Liam and... a Bad Girl???

Rose has had many boyfriends similar to Zayn Malik, who she meets at an amusement park. Nice bad boys at first, but then abusive. For some reason, Zayn's best friend and fellow band member Liam makes her feel like a different person, but who is she actually? The person she is with Zayn; bad girl who doesn't care about anything. Or the person she is with Liam; kind, gentle, and caring?