Varsity player, Penelope, thinks she's in love with their school's resident heartthrob, Cole. So when their professor asked who among them is willing to tutor him, she instantly volunteered to fill the job. She thought it's her chance to finally make Cole see her in a different light, so she plotted a plan to make him fall for her. First tutoring session came, and Penelope was ecstatic, but Cole failed to come. Darren, his nerd cousin, came for him instead, to ask her to be his tutor, too. Penelope declined. She wanted Cole, not Darren. But an idea struck her: she will tutor Darren, and in return, he will help her win Cole. A brilliant idea, she thought. But Darren seemingly had a plan of his own, and it involves Penelope-- the girl of his dreams.