"She grew up needing Abbott. Now Abbott needs her."
•••
Abbott Elementary | Melissa Schemmenti x OC | Starting at season 2
•••
Samantha 'Sam' Sinclair never imagined she'd walk back through the doors of Abbott Elementary-not as a student, but as a teacher. At twenty-six, life has carried her through a turbulent childhood, a late-finished degree, and years of drifting between jobs, all while holding onto the memory of the one person who saw her when no one else did: her kindergarten teacher, Barbara Howard.
When a sudden maternity leave creates an unexpected vacancy, Sam steps in as a substitute for a first-grade class, determined to give her students the same sense of safety and hope that once carried her. But returning to Abbott is more than just a professional choice-it's a collision of past and present. In the familiar hallways, amidst the soft hum of focused classrooms and the chaos of seasoned teachers, Sam is seen again in ways she thought she'd long forgotten.
As she navigates the vibrant, unpredictable world of public education, Sam encounters the big-hearted, eccentric staff: the charmingly chaotic Ava, the skeptical but caring Gregory, the sharp-witted Melissa, and, of course, Barbara, whose quiet pride and steady guidance anchor her. Between classroom crises, hallway dramas, and the quiet victories of students who grow under her care, Sam discovers that home is not just a place, but the people who remember and believe in you.
Back to Abbott is a heartwarming, witty, and deeply human story about the ties that shape us, the classrooms that hold us, and the courage it takes to return to the place where it all began.
•••
Content Warning: Childhood abuse, Domestic violence, Parental neglect, Emotional abuse, PTSD, Trauma, Bullying, Substance issues, Crime, Jail, Medical complications, Anxiety, Loss, Grief, Emotional manipulation, Mild romantic/sexual themes, School-related chaos, SMUT
Ava Coleman has always been larger than life - tall, magnetic, and in control of every room she walks into. As the principal of Abbott Elementary, she hides her insecurities behind confidence and charm, keeping everyone - especially her overly eager teacher Janine Teagues - at arm's length.
Janine has always been sure of herself. She loves her students, her work, and the small routines that keep her world in order. But when late nights of planning and shared victories bring her closer to Ava, something shifts. Beneath Ava's wit and sharp edges, Janine starts to see a woman capable of tenderness. Beneath Janine's sunny optimism, Ava discovers a strength she never expected to crave.
The line between admiration and desire begins to blur, and both women are forced to confront what their hearts have been whispering all along. For Ava, love means risking vulnerability; for Janine, it means stepping beyond every label she's ever known.
When Desire Calls is a slow-burn lesbian romance filled with tension, humor, and the dangerous beauty of falling for the one person you were never supposed to want.