The Missing Girl
- Reads 49
- Votes 10
- Parts 5
MatureComplete Mon, Nov 10, 202535m
Twelve years ago, Mikayla Murray vanished from her quiet Indiana town, leaving her family in a web of grief and unanswered questions. The Murrays have never stopped searching, clinging to faded photos and fading hope in their secluded home on the edge of endless fields.
Then, one autumn evening, a young woman appears at their door, blonde hair, blue eyes, and a smile that could be Mikayla's twin. She's weary, guarded, and claims to be the girl they've mourned for over a decade. Linda, the devoted mother, welcomes her with tears. Paul, the stoic father, watches with quiet suspicion. And James, the younger brother who's grown up in her shadow, can't shake the feeling that something's off.
As the stranger settles into Mikayla's old life, cracks begin to form in the family's fragile peace. Whispers of the past echo through the halls, secrets buried deep, loyalties tested, and truths that no one wants to face. Is this homecoming a miracle, or the start of something far more dangerous?
A tense psychological thriller exploring identity, family bonds, and the shadows we hide from ourselves. Perfect for fans of Gone Girl, The Girl on the Train and The Silent Patient.
Tropes: Lookalike mystery, unreliable perspectives, slow-burn suspense, family drama.
Content Warnings: Violence, abuse, themes of trauma and deception.
Dive in if you dare-what if the missing girl was never really gone?
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Amongst the worst
This story follows 5 siblings living with their aunt and uncle after being abandoned by their parents. Clueless about the real world around them and who they really are, they continue training by order of their father who is now gone. What happens when they are sent to the train among killers like them? What happens when they figure out their lives aren't so ordinary after all? Can they handle the burden of having one of the most feared people in the world as their father, or will they keep it for only them to know? Will they become stronger or will their world come crashing down? What happens when a 15 year old Rose meets someone she never intended to? Why is his face so familiar? A boy. With a face of an angel but the mind and soul of a devil. The Tyler Blake. Will she be able to resist his charms or will he figure out who she really is or will he found out who she really is first?Complete
Rivals?
Love. Love is such a strong word. Love is something you feel for someone you truly care about. Right? So is love ever possible to feel for someone that you hated so much for so long? Mikayla is a junior at Bristol High School in Bristol, Tennesee. She's sixteen, 5'4, plays softball and volleyball, and has a great and positive personality. However, her family has a lot of issues. Her dad is a depressed alcoholic who likes to take his anger out on Mikayla and her twin brother, Joey. Mikayla thinks sex and relationships are stupid. It's high school. She wants to lay back and be mature. However, will that ever change? I mean, high school is always rough and deceiving, right? Mikayla is an excellent student and makes amazing grades. However, she has competition. Daniel is Mikayla's competition. He plays quarterback on their school's football team. Typical, right? Well, Mikayla and Daniel have competed against each other for years. Daniel likes to push Mikayla down and make her feel like he's superior and better. Daniel is six-foot-something and handsome. He could pull any girl he wanted, however, he remains single. Is it his terrible personality? Or does he like being single? This story is about teenage love and the problems that you can encounter in high school. Mikayla and Daniel, head to-head, all the time. However, who will win overall? Who will be the bigger person and try to drop all of their immaturity and stupidity? TW and MATURITY WARNING: Drug use, SH, reference to sex, strong language throughout the story, depression, and family trauma.Complete
The Princess & Her Four Knights
She thought she was an only child. She thought her mom's bedtime stories were just stories. She was wrong about everything. After a crash that kills her mother and steals her voice, 14-year-old Sofia wakes up in a hospital-mute, alone, and staring into the eyes of four older brothers who thought she died as a baby. Her name was a lie. Her life was a cover. And now... the truth could kill them all. The bedtime stories her mother once whispered? They were coded warnings. Clues to a dark legacy tied to powerful enemies-and the dangerous game Sofia and her brothers were born into. Now, silence is her weapon. Family is her only shield. And trust? A luxury they can't afford. To survive, Sofia must decode her mother's secrets, stay one step ahead of those who want her gone-and write a new ending. Because the old one? Was never hers. Found family. Fierce brothers. Deadly secrets. Welcome to the game. 📖 Bonus content & exclusive chapters: https://substack.com/@theprincessher4knightsComplete
Black Mercy
Evelyn was kidnapped at the age of six, disappearing from her family's life as if she had never existed. Years passed, and the search continued... but Evelyn wasn't killed. She escaped, falling into the hands of a strange man, who gave her life... but in a different form. Raised on coldness, silence, discipline, and a deadly instinct. She calls him "Dad," his son "Big Brother"-they are the only ones she knows mercy for. Beyond that? A world where there's no room for weakness. But she's not who they think she is. She's the daughter of a buried past, and the twin of her missing half is still alive... waiting for her without knowing her. When Evelyn returns, no one knows who she is. No one recognizes her cold eyes, her hard steps, the mercy that has turned black. Can someone raised in the shadows return to the light? Or do some hearts... never heal?Complete
When The Light Finds Us
To the best of her knowledge, no one Casey Owen's age had had life serve them a series of disaster-flavoured cliches in one blow. Trauma? Check Dead twin? Check Depression? Check Intense guilt and crippling expectations from family? Triple check A year after Amber's death, Casey is trying, really trying, to move on. But when a familiar shadow from her past resurfaces, threatening to rip open old wounds, she realizes that grief wasn't the only thing haunting her. Someone knows what happened that night... and they'll do anything to keep the truth buried. As fragments of memory begin to surface, Casey is forced to confront the dark edges of her past and the chilling possibility that Amber's death wasn't an accident. The closer she gets to the truth, the more dangerous her world becomes. Because in Kensbury, the past doesn't stay quiet. And neither do the people who want you silenced.
