"Hating you is the only way I can stop myself from loving you." Allison Pierce embarks on her first day as a sophomore in high school and somehow acquires an enemy... The school's bad boy, Sherman Black. Even upon meeting for the first time, they absolutely hate each other. But things soon get better when she meets the school's sweet heart, Eli. They meet, hit it off, and fall in love. But Allison is in for a huge surprise when she discovers that Eli and Sherman are brothers. Now she has to deal with her boyfriend's jerk of a brother, Sherman, in school and out of school. But the more they're together, the more they grow to like each other. Now Allison must choose who she wants without tearing the two brothers apart. Sometimes love is good, sometimes love is bad. And then sometimes... It's just plain old complicated.