Jonathans' Second Chance

When Azazel sent Jonathan back to the mortal plain, he missed the mark as to which dimension Jonathan was supposed to be in.

Instead of showing up in the Shadow Dimension, where his sister and the rest of the TMI gang are, Jonathan shows up in the real world. He appears in a small town, named Paraparaumu, in the country of New Zealand.

Jonathans' luck turns when he's found by a young, genderfluid person, named Charlie, who's only a couple of months away from 20, not all that much older than him.

Charlie, being a Shadowhunters fan, and having recently lost her entire human family, with only his dog, named Bubbles, takes Jonathan in without hesitation.

She helps Jonathan realise that what happened to him wasn't normal or right, and brings him out of his shell slowly.

Jonathan and Charlie form a close relationship, especially after Charlie shows Jonathan the Shadowhunters TV series, and how his life would've turned out, had Azazel hit the mark.

When Lilith comes to check on her son, she finds he has a very loyal protector now. When she recognizes Charlie as one of the children her and Lucifer routinely watch over, and have done since Charlie was a child.

Then, when the TMI gang comes to see Jonathan, Charlie makes it clear that Jonathan will not be leaving unless he wants too.

Read to find out how Jonathans' relationship with Charlie will help his relationship with his sister, her boyfriend, Alec and Izzy.

Started: 31/03/2026
Finished: 05/04/2026