My Crush Is a Killer (Ticci Toby x reader)(oc)
  • Reads 15,484
  • Votes 280
  • Parts 10
  • Time 27m
  • Reads 15,484
  • Votes 280
  • Parts 10
  • Time 27m
Ongoing, First published Aug 14, 2015
You and toby were friends in grade school and you helped each other throughout each other's troublesome lives. Then he suddenly disappears and ends up a Creepypasta. Will you ever find your crush again? Or will he find you and lead you to your fate?
All Rights Reserved
Sign up to add My Crush Is a Killer (Ticci Toby x reader)(oc) to your library and receive updates
or
#535ticci
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Won't You Stay? {COMPLETED} by Chaotic_Energy_420
16 parts Complete Mature
Ticci Toby x Reader I do not own most of these characters. Hoodie and Masky (Brian and Tim) belong to Marble Hornets. The rest of the Pastas belong to their rightful owners. I don't own the you in the story. That'd be weird- and it's truth. So. Any side characters that I may add are most likely gonna be made up by me, so those characters I do own- I guess. The story cover was not made by me. I just found a photo on Google. This story will be using She/Her pronouns, meaning the you in this story is female. You have been warned. (If this does well, I may make another CreepyPasta x Reader with the reader being male. 👌) --------------- His name was Toby. He was a generally quiet boy around strangers, but was more than annoying and loud around people he knew. Though, he didn't know very many people other than the people he lived with. Kinda rare for a killer to make friends with someone that wasn't like him. Her name was (Y/N). She was sarcastic and generally grumpy towards everyone. She didn't like where she was in life and didn't even know what she wanted to do with it. This lead to her having a generally boring life. She acted as if death couldn't come soon enough. But, things changed. This wouldn't be much of a story if it would've gone otherwise. What happens after one quick encounter? Eh, guess you'll find out soon enough, right? (Please don't have high expectations for this story, I suck at writing. ;-;)
You may also like
Slide 1 of 8
Nightmare or Daydream? (Ticci Toby X Reader) cover
Mirror cover
Now Or Never (Ticci Toby X Eyeless Jack) cover
Ticci-Toby x reader cover
Won't You Stay? {COMPLETED} cover
Ticci Toby X Reader cover
Ticci Toby X Reader cover
Partners In Crime (Ticciwork fanfic) [DISCONTINUED] cover

Nightmare or Daydream? (Ticci Toby X Reader)

43 parts Complete

(I started this when I was about 13 so please don't hate the first half too much!) "It was you all along, looking out for me?" Toby nodded looking down. "Of course." #623 Horror - August 30 2018 #255 Ticci Toby - February 1 2019 #12 Guy x girl - June 2 2019 #85 Creepypasta x reader June 2 2019 #295 Creepypasta - January 4 2021