Annoyingly in Love - sup - Wattpad

Annoyingly in Love

Reads 177
Votes 16
Parts 11
Time 49m

Reads 177
Votes 16
Parts 11
Time 49m

bendrowned creepypasta eyelessjack fanfiction fluff hoodie janethekiller jeffthekiller jeffthekillerfanfiction laughingjack masky oneshots proxies riley romance sally slenderman therake ticcitoby ticcitobyfanfiction

Riley... A brand new Proxy, new to the Creepypasta household, and of course, everything else.
Although, there is one peculiar person that loves to annoy and pick on her; that person? Ticci Toby. Hate evolves into crushes, and crushes evolve into love.  However, is it possible that, that love comes tumbling back down to hate?

****DRAWING IN COVER BELONGS TO SKUKAAI (OUKAAI ON INSTAGRAM)****All Rights Reserved

bendrowned creepypasta eyelessjack fanfiction fluff hoodie janethekiller jeffthekiller jeffthekillerfanfiction laughingjack masky oneshots proxies riley romance sally slenderman therake ticcitoby ticcitobyfanfiction

Table of contents

11 parts

Sign up to add Annoyingly in Love to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Fighting Love by JessicaDark2

I don't own any of the characters, except mine. Yes I know most or all characters, and I am a huge fan of creepypasta. Characters that you will or may see and that I will use. Characters - Slenderman, Ticci Toby (Toby Rogers), Masky (Tim,Timothy), Hoodie(Brian), Jeff the Killer (Jeffrey Woods), Eyeless Jack (Jack), Jane the Killer (Jane Richerdson), Sally Williams, Ben Drown, Dark Link, Lulu (Lucial Tiffany), Laughing Jack, Nurse Ann,Yandary (Ayano), Lazari, Jason the ToyMaker, Suicidal Liu(Liu Woods), the Puppeteer, Nina the killer(Nina), Clockwork , Blood Traitor, Jasper, Lost Sliver, Smiling Dog, Rake, Zalgo, Creepy Fanf characters, Sonic Ex, Jason, Huntress, Doctor Tima- Kiel, Cp/n (Y/n) and Red Mask ( Rosaline, or Rose Grey) and Blue Mask (Ryan Grey), Pink Wolf (Ruby Grey) and Grey Night (Susen Grey) ....I know most of these characters aren't creepypasta but to me they are, and the last one is my oc, soo ye.. shipping Toby x Masky Hoodie x Rose Lulu x Jeff Sally x Ben Ryan x Eyeless Jack

Our New Addition - A CreepyPasta Fanfiction. [DISCONTINUED] by cinnabunny08

I'm no longer working on this story. Truth be told, I don't like it. I kept telling myself that once I got it started I'd sort of warm up to it, but at this point I've given up on it. I have no motivation nor desire to continue it. I do, however, have other CreepyPasta-related story ideas. Stay tuned for those. <3

Creepypasta Vacation Tips by Paranoid_Badger

The Creepypasta crew gives tips on having a nice vacation while everything they do completely backfires in their faces miserably. I'm sorry for writing this. But I hope you enjoy

Jake The Lumberjack: He Comes by Blushy_Boy

- Cover made by Mystical_Panda! - A Creepypasta story, My oc, DO NOT STEAL! His life use to almost be perfect, well, besides the fact were he was never loved by his family. But one day when his dad finally gave him the chance to show off what he could do, he screwed up. Something happened to him, he went insane, slowly, minute by minute. But when six months past by, he went full insane and did something that he might regret. But when he ran away, he ran into some people. They ended up being the Creepypasta. They become good friends, well most of them at least. But, something happened one night that led to something big. Read to figure out what happens.

Sinister love (creepypasta X fem!reader) by m1lfandD1lfl0v3r

A young, hot, but depressed college girl who only wishes someone would put her out of her misery accidentally stumbles upon an ongoing murder. She does the right thing...by getting the fuck out of there, it ain't her problem that person was getting stabbed. However it becomes her problem when said murderers were aware that she was a witness and one that they let get away. Now stopping at nothing, the killers agreed to find the woman and keep her mouth shut, the one that she was never going to open anyway💀 A creepypasta X fem!reader

Masky X Reader X Hoodie by WildChild289

Alone in the forest, A runaway from your abusive ex bf, A savior named hoodie takes you to a mansion.... An outgoing guy and a cold hearted killer. 2 guys 1 heart... Who will you choose?.

Where the wolves go, ravens follow (Creepypasta) by Jewel_Evelyn

I (poorly) edited the cover lol ajkfdjacnjecgb Written in Toby's p.o.v unless stated otherwise. In this version most of the Creepypasta characters live together. Personal fanon versions of the characters. I apologize if they seem out of character! I like experimenting with my own interpretations of them. I have nothing against the originals and I also adore other people's versions of these characters! Contains shipping!!! Everything's more fast paced in this fanfic (at least I tried),,, If you don't like my story or my versions of the characters then that's totally okay, I don't mind! Just please don't give me hate comments or threatening messages. AU where Creepypasta and Marble Hornets mix and Proxies work for the Slenderman. Contains violence! (fighting, blood etc. standard Creepypasta stuff) I am aware that it's cringe EEk🥲 This is not referring to real people!!!! These characters don't belong to me!!

