This Wasn't Supposed To Happen (Hiatus)
xkennyisdeadx
  • Reads 1,118
  • Votes 120
  • Parts 23
  • Time 1h 22m
  • Reads 1,118
  • Votes 120
  • Parts 23
  • Time 1h 22m
xkennyisdeadx
Ongoing, First published Aug 17, 2015
bendrownedcreepypastacreepypastafanfictioneyelessjackfancharacterfanfictionhoodiehorrorjeffthekillerlaughingjackmarblehornetsmaskymissfortuneoperatorslendermansuspensethrillerticciticcitobytoby
I had a good life, single mom, dead dad, and a crazy uncle to babysit me. Not as bad as you think to be honest; now my life is twisted- the freakishly pale one despises me to the bone and almost killed me, along with the one in the yellow hoodie, and the one with the white mask helping them capture me. The one behind this all? The Operator, and Im supposed to join them. This all started after the day my luck went downhill, but, the Proxies aren't the only threat around here. 

Come and join me, read my accidental life-changing story. A story where I try to abscond these horrors, a story where I refuse to be a proxy, where I deny or accept my fate- a story that was never supposed to happen in the first place.

[TICCI TOBY BELONGS TO KASTOWAY ON DEVIANTART, MASKY/HOODIE TO MARBLE HORNETS, AND MISS FORTUNE (RILEY ALEXANDER) TO ME.]
(CC) Attrib. NonComm. NoDerivs
bendrownedcreepypastacreepypastafanfictioneyelessjackfancharacterfanfictionhoodiehorrorjeffthekillerlaughingjackmarblehornetsmaskymissfortuneoperatorslendermansuspensethrillerticciticcitobytoby
Table of contents

