One Time Thing

Amanda Rivers and Carley Benner have spent years hating each other. As star volleyball players and longtime rivals, every interaction between them turns into an argument, whether it's at school, practice, or during their annual team meetings. Amanda sees Carley as arrogant, cruel, and secretly homophobic, while Carley views Amanda as the one person who constantly threatens her need to be the best.

When both girls are unexpectedly chosen as team captains, they're forced to work together for the first time. Their rivalry only intensifies during practices, but beneath the insults and competition, something begins to shift. Amanda starts noticing sides of Carley she's never allowed herself to see, while Carley finds herself confused by feelings she can't explain or accept.

As pressure from school, family, relationships, and volleyball builds, the tension between them turns into something neither girl is prepared for. After Carley discovers her boyfriend cheating on her with one of her closest friends, she breaks down during a storm and unexpectedly finds comfort in Amanda. In a moment of vulnerability, the two share a kiss that changes everything.

Now both girls are left struggling with emotions they don't understand. Amanda begins questioning whether her hatred for Carley was ever real, while Carley fights against feelings that clash with the expectations placed on her by her father, her social life, and even herself. Torn between fear and attraction, the two must decide whether continuing to act like enemies is easier than facing the truth about who they really are.