His Claim, Her Cage | Gator & Katie | Book One
- Reads 16,796
- Votes 673
- Parts 91
MatureComplete Sat, Jun 20, 202619h 42m
When your father dies owing Roy Tillman more money than you could ever repay, the debt doesn't disappear.
It transfers.
Roy decides you'll be sold to one of his men.
Before anyone else can claim you, Gator Tillman does.
Now you belong to him.
Forced to live at the ranch as his property, you believe you're trapped with a man just as cruel as the others... but the longer you stay, the more you begin to notice something doesn't add up.
Because Gator watches you too closely.
Stops things before they happen.
And treats you worst when Roy is looking.
Best when he isn't.
He says you're his.
But he never touches you like you are.
And that might be the most dangerous thing of all.
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Delete Ya | Joe Keery
A year and a half after their lives took different turns, Julia and Joe are living in separate worlds: hers grounded in the routine of her New York bookstore, his swept up in filming projects across the globe. But when an unexpected reunion stirs up long-buried feelings, their paths slowly start to intertwine once more. **Sequel to The End of Beginning**
Joe Keery x Reader imagines
You are Joe Keery/Djo's Girlfriend, juggling your relationship, his music writing as Djo, and his busy schedule of filming. Not to forget you're a Pedatric Nurse who works with children, all while taking care of your welbeing and panic attacks, making sure Joe stays out of trouble with work when he's checking you're okay.
TEETH ⋆｡°✩ gator tillman
✮⋆˙ 𝘏𝘦𝘺 𝘋𝘦𝘱𝘶𝘵𝘺! 𝘚𝘩𝘰𝘸 𝘮𝘦 𝘶𝘳 𝘵𝘦𝘦𝘵𝘩! ˖.𖥔 ݁ ˖ ⊹ ࣪ ˖ Cassidy Halloway is the Mayor's daughter and Stark County's golden girl. But when she gets tangled up with Deputy Gator Tillman and the county's most gruesome serial killer to date Gator learns the Mayor's girl is anything but golden. ˖.𖥔 ݁ ˖ ⊹ ࣪ ˖ 𝐌𝐀𝐓𝐔𝐑𝐄 𝐂𝐎𝐍𝐓𝐄𝐍𝐓 ✮⋆˙ ⚠️ Proceed with caution. Story includes mentions of death, gore, drug use, mental illness, psychotic behavior, sex, alcohol, weed, age gap, and domestic violence. Reader discretion Is advised. Minors do not read. #1 in #fargo 3.30.26 #1 in #gatortillman 5.15.2026Complete
Notes Left Behind | Joe Keery
On a September morning in New York City, Lydia stops by her favorite coffee shop. A place of comfort, routine, and well-loved books. What begins as an ordinary journey to work when a brief exchange with a stranger turns into something quietly unforgettable. As mornings begin to blur into something more, Lydia discovers that some connections arrive quietly and unexpected, like a favorite book finding its way back into your hands. #1 in steveharrington 20/3/26 #1 in joe 13/4/26Complete
The Match | Joe Keery
One random night out in London never meant anything to anyone. But a year later, after finally getting accepted onto a dating app, you come across a familiar face who remembers you. What starts as easy conversations and late night phone calls, turns into months of growing closer from opposite sides of the world. You soon begin to wonder if a chance meeting from last summer was actually the start of something bigger.
Across The Street | Joe Keery
She grew up across the street from him. Joe was first crushes, porch lights, family parties, and everything Victoria never quite got over. Even when he left for college. Even when New York claimed him. Even when the world did too. Years later, Victoria is building a life through photography, art, and carefully controlled distance when she's invited on tour with Joe and his friends, but proximity has a way of exposing what time never erased. As old feelings collide with new realities, Victoria is forced to confront the hardest truth of all: loving someone for years doesn't mean they were ever yours.Complete
How the Bad Boy Breaks | Gator Tillman
Sophia Shepard has every reason to hate Gator Tillman. He's the reckless troublemaker who tore her family apart- at least, that's how she's always understood it. And Sophia has never forgiven him. While her brother left town, Sophia stayed behind to help her father keep the ranch running. She's built a life out of grit and routine, and she refuses to let Gator's smirks or lazy "Mornin', sweetheart" shake her. After all. Why would she fall for someone like him?
The Son of Sin | Gator Tillman
Maggie swore she'd never be like the girls who fell for Gator Tillman, the sheriff's rotten son. But hate burns close to desire, and when old wounds and buried truths resurface, Maggie finds herself caught in a web of betrayal, control, and the one man she grew up despising. **This story uses characters and references from Fargo S5, but the events don't explicitly follow the show.**
Memories Of You | Gator Tillman x Reader
After fleeing a controlling relationship, you return to the remote cabin your grandfather left you outside Fargo, hoping for a quiet fresh start. Instead, old memories begin resurfacing-along with Gator Tillman, the boy who once knew you better than anyone. As your past slowly unravels, it becomes clear that the life you left behind isn't done with you yet. Gator Tillman x ReaderComplete
Gator Tillman's Wildfire Girl
Wynn Wilder was born barefoot and brazen, raised in the dust of Tillman Ranch with fight in her fists and a fire in her heart. For most of her life, she was just the annoying, tagalong kid sister - Luke Wilder's little spitfire and Gator Tillman's favourite source of trouble. But time has teeth. And it changes everything. Now Wynn's grown, all sharp tongue and sweet curves - a singer with a voice that could bring a man to his knees. And Gator, her brother's best friend, the boy who used to shove frogs in her boots, is suddenly seeing her in a whole new light. A light he has no business stepping into. He's trying to be good. A badge on his chest. A last name to live down. And, a loyalty to Luke that he risks breaking, one stolen glance at a time. Because Gator went and fell for the one girl who's always been off-limits. Author's note: If you ever wondered what Gator Tillman might've looked like if he'd been raised with a little more love, and what kind of woman it would take to teach him gentle - this is for you. This is Gator and Roy Tillman reimagined, rewritten, and redeemed.Complete
A year and a half after their lives took different turns, Julia and Joe are living in separate worlds: hers grounded in the routine of her New York bookstore, his swept up in filming projects across the globe. But when an unexpected reunion stirs up long-buried feelings, their paths slowly start to intertwine once more. **Sequel to The End of Beginning**
More detailsContent Guidelines