23 parts

Sign up to add This Wasn't Supposed To Happen (Hiatus) to your library and receive updates
or
#828hoodie
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Living With The Creepypastas (Old) by VikingMetalToby
43 parts Complete
IMPORTANT: I originally wrote this back in 2018 when I was younger and an idiot and sucked badly at writing. It's all toxic fandom stereotypes in this book. You should know ahead of time that this story is gonna suck. Huge L. DESC: You're a useless outsider until you get recruited by Slenderman one night. Congrats, you get to be a proxy and live in the Slender Mansion with the creepypastas and have cliché a Creepypasta x reader life! Ughhh. !𝐒𝐓𝐎𝐑𝐘 𝐖𝐀𝐑𝐍𝐈𝐍𝐆𝐒! - Y/N, unfortunately, is the overused female lead idiot stupid. (Please feel free to treat Y/N as your preference). - Ticci Toby is 'sort of' a waffle addict. - Hoody and Masky are considered Creepypasta/Proxies. - There's TicciWork (This was old, alright?) - There's obvious excessive cursing. - There's obviously cringe (2018 trash.) - yeah #1 in boring. Now you know to run...
Everything is fine (Eyeless Jack x Ticci Toby) by Jewel_Evelyn
132 parts Ongoing Mature
I edited the cover. Credit to the original image: https://i.pinimg.com/736x/c7/25/c7/c725c7ba9e18db2165b6dfe94c1b7e72.jpg (This was the original link but it doesn't seem to work anymore..?) https://millivedder.tumblr.com/post/613148037514231808/lord-of-the-forest Hello! This was my first time writing a fanfic, so bear with me (I've been working on this since 2019 OMG). Expect bad writing haha... English isn't my first language so I will probably have tense/grammar mistakes. Written in Toby's p.o.v unless stated otherwise. Mostly about the characters: Toby, Eyeless Jack, Hoodie and Masky, other characters don't appear often in the story. Personal fanon versions of the characters. I apologize if they seem out of character! I like experimenting with my own interpretations of them. I have nothing against the originals and I also adore other people's versions of these characters! The characters are kinda inconsistent.... Contains violence! (fighting, blood, murder etc. standard Creepypasta stuff) I try to add warnings at the beginning of chapters. AU where Creepypasta and Marble Hornets mix and Proxies work for the Slenderman. If you don't like my story or my versions of the characters then that's totally okay, I don't mind! Just please don't give me hate comments or threatening messages. I am aware that it's cringe EEk🥲 This is not referring to real people!!!! These characters don't belong to me!! (except for the like 2 oc's lol)
𝐁𝐈𝐓𝐓𝐄𝐑-𝐒𝐖𝐄𝐄𝐓、 TICCI TOBY. by HEROINELACE
23 parts Ongoing Mature
In the heart of a picturesque town lies a /love/ story driven by jealousy and possessiveness. As Toby's infatuation descends into a chilling game of cat and mouse. Our character, Cleo, finds herself trapped in a terrifying reality where every step she takes is monitored, every hour is haunted. As the line between obsession and love blurs, Cleo's life becomes a waking nightmare and Toby's a twisted life worth advancing. What will the two become? ⋆ written by @𝙝𝙚𝙧𝙤𝙞𝙣𝙚𝙡𝙖𝙘𝙚、 est 2024. Dislclaimer .ᐟ characters may be written using my own interpretations and head-cannons of them、but it is just that. Head-cannon. This means their appearance and character overall may differ. ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ [Ticci-Toby fic ╱ creepypasta verse.]
It's all your fault (Masky x reader) by oxblurxo
25 parts Complete Mature
A creepypasta and marble hornets crossover fic. <3 (Y/n) ran away from her home and went to Alabama where (F/n) lives. She meets Timothy and Brian along the way and is haunted by Slenderman. Next thing she knows is that everyone in her life is dead and she is now apart of the creepypasta family. But there is some bumps in the road that will lead to disaster. But who's fault is it? "This is all YOUR fault." Best rankings: #1/58 in marble #4/246 in marblehornets #19/306 in tim #91/1000+ in hoodie #127/1000+ in masky #580/1000+ in creepypasta WARNING!!!! CONTAINS: blood, depression, swearing, killing, secrets, cliff hangers, long ass chapters and marble hornets spoilers. If you are uncomfortable reading that kind of stuff then don't read this book at all. I DO NOT ENCOURAGE ANY OF THOSE THINGS ^^^
Dear Diary | Proxies by 1987vampire
40 parts Complete Mature
"Tim," I finally spoke, my voice cracking from misuse and my crying. "Tim, I think I did something bad." Tim looked like a deer in headlights at the sound of me finally speaking. "It's okay, baby," he said, dropping the rag and moving so he was directly in front of me. "It's going to be okay." I let out another choked sob as I wrapped my arms around him, pulling him close to me as I could. Tim was quivering in my touch as he tried to stay strong. "I'm sorry. I'm so sorry," he mumbled, pressing his face into my hair. "We're going to be okay, yeah?" ----- Dear Diary, What. The. Fuck. You would think the encounters from working at waffle house would be weird enough for a lifetime, but next thing you know, I'm falling head-first in love with three - technically five - men and fighting for my life in a series of trials set up by an eldritch god. I guess normality was never my forte, but this is something else entirely. Let's see how this ends? Creepypasta Proxies [ Ticci Toby, Brian Thomas (Hoodie), Tim Wright (Masky) x OC] Started: June 3rd, 2021 Ended: July 21, 2022 Word Count: 121k
A Forgotten Friend Ticci Toby X Reader [COMPLETE] [EDITING] by VCReading1098
53 parts Complete
Cover By: mrsagustd93 Y/N L/N-Age 19 She had a friend from her past disappear. People say he's dead. Others say he's alive and killing. She wish both of these remarks aren't true and he's just at a vacation for a long time... Tobias Rodgers Aka. Ticci Toby- Age 19 One of the proxies of Slenderman. Doesn't really remember some of his past from a little bit of amnesia. Can't feel pain from one of his disorders. Has Tourette's Syndrome. What happens if they meet again? ⚠️CONTAINS GORE, BAD LANGUAGE⚠️
The Devil's Demon [Ticci Toby X Reader] by SteveFromCorporate
12 parts Complete Mature
