I'm in Love With My Own Sins

Okay Sammy," Dean said sitting sown next to Sam, "any interesting cases?"
"No Dean," Sam huffed still scrolling through his computer feed, but then exclaims, "Dean look at this!"
Dean looks over Sam's shoulder to see an article from Chicago two days ago. It read:

Another Missing!
Tara Pope was found missing from her home two days ago. This is believed to be apart of a kidnapping scheme that started with the Willmette native band, Fall Out Boy, two years ago.

"Sam this is just another boring story," Dean complained, "leave that to the police."
"No Dean look closer," Sam huffs pointing below the paragraph.

They might not seemed linked but they are. The thing that links them is a strange green goo was dripping out of the bottom of the TV.

"Okay Sammy that seems really deep," Dean sarcastically says.
"So is that a yes on the case?" Sam asks.
"I guess so," Dean replies.
"Well lets get go the Impala!" Sam exclaimed.
They rushed over to a 1967 Chevy Impala. And begin their drive to the scene of the crime.

*Fall Out Boy/Supernatural Crossover*

Collaboration with @BodhiNewbill