An unnatural love story (Jeff the killer x ben drowned)

Reads 132,227
Votes 1,665
Parts 29
Time 2h 21m

Reads 132,227
Votes 1,665
Parts 29
Time 2h 21m

Hell I never expected this to happen & neither did he. but now that it has im not leting it go. And ill be dammed if anyone says otherwise.All Rights Reserved

ben creepypasta dark jeff yaoi

29 parts

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Originally Published: January 2024 onwards Original Reads: 715K, Votes: 12K Republishing (after being deleted): February 26, 2025 onwards ~ • ⁠༶⁠ • ~ When my dad told me his best friend was finally returning back to his hometown, I expected him to be someone who got me bored with a word, not the one who got me wet with a look. I expected him to be someone I would rather ignore, not the one whose fantasies I pleasured myself to. I expected him to be an addition to my dad's drinking group, not the one I'd prefer to eat me out. I expected him to be someone my dad went out with, not the one who brought home my college bestie. More or less, I expected him to be an uncle, never my hottest-ever one-night stand.

Do You Really Want Me? by thepromiseofanend

Never Thought We'd Be Together, Again by Ivie_Clarissa2

This is a mixture of my fandoms=) so,uh yeah. I sighed, knowing everyone wouldn't even care. ----------- No way.He's back,in my arms. ----------- DID YOU EVEN CARE?! ----------- I really wish you were here...

Story written with @AllAboutTheBear

Free Falling {Gus De St Jeor FanFic} (#Wattys2016) by TheRumIsDyedBlue

It was never planned. All I was going to do, was go to the concert and have fun. I didn't think I would run into him there. I mean, I have always had a crush on him, but never like this. But all I know, is that I'm Free Falling for him.

His Pretty little nightmare by ___that__thing___

It was just a normal I was playing video games when I fell asleep and had these weird dreams but they ended coming true and it's got a certain killer involved who's been following me around and maybe becomes more then a friend Read to find out more

A collection of creepypasta stories. I don't own any of them.

SAFE HOUSE (Creepypasta x reader) rewrite by shilo2

i do not own any of the characters in this story they belong to there rightful owners and you belong to you. i am not good with description's so i suggest you read it, it's is a good story and reader discretion is advised that there is violence and swearing in this story. This is a transfer from my other account here on wattpad and the account name was @ShirleyCarpenter so please do not report this i am just transfering it over to this account because i can't log on with my facebook account sorry for the inconvenience.

I never thought...I never actually thought....that I would....fall....for someone as great....as you.

It's... Complicated (Jeff x Ben) by deletedusername12

I Thought Jeff was Nice, I guess I was Wrong, He is..... You'll see in the story #10 in jeffxben ⬅️please stop reading this

Mr. Vincenzo | 18+

Originally Published: January 2024 onwards Original Reads: 715K, Votes: 12K Republishing (after being deleted): February 26, 2025 onwards ~ • ⁠༶⁠ • ~ When my dad told me his best friend was finally returning back to his hometown, I expected him to be someone who got me bored with a word, not the one who got me wet with a look. I expected him to be someone I would rather ignore, not the one whose fantasies I pleasured myself to. I expected him to be an addition to my dad's drinking group, not the one I'd prefer to eat me out. I expected him to be someone my dad went out with, not the one who brought home my college bestie. More or less, I expected him to be an uncle, never my hottest-ever one-night stand.

More details