My Unexpected Lover *Completed* - OT5 Trash 😛 - Wattpad

Story cover for My Unexpected Lover *Completed* by Mrs_Orton25

My Unexpected Lover *Completed*

Reads 67,783
Votes 1,204
Parts 35
Time 5h 21m

Reads 67,783
Votes 1,204
Parts 35
Time 5h 21m

ajkaitlyn ajlee ajorton kaitlyn randyorton wwe

WWE Diva AJ Lee thought she would never find love........until she meets the guy of her dreams, CM Punk. But as time goes on, the relationship gets rocky. He's really just using her to get the WWE Championship. He goes from this loveable man she met on NXT to the boyfriend from hell. But then as Punk starts spending time with her, he starts catching feelings. She confides in her good friend, Randy Orton. But after a storyline kiss and she starts seeing him more, she starts catching feelings for him, and he feels the same way. Soon they are in this spicy love affair. Will her acts catch up to her, will she break up with her abusive and controlling boyfriend and have a happy relationship with the REAL man of her dreams, or will CM Punk reconsider his plan and ask her out?All Rights Reserved

ajkaitlyn ajlee ajorton kaitlyn randyorton wwe

Table of contents

35 parts

Sign up to add My Unexpected Lover *Completed* to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Rage & Redemption by NoNaMee420

- Completed 9/26/25 - His eyes bore into hers, fierce and desperate. "When I'm with you, Zara, I feel something real-a connection that I thought had died with my marriage. You're not just another name on the roster; you're fire and passion wrapped in a body that makes me want to be better." Each word dripped with sincerity as his heart bared itself before her, raw and vulnerable. "I was scared of what that meant for me. Scared of losing control because for once in my life, it felt like maybe-just maybe-I could have something worth fighting for." The truth hung heavy between them as he swallowed hard against the emotions pooling in his throat. Zara's gaze softened momentarily as if she felt the weight of his admission sink deep into her bones. But just as quickly as her expression shifted, her defenses snapped back into place. "Had you told me this the day I confronted you in the medic room," she said slowly, her voice steady despite the tremor of vulnerability beneath it, "I would've accepted it. But now it's too little too late." Randy felt as though she'd slapped him across the face with those words, the sting of her rejection cutting deeper than he could've anticipated. Every muscle in his body tensed, and the breath fled his lungs as he struggled to comprehend the weight of her finality. However, much to his dismay, he nodded in acceptance, turned his back and walked out of her room. Heartbroken. © 2025 All Rights Reserved - #1 WWE 09/24/2025 #1 wrestlers 09/24/2025 #1 randyorton 09/24/2025

Shielded by creampuffrollins

Adalia Black is a WWE Diva and currently at the peak of her career and closing in on her Divas championship shot. But the current divas champion AJ Lee see's how big of a threat Adalia is and plans a way to eliminate the threat. A few unlikely WWE superstars are aware of the attack that AJ has planned and will try to save Adalia. These new companions will be a part of Adalia's journey to Wrestlemania.

Jealousy ( A Dean Ambrose And Aj Lee Story ) COMPLETED by luvvug

It's the New Ara in WWE ! And the Superstar Shakeup leads to the return of WWE's craziest Diva. But what happens if her and WWE's craziest superstar collide? Will they become lovers? Or find another?

WWE School by IamHavoc777

Go back to high school with the Viper Randy Orton and all of his friends, enemies, and possibly crushes. We have the regular school drama with break ups, heart breaks, kissing, hopefully no kids lol that would suck. Most possibly gonna have cussing, a little blood, n Smut (maybe smut)

Lost In Love by BlackWidowAsylum

Aj Lee is coming back to WWE after almost two years. She had a bad breakup with CM Punk and was ready to get back to work. She meets up with her long-time friends, The Shield, and becomes the girl who accompanies them to the ring for all of their matches. Eventually, the guys began confessing their feelings for her one by one. Who will she choose?

My WWE Story (Randy Orton) (WWE) by stylinsonsrko

BOOK 1 Sam becomes a WWE Diva and gets in a relationship with Randy Orton. Her bestfriend AJ Lee is always there for her with her boyfriend CM Punk. Problems come to Randy and Sam but will Randy stick with her or leave her? Read to find out! I hope you enjoy this book!

