The Missing Girl
- Reads 70
- Votes 10
- Parts 5
Twelve years ago, Mikayla Murray vanished from her quiet Indiana town, leaving her family in a web of grief and unanswered questions. The Murrays have never stopped searching, clinging to faded photos and fading hope in their secluded home on the edge of endless fields.
Then, one autumn evening, a young woman appears at their door, blonde hair, blue eyes, and a smile that could be Mikayla's twin. She's weary, guarded, and claims to be the girl they've mourned for over a decade. Linda, the devoted mother, welcomes her with tears. Paul, the stoic father, watches with quiet suspicion. And James, the younger brother who's grown up in her shadow, can't shake the feeling that something's off.
As the stranger settles into Mikayla's old life, cracks begin to form in the family's fragile peace. Whispers of the past echo through the halls, secrets buried deep, loyalties tested, and truths that no one wants to face. Is this homecoming a miracle, or the start of something far more dangerous?
A tense psychological thriller exploring identity, family bonds, and the shadows we hide from ourselves. Perfect for fans of Gone Girl, The Girl on the Train and The Silent Patient.
Tropes: Lookalike mystery, unreliable perspectives, slow-burn suspense, family drama.
Content Warnings: Violence, abuse, themes of trauma and deception.
Dive in if you dare-what if the missing girl was never really gone?
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Rivals?
Love. Love is such a strong word. Love is something you feel for someone you truly care about. Right? So is love ever possible to feel for someone that you hated so much for so long? Mikayla is a junior at Bristol High School in Bristol, Tennesee. She's sixteen, 5'4, plays softball and volleyball, and has a great and positive personality. However, her family has a lot of issues. Her dad is a depressed alcoholic who likes to take his anger out on Mikayla and her twin brother, Joey. Mikayla thinks sex and relationships are stupid. It's high school. She wants to lay back and be mature. However, will that ever change? I mean, high school is always rough and deceiving, right? Mikayla is an excellent student and makes amazing grades. However, she has competition. Daniel is Mikayla's competition. He plays quarterback on their school's football team. Typical, right? Well, Mikayla and Daniel have competed against each other for years. Daniel likes to push Mikayla down and make her feel like he's superior and better. Daniel is six-foot-something and handsome. He could pull any girl he wanted, however, he remains single. Is it his terrible personality? Or does he like being single? This story is about teenage love and the problems that you can encounter in high school. Mikayla and Daniel, head to-head, all the time. However, who will win overall? Who will be the bigger person and try to drop all of their immaturity and stupidity? TW and MATURITY WARNING: Drug use, SH, reference to sex, strong language throughout the story, depression, and family trauma.Complete
When The Light Finds Us
To the best of her knowledge, no one Casey Owen's age had had life serve them a series of disaster-flavoured cliches in one blow. Trauma? Check Dead twin? Check Depression? Check Intense guilt and crippling expectations from family? Triple check A year after Amber's death, Casey is trying, really trying, to move on. But when a familiar shadow from her past resurfaces, threatening to rip open old wounds, she realizes that grief wasn't the only thing haunting her. Someone knows what happened that night... and they'll do anything to keep the truth buried. As fragments of memory begin to surface, Casey is forced to confront the dark edges of her past and the chilling possibility that Amber's death wasn't an accident. The closer she gets to the truth, the more dangerous her world becomes. Because in Kensbury, the past doesn't stay quiet. And neither do the people who want you silenced.
The Unseen Witness
"You think I don't care about you?" he murmurs. "You think I don't feel anything?" "I-Noel-" His voice is low enough to weaken me. When her best friend disappears without a trace, Lily arrives at college carrying more questions than answers. Raised by former detectives, she knows one rule: nothing vanishes without reason. What she doesn't expect is him - charming, guarded, and always one step ahead of the truth. As clues surface and feelings deepen, she begins to realize the person she's falling for may be the one who knows exactly what happened to her best friend. Some secrets are buried. Others are sleeping beside you. #1 in Romeo 02/26/26 #6 in mystery
Whispers Beneath the Willow
When two girls disappear from Sanderwood Valley, the whole town goes into panic mode. For Laine, it's worse-because the second girl is her twin sister, Lana. The one everyone loved. The one she could never quite measure up to. The police have no leads. The town wants to forget. But Laine refuses to move on. Armed with her curiosity and her determination to become a detective someday, she starts her own investigation. What she finds isn't what she expected. Lies. Secrets. People she trusted with blood on their hands. Beneath the whispers, the lies, and the shadow of the willow tree where they used to meet, Laine begins to see that everyone is hiding something. And some people will do anything to keep their secrets buried.
