3 parts Complete Sabrina visits a carnival psychic when she's thirteen years old, and told she will marry a man whose name begins with the letter J. At that time, her crush's name is Justin, so she believes the psychic is referring to him. Convinced she will marry him, she watches him go through girlfriends, waiting for her chance to be with him. She finally gets that chance, though it is short lived. Still convinced he is the one, she hatches a plan to get him back, which includes dating someone new to make Justin jealous. She chooses Andrew, the guy at the coffee shop she visits almost daily, who is typically not her type, with long hair and an unkempt beard. Along the way, she begins to fall for Andrew, who falls for her as well, and she questions her plan. She fights the feelings for Andrew, viewing them as a betrayal to Justin. But she comes to a point of asking herself if she's really meant to be with Justin. Should she continue pursuing him, or let go, and go with the new feelings for Andrew?