Dear Diary | Proxies by 1987vampire

"Tim," I finally spoke, my voice cracking from misuse and my crying. "Tim, I think I did something bad." Tim looked like a deer in headlights at the sound of me finally speaking. "It's okay, baby," he said, dropping the rag and moving so he was directly in front of me. "It's going to be okay." I let out another choked sob as I wrapped my arms around him, pulling him close to me as I could. Tim was quivering in my touch as he tried to stay strong. "I'm sorry. I'm so sorry," he mumbled, pressing his face into my hair. "We're going to be okay, yeah?" ----- Dear Diary, What. The. Fuck. You would think the encounters from working at waffle house would be weird enough for a lifetime, but next thing you know, I'm falling head-first in love with three - technically five - men and fighting for my life in a series of trials set up by an eldritch god. I guess normality was never my forte, but this is something else entirely. Let's see how this ends? Creepypasta Proxies [ Ticci Toby, Brian Thomas (Hoodie), Tim Wright (Masky) x OC] Started: June 3rd, 2021 Ended: July 21, 2022 Word Count: 121k

The Devil's Demon [Ticci Toby X Reader] by SteveFromCorporate

Sometimes life doesn't go to plan. Sometimes the people you love, don't love you back. Sometimes, you get fed up with some people and take matters into your own hands. She's baack! By she, I mean you. (Y/N). You're back. The long awaited sequel to "A Dance With The Devil" is finally here! With a whole lot more drama and more. Dedicated to all the people who were so supportive in the first book! I hope you love it. *** (Y/N) has been through one hell of a time when she first encountered the love of her life,Toby. After the death of her friends and her own near death experience, (Y/N) can finally relax in the safety of the creepypasta mansion. Or so our sassy friend (you) thinks. A year has past and (Y/N) is now 19 years old. Her year long, rocky relationship with Toby has kept her happy. But when (Y/N) hears some bittersweet news, her excitement turns to rage when she gets fed up of how indecisive Toby is. What will she do? ** All credit for the amazing cover art goes to the artist!

𝐁𝐈𝐓𝐓𝐄𝐑-𝐒𝐖𝐄𝐄𝐓、 TICCI TOBY. by HEROINELACE

In the heart of a picturesque town lies a /love/ story driven by jealousy and possessiveness. As Toby's infatuation descends into a chilling game of cat and mouse. Our character, Cleo, finds herself trapped in a terrifying reality where every step she takes is monitored, every hour is haunted. As the line between obsession and love blurs, Cleo's life becomes a waking nightmare and Toby's a twisted life worth advancing. What will the two become? ⋆ written by @𝙝𝙚𝙧𝙤𝙞𝙣𝙚𝙡𝙖𝙘𝙚、 est 2024. Dislclaimer .ᐟ characters may be written using my own interpretations and head-cannons of them、but it is just that. Head-cannon. This means their appearance and character overall may differ. ⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀ [Ticci-Toby fic ╱ creepypasta verse.]

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Fighting Love cover

Our New Addition - A CreepyPasta Fanfiction. [DISCONTINUED] cover

Creepypasta Vacation Tips cover

Jake The Lumberjack: He Comes cover

Sinister love (creepypasta X fem!reader) cover

Masky X Reader X Hoodie cover

Where the wolves go, ravens follow (Creepypasta) cover

Dear Diary | Proxies cover

The Devil's Demon [Ticci Toby X Reader] cover

𝐁𝐈𝐓𝐓𝐄𝐑-𝐒𝐖𝐄𝐄𝐓、 TICCI TOBY. cover

Fighting Love

I don't own any of the characters, except mine. Yes I know most or all characters, and I am a huge fan of creepypasta. Characters that you will or may see and that I will use. Characters - Slenderman, Ticci Toby (Toby Rogers), Masky (Tim,Timothy), Hoodie(Brian), Jeff the Killer (Jeffrey Woods), Eyeless Jack (Jack), Jane the Killer (Jane Richerdson), Sally Williams, Ben Drown, Dark Link, Lulu (Lucial Tiffany), Laughing Jack, Nurse Ann,Yandary (Ayano), Lazari, Jason the ToyMaker, Suicidal Liu(Liu Woods), the Puppeteer, Nina the killer(Nina), Clockwork , Blood Traitor, Jasper, Lost Sliver, Smiling Dog, Rake, Zalgo, Creepy Fanf characters, Sonic Ex, Jason, Huntress, Doctor Tima- Kiel, Cp/n (Y/n) and Red Mask ( Rosaline, or Rose Grey) and Blue Mask (Ryan Grey), Pink Wolf (Ruby Grey) and Grey Night (Susen Grey) ....I know most of these characters aren't creepypasta but to me they are, and the last one is my oc, soo ye.. shipping Toby x Masky Hoodie x Rose Lulu x Jeff Sally x Ben Ryan x Eyeless Jack