Whispers Beneath the Willow
When two girls disappear from Sanderwood Valley, the whole town goes into panic mode. For Laine, it's worse-because the second girl is her twin sister, Lana. The one everyone loved. The one she could never quite measure up to. The police have no leads. The town wants to forget. But Laine refuses to move on. Armed with her curiosity and her determination to become a detective someday, she starts her own investigation. What she finds isn't what she expected. Lies. Secrets. People she trusted with blood on their hands. Beneath the whispers, the lies, and the shadow of the willow tree where they used to meet, Laine begins to see that everyone is hiding something. And some people will do anything to keep their secrets buried.
intrepidity
Aurora's life had always been about survival, each day a quiet battle against fear and pain. When her stepfather was finally arrested, she thought the fight was over. But leaving one dangerous world meant stepping into another-one she didn't fully understand. Now, she's living with seven older brothers she barely knows, their lives a tangle of secrets and shadows they never speak of. Their house is loud, protective, and filled with rules she's afraid to break. For Aurora, it's a new kind of survival. For her brothers, it's a chance to keep her safe-no matter what it takes.Complete
⟡ 𝓑𝓮𝓱𝓲𝓷𝓭 𝓒𝓵𝓸𝓼𝓮𝓭 𝓓𝓸𝓸𝓻𝓼 ⟡
In a quiet town wrapped in fog and secrets, something ancient stirs beneath the surface. When new blood enters a neighborhood already weighed down by silence, curiosity can become dangerous. Some doors are locked for a reason... and some truths are meant to stay buried. But for April, once she knocks-there's no turning back. ⟡𖤐⟡✧⟡𖤐⟡✧⟡𖤐⟡✧ April had always been curious about the new boy named Gregory, who had moved into her neighborhood. He was quiet, always alone, with a stare that seemed too heavy for someone his age. Rumors began to spread-whispers of screams in the night and strange symbols drawn in red near the woods. Due to him not showing up to school regularly and having been acting quite strange, April's curiosity turned into obsession. Her dreams became disturbed, filled with flickering shadows and haunting whispers that spoke his name. Unexplained disappearances and brutal attacks from a mysterious creature started happening. Victims were found torn apart-no trace of the attacker, only claw marks and eerie silence. And April happened to be stalked by something lurking through the shadows. She soon discovers and is surprised to see who it is. A face she trusted. Having a rare condition... one hidden for generations. To consume blood flesh. ⟡𖤐⟡✧⟡𖤐⟡✧⟡𖤐⟡✧ ⚠ Content Warning: strong language, blood/gore, graphic violence, alcohol use, attempt of suicide, SA, and frightening scenes ⚠ · ┈┈┈┈┈┈ · ꕥ · ┈┈┈┈┈┈ · This story has a playlist **Listen on Spotify**Complete
This story follows 5 siblings living with their aunt and uncle after being abandoned by their parents. Clueless about the real world around them and who they really are, they continue training by order of their father who is now gone. What happens when they are sent to the train among killers like them? What happens when they figure out their lives aren't so ordinary after all? Can they handle the burden of having one of the most feared people in the world as their father, or will they keep it for only them to know? Will they become stronger or will their world come crashing down? What happens when a 15 year old Rose meets someone she never intended to? Why is his face so familiar? A boy. With a face of an angel but the mind and soul of a devil. The Tyler Blake. Will she be able to resist his charms or will he figure out who she really is or will he found out who she really is first?
More detailsContent Guidelines