Unravelling
Lily is happy with her life. She has a unique family that she can rely on as well as four great friends who support her - and vice versa. She doesn't mind school, loves to play soccer in her spare time and cannot say no to sweets. For as long as she can remember, it has always been just her and her brothers. There are no parents in the picture. The 12-year-old has never bothered to find out what actually happened to them and she has never even met them. Her oldest brother is her and the other minors' guardian. This is how it has always been, and Lily likes it that way. However, something seems to be changing. Three of her brothers suddenly move back home, or at least make plans to do so. The older ones start to act secretive and they appear more preoccupied than usual. Certain things don't add up anymore. Lily's curiosity is piqued. What is going on with her family? What are her oldest brothers hiding from her? Have they been lying to her? Who are her parents? And where are they? Join Lily on a journey that will turn her life upside down and that will put everything into a new perspective, as things slowly start to unravel.Complete
Left Behind
Be careful what you ask for. When digging deep, you may uncover bodies. Maisie's life has been falling apart since her older sister went missing years ago without a trace. With a dead father and a mentally unstable mother, the teenage girl has been left in the care of her older brothers. When she bumps into hidden boxes in the attic, a web of lies and secrets unravel between her fingers. Pieces of what happened to her sister wait to be put together. And the complete puzzle might give Maisie more answers than she bargained for. Not just a mystery, a story about the ties that bind a family and have the power to break one. [extended summary inside] [contain mature themes] #1 littlesister #1dysfunctionalfamily
Amongst the worst
This story follows 5 siblings living with their aunt and uncle after being abandoned by their parents. Clueless about the real world around them and who they really are, they continue training by order of their father who is now gone. What happens when they are sent to the train among killers like them? What happens when they figure out their lives aren't so ordinary after all? Can they handle the burden of having one of the most feared people in the world as their father, or will they keep it for only them to know? Will they become stronger or will their world come crashing down? What happens when a 15 year old Rose meets someone she never intended to? Why is his face so familiar? A boy. With a face of an angel but the mind and soul of a devil. The Tyler Blake. Will she be able to resist his charms or will he figure out who she really is or will he found out who she really is first?Complete
Killer Instinct
Three months ago, four kids were run off the road by a drunk driver and pronounced dead at the scene, leaving their families to grieve and wonder why accidents had to happen. The four left behind families, and namely, five specific siblings: all seniors in high school but not all similar. The five don't interact too often, but a common thought brings them together: what if their siblings had been murdered? As they begin to work together to find out who killed their older siblings, the five begin to realize that they might be getting in over their heads--for the four families have secrets that intertwine them beyond what anyone could have imagined, and the five teens find themselves in possession of the very secrets that may have got their siblings killed in the first place.Complete
No way out
When you see it, you are in too deep Two years and a half ago, Kate lost her sister. Six months laters, she became an orphan. And since then, in the care of her older brothers, she has been running from the pain and memories. Only now, Kate has no choice but to confront her past. There are doubtful circumstances around her sister's death and odd questions sorrounding her parents' passing, not to mention secrets her older brothers aren't willing to share--but someone is. The teen girl starts receiving sliver of evidence and she can't help but continue searching for the answers, without realizing her actions are about to spark a fire that will turn everything she knows--or think she does--into ashes. ---- Family drama mixed with nail bitting mystery and bittersweet coming of age. A tale of love and loss, sins and redemption, despair and hope [extended summary inside] [contains mature themes]
The Vanishing Cheerleaders
At Willow Creek High, blonde, blue-eyed cheerleaders are disappearing without a trace. The once vibrant school is now clouded with fear and uncertainty. For 21-year-old Emily Carter, the disappearances hit close to home-her younger sister, Ashley, was the latest victim. Determined to uncover the truth, Emily takes matters into her own hands. She dyes her naturally brunette hair blonde and goes undercover, joining the cheer squad to find out what really happened to her sister. Emily quickly notices something sinister: the school's bad boy, Cole Matthews, seems unusually interested in her. With his brooding looks and dangerous reputation, Cole has always given Emily the creeps, but now he's watching her more than ever. As he persistently asks her out, Emily's suspicions grow. But when her older brother, Jake, a 25-year-old police officer, suggests she take the risk and go on the date-armed with a hidden tracker-Emily agrees. What begins as a simple date soon turns into a nightmarish ordeal as Cole drives her deep into the woods. At a secluded cabin, Emily uncovers the horrifying truth: Cole has been abducting and murdering cheerleaders, including her sister. With her brother and the police closing in, Emily must use every ounce of strength and courage to survive the night and bring Cole to justice. But the scars of what she uncovers may never heal.Complete
Love. Love is such a strong word. Love is something you feel for someone you truly care about. Right? So is love ever possible to feel for someone that you hated so much for so long? Mikayla is a junior at Bristol High School in Bristol, Tennesee. She's sixteen, 5'4, plays softball and volleyball, and has a great and positive personality. However, her family has a lot of issues. Her dad is a depressed alcoholic who likes to take his anger out on Mikayla and her twin brother, Joey. Mikayla thinks sex and relationships are stupid. It's high school. She wants to lay back and be mature. However, will that ever change? I mean, high school is always rough and deceiving, right? Mikayla is an excellent student and makes amazing grades. However, she has competition. Daniel is Mikayla's competition. He plays quarterback on their school's football team. Typical, right? Well, Mikayla and Daniel have competed against each other for years. Daniel likes to push Mikayla down and make her feel like he's superior and better. Daniel is six-foot-something and handsome. He could pull any girl he wanted, however, he remains single. Is it his terrible personality? Or does he like being single? This story is about teenage love and the problems that you can encounter in high school. Mikayla and Daniel, head to-head, all the time. However, who will win overall? Who will be the bigger person and try to drop all of their immaturity and stupidity? TW and MATURITY WARNING: Drug use, SH, reference to sex, strong language throughout the story, depression, and family trauma.
More detailsContent Guidelines