Lana Michaels life consists of 1. her cello, 2. her art, 3. her books and 4. her best friend, Gabby. It's a life her twin sister, Elizabeth - soccer player and dramatic popularity queen - couldn't dream of living. The girls share all the bad things in their lives - their awful father, freckles - but it seems to Lana that Elizabeth gets all the good things. So when something good finally comes Lana's way she doesn't believe for a second that Elizabeth won't strut in with her extravagant looks and massive popularity and steal him from her. Can Lana have him as an anchor in her crumbling life? Will Elizabeth steal him just like she stole Lana's favorite pair of shoes?