My Unexpected Lover *Completed*
- Reads 67,998
- Votes 1,204
- Parts 35
WWE Diva AJ Lee thought she would never find love........until she meets the guy of her dreams, CM Punk. But as time goes on, the relationship gets rocky. He's really just using her to get the WWE Championship. He goes from this loveable man she met on NXT to the boyfriend from hell. But then as Punk starts spending time with her, he starts catching feelings. She confides in her good friend, Randy Orton. But after a storyline kiss and she starts seeing him more, she starts catching feelings for him, and he feels the same way. Soon they are in this spicy love affair. Will her acts catch up to her, will she break up with her abusive and controlling boyfriend and have a happy relationship with the REAL man of her dreams, or will CM Punk reconsider his plan and ask her out?
All Rights Reserved
#165
ajlee
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
There's beauty in the Darkness
After being out of wrestling for 4 years due to the 3 people she thought who would never betray her, she's back and she's back with vengeance #1 on Roman Reigns- 8/8/20 & 10/8/20 & 10/18/20 #1 on smackdown- 8/12/2020 & 10/14/20 #3 on Sethrollins - 9/22/20 #1 on Nalani - 9/22/20 #2 on harleyquinn- 10/18/20 #1 on nalani - 10/18/20 & 11/4/20 #2 on randyorton 11/15/20 #1 on randyorton 11/26/20 #1 on raw 11/29/20 Completed - 10/26/20Complete
Book 1- Living A Lie
AJ has a plan to make Dean fall head over heels for her but what happens when both AJ and Dean both fall in love with each other? Will AJ continue with the plan or end it? The only way to find out is to read!Complete
Torn Between Two (CM Punk Love Story)
Alicia Marquez is on her way to achieving great things in the WWE. She gets sidetracked when she begins to develop serious feelings for CM Punk. Alicia's life begins to have many twists and turns. Will her and Phil make it through every impossible obstacle? Or will they crumble under the pressure?Complete
Unscripted - CM Punk
Cassian Evans a wrestler, one of the best female wrestlers known. She rose to fame in the early 2010s alongside her best friend, known as CM Punk. What he didn't know then was that she was hopelessly in love with him. But when Cassie finally gets the courage to say something he leaves WWE, completely abandons her. But what happens when after almost 10 years he comes back, even if she was finally happy. Will she fall back into step with him and let him back into her life? Or do what he did to her?
Rage & Redemption
- Completed 9/26/25 - His eyes bore into hers, fierce and desperate. "When I'm with you, Zara, I feel something real-a connection that I thought had died with my marriage. You're not just another name on the roster; you're fire and passion wrapped in a body that makes me want to be better." Each word dripped with sincerity as his heart bared itself before her, raw and vulnerable. "I was scared of what that meant for me. Scared of losing control because for once in my life, it felt like maybe-just maybe-I could have something worth fighting for." The truth hung heavy between them as he swallowed hard against the emotions pooling in his throat. Zara's gaze softened momentarily as if she felt the weight of his admission sink deep into her bones. But just as quickly as her expression shifted, her defenses snapped back into place. "Had you told me this the day I confronted you in the medic room," she said slowly, her voice steady despite the tremor of vulnerability beneath it, "I would've accepted it. But now it's too little too late." Randy felt as though she'd slapped him across the face with those words, the sting of her rejection cutting deeper than he could've anticipated. Every muscle in his body tensed, and the breath fled his lungs as he struggled to comprehend the weight of her finality. However, much to his dismay, he nodded in acceptance, turned his back and walked out of her room. Heartbroken. © 2025 All Rights Reserved - #1 WWE 09/24/2025 #1 wrestlers 09/24/2025 #1 randyorton 09/24/2025Complete
Chuck Taylors and Red Bottoms
Two of the most unlikely people somehow together. Feelings more than platonic get involved, but there's a certain somebody or certain some bodies that object. "You...and Nikki? Nikki Bella?" "AJ? AJ Lee? The AJ that practically slammed our show and disrespected us? That AJ Lee?" [ I own nothing except for the ongoing story. The characters are WWE talent, this is a fan fiction. Some things are canon, others not so much. FEMSLASH. ]Complete
My WWE Story (Randy Orton) (WWE)
BOOK 1 Sam becomes a WWE Diva and gets in a relationship with Randy Orton. Her bestfriend AJ Lee is always there for her with her boyfriend CM Punk. Problems come to Randy and Sam but will Randy stick with her or leave her? Read to find out! I hope you enjoy this book!Complete
In Love With A Reborn Superstar
*A Matt Sydal/Evan Bourne love story* Chaylyn Garcia comes across with a wrestler (Matt Sydal). She seen on tv and actually gets her chances to go out with him. And grew head over heals with him. Then a little later on, things get a little rocky between Chaylyn and Matt due to a major situation that went on. But eventually it all works out at the end. Keep reading this wrestling romance fanfiction to find out what happens.Complete
Wish Come True
she's 19, he's 30. but what happens when they become bestfriends and spend every moment with each other? along the way they both find love and happiness, but they run into some complications.. what happens when they start to argue and things start changing? Will they still love the same or will it all turn into a game? Read To Find Out.Complete
Girl in Stilettos (WWE Fan Fic - GYOW Sequel)
'What the hell?! Who was that and where is Phil!' I cried. My parents looked at me grimly, so did Beth and Nattie. 'What?' I asked. Nattie then sat beside me and held my hand. 'Em, Phil is gone. We have no idea where he went, he just left...' And that was the moment I felt my heart drop.... Things seemed perfect didn't they? Emily and CM Punk were finally together; they were reigning championship and at the pinnacle of the WWE. But what happens when a legit ambush on the two of them go hazy? Emily ends up in hospital and Punk is no where to be found. Accepting reality that Punk may very well had just walked out on Emily, she feels like she's going insane without him, and no one can help her, not even the ones she loves the most. But what happens when Emily find a vital clue as to where Punk is? She will go on a wild chase to find the one she loves the most, with or without anyone by her side. As well as trying to right the wrongs, she wants to prove that she's not just a girl in stilettos...Complete
After being out of wrestling for 4 years due to the 3 people she thought who would never betray her, she's back and she's back with vengeance #1 on Roman Reigns- 8/8/20 & 10/8/20 & 10/18/20 #1 on smackdown- 8/12/2020 & 10/14/20 #3 on Sethrollins - 9/22/20 #1 on Nalani - 9/22/20 #2 on harleyquinn- 10/18/20 #1 on nalani - 10/18/20 & 11/4/20 #2 on randyorton 11/15/20 #1 on randyorton 11/26/20 #1 on raw 11/29/20 Completed - 10/26/20
More detailsContent Guidelines