Three guys go out for a fun night and happen to find each other. They drink until they're too drunk to drive home and walk to whose house is the closest and pass out in bed together. Needless to say hilarity ensues.
Mitch can't stop thinking about a Calvin Klein billboard. He has to know who that guy is. Then, at a photoshoot for the Pride Parade, he's suddenly face-to-face with the man he's been obsessing over for months. When a sex scandal breaks, Mitch decides to help the guy-who turns out to be a baseball player-salvage his career. Maybe pretending to date would be the best way to fix the mess.