Audrey Peschetti has a knack for making boys that she has no interest in fall for her. Her boyfriend, Dylan, is one of those guys. While she doesn't return his affection completely, Audrey is still somewhat content with her relationship. That is, until the party where her whole world flips upside down and inside out. There, Adurey finds herself realizing her impending romantic feelings for Adam, who just-so-happens to be one of Dylan's closest friends. Throw in some alcohol, a stupid part game, and a huge blowout and you find Audrey stuck between two boys; one who whols her affection and one who has been fooled to think he does. As her best friend warns her, nothing good can ever come out of chasing love.