Tyler is the preppy, wholesome football star who is friends with everyone, gets good grades and is adored by all. While Jeremy on the other hand is the druggie, pot-head punk who smokes too much but has Tyler wrapped right around his finger, he just doesn't know it. Tyler having been in love with Jeremy for years with absolutely nothing to show for it but a still yearning heart decides to do something about his pathetic crush, becoming the 'bad boy' he thinks Jeremy wants.