Sometimes life doesn't go to plan. Sometimes the people you love, don't love you back. Sometimes, you get fed up with some people and take matters into your own hands. She's baack! By she, I mean you. (Y/N). You're back. The long awaited sequel to "A Dance With The Devil" is finally here! With a whole lot more drama and more. Dedicated to all the people who were so supportive in the first book! I hope you love it. *** (Y/N) has been through one hell of a time when she first encountered the love of her life,Toby. After the death of her friends and her own near death experience, (Y/N) can finally relax in the safety of the creepypasta mansion. Or so our sassy friend (you) thinks. A year has past and (Y/N) is now 19 years old. Her year long, rocky relationship with Toby has kept her happy. But when (Y/N) hears some bittersweet news, her excitement turns to rage when she gets fed up of how indecisive Toby is. What will she do? ** All credit for the amazing cover art goes to the artist!
Camp Creepypasta {Ticci Toby x Reader} [BOOK 1] by deepinecstasy
26 parts Complete
Basically, you're 18. You were homeschooled your entire life but you were fine with that, you preferred to be alone. Your parents never cared to spend time with you and they neglected you which was part of the reason you were so used to being alone. You loved creepypastas and read them whenever your parents would neglect you. One night, when you snuck out of the house and towards the lake to go clear your mind, some girls pushed you in and you almost drowned but you were saved by who you thought was a fictional character. Then, you receive a letter, telling you about a camp that was perfect for you. You went and even made some friends, but more and more happens and everything keeps getting worse. You need to try and fix things before things spiral beyond your control, There has to be a way to stop this, right? Read the story to find out what happens! -------- « Book Status: COMPLETE » completed on 03/11/2020 This is a series of books, this book is the first thus why it says 'BOOK 1' in the title. The second book and the rest of them will be on my profile. - BOOKS OUT SO FAR: 2/7 [ also, this is a Marble Hornets and Creepypasta crossover, so expect some Marble Hornets related chapters :) ] [ cover art by Lynnarty ] (!) [TW/CW: strong language, self-harm, suicide, drugs, described gore, long mf chapters lmao] (!) All your support truly means a lot to me! -------- Rankings: hoodieandmasky - #1 ! [wOW] hoodieandmasky - #4 😔 Creepypasta - #595 ouch :,( hoodieandmasky- #3 👀 Creepypasta - #820 seriously- hoodieandmasky- #3 👁-👁 hoodieandmasky - #2 ! Toby - #148 hoodieandmasky - #326 (HOW THE FU-) Toby - #114 :D ticcitobyxreader - #5 ! proxy - #1 ! proxies - #1 !✨ creepypasta - #279 sally williams - #1 (why tho lmao she's like not mentioned once i don't think) creepypasta - #592 toby - #23 :)
Tear In My Heart (COMPLETE) by Kcx245
13 parts Complete
Tim finds himself lost to the Operator after the events of Marble Hornets; caught up in a lone life of travel and covering up the Operator's tracks. He's been so used to being alone, his friends long gone or having moved on with their own lives. But what would happen if a friend long gone would return to him in the most unconvential of ways? And what of his life living under the Operator and meeting more horrific monsters than he ever thought existed? And what of the newest Proxy the Operator decides to bring in, in the hopes of lessening the burden of his two highest ranking members? Tim could only suppose, at this rate, that the more he wasn't surprised with life, the better. ( If you like this story, make sure the read the rest I have on my profile in the series for this ship! There's 3 others!
Messed up in all the right ways {proxies X reader} by mortuusrising
40 parts Complete Mature
{C O M P L E T E D} -- An orphan girl, (y/n) (l/n) an abused and bullied girl with depression. Her life changes when she is taken to become the newest proxy, and meets the proxies. Read to find out what happens next! -- Cover by: @OliverTheHoodini -- *contains: mature language, potential triggers, abuse, and depression. (so far)* -- This is a crossover universe/alternate universe where the events of marble hornets did happen but Hoodie never died and instead of Tim (Masky) running away from the law, they both went with The operator. The operator will be Slenderman not a different entity in this story -- I am very aware that Masky and Hoodie aren't creepypasta characters, and that they have never and will never be in anyway connected to creepypasta. -- Masky and hoodie belong to THAC Ticci-Toby belongs to Kastoway (even though Kastoway doesn't care anymore) -- sorry for such a long description. But, enjoy!
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
Living With The Creepypastas (Old) cover
Everything is fine (Eyeless Jack x Ticci Toby) cover
𝐁𝐈��𝐓𝐓𝐄𝐑-𝐒𝐖𝐄𝐄𝐓、 TICCI TOBY. cover
It's all your fault (Masky x reader) cover
Dear Diary | Proxies cover
A Forgotten Friend Ticci Toby X Reader [COMPLETE] [EDITING] cover
The Devil's Demon [Ticci Toby X Reader] cover
Camp Creepypasta {Ticci Toby x Reader} [BOOK 1] cover
Tear In My Heart (COMPLETE) cover
Messed up in all the right ways {proxies X reader} cover

Living With The Creepypastas (Old)

43 parts Complete

IMPORTANT: I originally wrote this back in 2018 when I was younger and an idiot and sucked badly at writing. It's all toxic fandom stereotypes in this book. You should know ahead of time that this story is gonna suck. Huge L. DESC: You're a useless outsider until you get recruited by Slenderman one night. Congrats, you get to be a proxy and live in the Slender Mansion with the creepypastas and have cliché a Creepypasta x reader life! Ughhh. !𝐒𝐓𝐎𝐑𝐘 𝐖𝐀𝐑𝐍𝐈𝐍𝐆𝐒! - Y/N, unfortunately, is the overused female lead idiot stupid. (Please feel free to treat Y/N as your preference). - Ticci Toby is 'sort of' a waffle addict. - Hoody and Masky are considered Creepypasta/Proxies. - There's TicciWork (This was old, alright?) - There's obvious excessive cursing. - There's obviously cringe (2018 trash.) - yeah #1 in boring. Now you know to run...

More details