All her life Ava dreamed of the day when she would find the man of her dreams and they could buy their dream house and have the perfect family. She's crushing on Vince Maloley, the quarterback of the football team and the top of her class. She thinks that as this is her last year of college, she needs him to fall for her in order to fulfill her dream. What she doesn't expect is that she may not catch the attention of only Vince but also his misfit brother Nate. Will her dream be fulfilled or will it change to fit in the misfit that fell for her?