping in this story like popular ships (CoinPin, Fireafy, Matchil, stuff like that!!) TW!! Book contains gore, cussing, deaths, and major suicide. (Everyone is a human in this book by the way!!) The main characters are Firey and Pin, (also Leafy) This AU is about Firey and Pin trying to figure out what happen to Leafy after Bfdia got canceled but after a while, things started taking a dark turn and there was more to Leafy then they thought!!!Complete
Wander
In a world of four elements, there was pure disharmony. Fire caused a war, causing the elements to separate and never be able to live peacefully again. Fast forward to now, where a young leaf struggling with her own inner problems, receives a whole new one because of a flame who was supposed to be dead long ago. Now, because of them, panic and racket has stirred up in every town and between every element. What will happen to the two? Will they ever be able to live peacefully with the trouble they've caused? And will they end up dead because of their mistakes? {NOT MY CHARACTERS, FROM A SHOW CALLED BFDI !! NOT HUMANIZED} first fanfic!! yay! sorry if the writing is kinda bad - - TW: CURSING MENTIONS OF DEATH SUICIDE MENTION VIOLENCE DEPRESSION ATTEMPTED MURDER ANGST SLIGHT SUGGESTIVE THEMES 100READS - 6/28/25 1K READS - 7/29/25 2K READS - 8/10/25 3K READS - 9/5/25 4K READS - 9/27/25 5K READS - 10/24/25 6K READS 11/16/25 7K READS -11/29/25 8K READS - 12/13/25 9K READS - 12/24/25 10K READS - 1/1/26 11K READS - 1/19/26 12K READS - 2/14/26 13K READS - 2/24/26 14K READS - 3/15/26
The Breaking and Fixing of Leafy
Firey and Leafy have their confrontation as they do in BFB 22: Who Stole Donut's Diary but this time, instead of apologizing, Leafy loses it and has an emotional breakdown when confronted, causing Firey to become aware of all of the trauma he caused Leafy and how much he wants her back. And he wants her back badly. Originally posted and made on Ao3, old chapters will published weekly, while new chapters will be roughly 1-2 times a month. We have also have a discord server! Come if you wanna chat! https://discord.gg/gXVDHQFCfs
alight. : a fireafy fic
[human au!] Leafy is falling apart without Firey, but she's still kind to everyone but herself. Firey is falling apart and going slightly insane. When will they realize they belong together?Complete
LOST FRIEND..? | FIREAFY
(not the best and it still looks fucking cringe to me, i don't wanna read it again lmao.. but i'm kinda proud of my 11-12 yr old self i guess :/👍) - Leafy & Firey were best friends for days or weeks (or a month) til BFDI 25 came (we all know how it goes) Firey saved Leafy from getting executed by the other contestants and apologized until everything became a blur.. things gone strange... Leafy stayed in Yoyleland and became a physco for months..but her kindness stays.. Firey seem forgotten someone he met in his past Firey has so many questions whos his friend back in BFDI but nobody wanted to answer it except a warning beyond the Field of Yoyleberries.. Til Firey took a step into the Fields of Yoyleberries, then someone seems to be lurking beyond those berries.. Then until, Firey met an unfamiliar object, but he find it looking familiar.. Did he knew this object or completely never knew..? Was that he's lost friend or forever never knew..? ~ ▪ discontinued! ▪ old & cringy af ▪ warning: strong languages ▪ bfdi/bfb belongs to jacknjellify released: 09.04.19 ended: 04.23.20Complete
bloom. : a fireafy fic
[human au!] After getting back together with Firey, Leafy's secret depression has not gotten any better. Firey, frustrated with the secrets and lack of affection, makes some bad decisions to cope. When will they learn to communicate?Complete
A Lit Spark. (A BFDI Fireafy Angst Concept Story.)
An alternate timeline where Firey doesn't try to save Leafy when she gets in trouble for stealing Dream Island , but instead lets her receive her punishment. Since there was no talk, Leafy thinks Firey is out for her. She spends her days alone in the harshly cold place called, "Yoyleland." She develops survival skills and in the process becomes a person (or leaf) she never wanted to be. Will she ever learn to trust him again? (P.S.- This does become romantic at some points, but isn't sexual.)Complete
"Ah! Fire Boy!" Firey is a Senior in Object High. All his life he's been the semi popular kid. This changed once he started dating Puffball, as his popularity spiked even higher. But with popularity, comes consequences. And with consequences, comes disaster. Leafy is a Junior who's also attending Object high. She doesn't care about popularity, all she's wanted was true Friends. She knows that behind the mask of someone who is stuck up, is someone who is just afraid deep down on the inside. Firey and Leafy cross paths again this year, and instead of arguing and fighting, they instead talk things out, becoming friends, and maybe even more. Started - November 4th, 2019 Ended - April 22, 2021 Heavily inspired by - Irreplaceable, a Fireafy fic that I think is lost to time. If you are that writer, please republish the book it was peak Authors Note - This book is not perfect. A lot of it was written based on my experiences as well as dreams I wanted to come true during high school. A lot of chapters do not make sense and I wrote Firey and Leafy how I saw them back then.
More detailsContent Guidelines