Lost in Time

Back when he was first made, Shadow Milk Cookie, a while after he came out of the oven, he stumbles upon a cookie called Nilly Cookie. As soon as Shadow Milk see's Nilly's heterochrome yellow and blue eyes, he gets lost in them. They become close friends (aka pining for each other) till the day Nilly finally dies, and Shadow Milk is left alone.

Thousands of years later, he meets another cookie with the same heterochrome yellow and blue eyes. The problem, he doesn't remember were he knows those eyes from, but they still steal his breath.

Pure Vanilla Cookie has had a problem sense he was created by the witches, he feels like he's not remembering something truly important. The only thing he can remember is the heterochrome eyes of light blue and dark blue and how they stole his breath.

When he enters Beast Yeast with the others, he suddenly feels like his head is gonna split apart. Sceans that he doesn't remember happening start to flash through his mind. He doesn't know why, but he feels like he's been there before. And when he see's Shadow Milks eyes all his memerys of when he was Nilly Cookie come flooding back.

Will Shadow Milk gain his memerys back of the cookie who stole his breath? Or will Pure Vanilla end up crumbling in greif due to Shadow Milk not rembering?