The Corner Store

Gabe just got out of a relationship and needs ice cream to drown his imaginary sorrows in (really, he just needs the ice cream), so he drags his brother down to the gas station on the corner to pick some up.

Dean and Sam happen to walk into the same store to pick up some essentials they'd run out of. They overhear Gabe and Cas arguing over which one of them is cuter, Dean or Sam.

Flirting ensues since there is no way Dean is walking out of that store without at least saying hello to the man with the blue eyes and the sex hair, and Gabe's not letting Sam escape quite so easily either....