Ava heads back home to Michigan for Christmas after being away at boarding school. While home she meets Caleb, he is like her other half spontaneous and energetic. Maybe he can break Ava out of her quiet and timid shell, but while he tries his hardest Hunter gets in the way. Hunter is everything Ava wants, or so she continues to believe. Will she pick the guy of her dreams or the guy who can make her dreams come true?