Hired For Ambrose (WWE Fanfic) by 1D_WWE

Hired For Ambrose; Dean is a professional WWE Superstar, Rumors are going around that Dean has a girlfriend within the company, Renee. Rules in the company is you can't really date within the company. Mark and Jane gets the news and searches for a girlfriend for Ambrose for the cover up. They come across WWE Fan Kim who is a huge fan of Dean Ambrose and takes her in. Little do they know, Kim and Dean already met once, but never knew they would meet again. Kims dream comes true when she is placed as Dean Ambrose's girlfriend. A little sometime later down the road, Kim gets her second dream come true and signs with WWE to make her love life with Dean seem more real. But soon later when the contract expires, Kim has the option to end it with Dean or the WWE. Also, Dean finds himself falling in love with the wrong girl. Who? Read and find out.

Torn Between Two (CM Punk &/ Colt Cabana Love Triangle) by JamaBJamaica

Miranda is a new diva in the WWE. When she gets CM Punk for a trainer she thinks her life is perfect! That is... until she finds herself falling for CM Punk. Little does she know CM Punk is getting feelings for her also. It's fine until CM Punk's best friend Colt Cabana joins the equation and CM Punk's girlfriend, AJ gets in the way. Who will steal Miranda 's heart? Will AJ get in the way? Read to find out!

Chickbusters by GuineaPig99

Best friends. Everyone's got them. Most people are just like their best friends, and like the same stuff. Other people... Not so much. Enter Kaitlyn and AJ. Kaitlyn just won the Divas championship and is on a clear paved road to success including success in attempting to woo Wade Barrett. AJ spends her time alongside Dolph Ziggler and slapping people, or doing it in WWE '13. Seemingly, they are much different yet still are best friends who will always stick together. When a career-threatening injury threatens all that they have together though, the path doesn't seem so clear for either. Can they persevere through the toughest of times together? Or will their differences tear them apart?

There's beauty in the Darkness by astrojikook

After being out of wrestling for 4 years due to the 3 people she thought who would never betray her, she's back and she's back with vengeance #1 on Roman Reigns- 8/8/20 & 10/8/20 & 10/18/20 #1 on smackdown- 8/12/2020 & 10/14/20 #3 on Sethrollins - 9/22/20 #1 on Nalani - 9/22/20 #2 on harleyquinn- 10/18/20 #1 on nalani - 10/18/20 & 11/4/20 #2 on randyorton 11/15/20 #1 on randyorton 11/26/20 #1 on raw 11/29/20 Completed - 10/26/20

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Rage & Redemption cover

Jealousy ( A Dean Ambrose And Aj Lee Story ) COMPLETED cover

WWE School cover

Lost In Love cover

My WWE Story (Randy Orton) (WWE) cover

Hired For Ambrose (WWE Fanfic) cover

Torn Between Two (CM Punk &/ Colt Cabana Love Triangle) cover

Chickbusters cover

There's beauty in the Darkness cover

Rage & Redemption

- Completed 9/26/25 - His eyes bore into hers, fierce and desperate. "When I'm with you, Zara, I feel something real-a connection that I thought had died with my marriage. You're not just another name on the roster; you're fire and passion wrapped in a body that makes me want to be better." Each word dripped with sincerity as his heart bared itself before her, raw and vulnerable. "I was scared of what that meant for me. Scared of losing control because for once in my life, it felt like maybe-just maybe-I could have something worth fighting for." The truth hung heavy between them as he swallowed hard against the emotions pooling in his throat. Zara's gaze softened momentarily as if she felt the weight of his admission sink deep into her bones. But just as quickly as her expression shifted, her defenses snapped back into place. "Had you told me this the day I confronted you in the medic room," she said slowly, her voice steady despite the tremor of vulnerability beneath it, "I would've accepted it. But now it's too little too late." Randy felt as though she'd slapped him across the face with those words, the sting of her rejection cutting deeper than he could've anticipated. Every muscle in his body tensed, and the breath fled his lungs as he struggled to comprehend the weight of her finality. However, much to his dismay, he nodded in acceptance, turned his back and walked out of her room. Heartbroken. © 2025 All Rights Reserved - #1 WWE 09/24/2025 #1 wrestlers 09/24/2025 #1 randyorton 09/24/2025