Killer Can't Kill Me (Jeff the Killer fanfiction) *COMPLETED* - Lemara Lavender - Wattpad

Killer Can't Kill Me (Jeff the Killer fanfiction) *COMPLETED*

Reads 5,101
Votes 113
Parts 17
Time 1h 50m

Reads 5,101
Votes 113
Parts 17
Time 1h 50m

Mature

bloody creepy creepypasta horror jeff jeffthekiller jtk killer knife knives mrcreepypasta paranormal pasta scary

*2016 Update*
I plan on getting around to edit this eventually, so forgive the small grammar mistakes. 
•••••

"I won't kill you" he blurted out with regret. Confusion mingled with my fear. He regretted not killing me?

"Who are you?" I asked, slowly moving toward the closed door. He looked at the painting on my easel, and smiled darkly. I saw it clearly for the first time, and my eyes widened. I had painted the man in my dream. His face, twisted in a smirk, dominated the canvas. A swirl of crimson paint surrounded him, and I saw myself in the painting, wearing a long, black evening gown, my hair in a long ponytail, my pail skin glowing, and I stared at the man with love in my eyes. The painting I had created shocked me to the point of forgetting to escape. 

"Nice" the man said, and yanked open the window above my bed. He crawled out of the room, crouched on the window sill. "Jeff" he said softly, watching me with interest. 

"Huh?" Came my dumbfounded voice. 

"My name is Jeff"All Rights Reserved

bloody creepy creepypasta horror jeff jeffthekiller jtk killer knife knives mrcreepypasta paranormal pasta scary

Table of contents

17 parts

Sign up to add Killer Can't Kill Me (Jeff the Killer fanfiction) *COMPLETED* to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Captured (Jeff the Killer) by JeffTheKillerLovers

We fight, we break up. We kiss, we make up. We're going in circles, being chased by your demons. Sirens and flashing lights fill my life now, even though my colors are stained. You're a liar, and a lie. Something inside of me tries to cry, but no tears appear. Cuffs and knives, chains and lost lives. Tormented and loved, something doesn't seem right. Tell me now, are you glad that you've been tamed? Or, do you feel like you've been captured?

PSYCHOTIC. (A Jeff the Killer P.O.V and Romance) by MeanKidz

He's psychotic, mad in the head, and shivers at the sweet taste of flesh. All Jeff desired was the perfect kill. A victim to fight back, give him a challenge, and amuse his sick cravings. He found who he was looking for, but was she too feisty, even for his taste? Too accustomed to his being there? When Jeff realizes this, he doesn't know whether to end her or not. The option is tempting, but there's something deeper to this story. Something that prohibits his inner murderer from stabbing her lifeless. He begins to feel something sick, even sicker than all the blood shed and fear he's caused, the longer he's met with those green, nostalgic eyes. He begins to remember.

Those cold eyes of stone(Jeff the killer FanFiction) by Anime_Nerd36

"Your fucking crazy." He whispered staring straight into me as if searching for my soul with those stone cold eyes. "I know but if I weren't then I wouldn't have tried to find you." I said giving him a stern look and never turning my eyes from him as he released his cold fingers from mine. "You can't keep saying that. I'll never except the fact that you can live with with a monster like me." His breath hitched and all I could do was become angry and grab Jeff's hand before it fell to his side. I put it to his heart and then took his chin and made him stare back at me. "Look me in the fucking eyes and tell me that! Tell me there's is not one bit or even a smidge of the old Jeff you were! Because I'm pretty sure I had see- suddenly I'd been caught off guard as he slammed me against the tree making me wince and...... I do not own creepy pasta all rightful work belongs to Mr.Creepypasta and others. Aside from that other elements of the story come from my own mind. [WARINING:Contains rude language ,mentions of or sexual content.]

Be His Light by TheSmallestFlower_33

Jeff The Killer x Reader...Creepypasta yo It's my first story! (/).(\) please go easy on meeeee! WARNING: I am horribly romantic *sigh* and I might include smut.....shhhhh....just accept it... Side note: I wrote this like forever ago. My stories and interests have changed but this story is a part of who I was at one time and I made a lot of good friends from it. Im keeping it up even though im changing my account from a depressing one to a more uplifting and well written one. I hope all my precious followers will continue to enjoy my stories.

Heart Killer (Jeff the Killer x Male! Reader) by t3rrible_fates

"Shit, shit! Why did you stab me!?" I exclaim, laying on the floor with my hand grasping my side, not really putting thought into what I'm saying anymore. "Well what did you think I came here to do!?" He still has his knife out, pointed out towards me. I grab the closest object and hold it out in front of me, this just so happens to be a can of hairspray. "No, you stay back there, I don't want you doing any more damage than you've already done." He falters for a second and stares at the can of hairspray before looking back at me, "I am a murderer, this is my job...you know what this is just getting annoying." - An 18yr old serial killer under the name of "Jeff The Killer" has been tormenting a small town in southern Mississippi for around a month now. He didn't know why he decided to target this town, he just needed to blow off some steam. He didn't want to be controlled anymore, he needed something different. When he meets (Y/n), and fails to kill him, will he actually find someone that understands him? (Y/n), also 18yrs old, is stuck in a house with an emotionally and physically abusive step sister, an avoidant step brother, a Dad who seemed to care more about his work and social status then his son, and a distant step mother. On the outside he looks perfect, he seems to have everything handed to him. On the inside though, however much he may think he's a saint, it's all a ruse to hide his homicidal thoughts. He prays for something new, something that will save him from the drone of life. However the way that prayer is answered might not be what he intended, but what he needs. (a/n): The version of this story with my own oc is on Ao3. ⚠️Will include violent scenes ⚠️ Tw: slurs cover art by shatteredankles on instagram

You're a Sharp One (Jeff the Killer X Female! Killer! Reader) by Charm_Speaker

"Now now.." Jeff's gruff voice whispered into your ear as he pinned you against the wall of your bedroom walls with his knife pressed against your neck. "You're always complaining how no one can catch you, but, you seem so frightened, with my knife against your [skin toned] neck. Face it. You're destined to death," he spoke as he tilted his head slowly to the side, an insane look in his lidless eyes. You looked at him, your own wide with terror. Who was this man? Why was he here? "He is your soul mate," a faceless man's 'voice' rang through so both of you heard. Jeff turned around, growling lowly. "What?" (I created this story on my Quotev https://www.quotev.com/TrueLove178 )

'Be mine' (Jeff the Killer x Reader) by notesgrabs

'"Jeff?" I ask. He didn't respond. I get up and walk to the door. He gets up and grabs his knife. "Jeff?!" I yell. "Shhhh no need to yell." He says. I look at him in horror. "It's okay doll, it'll only take a second." He says as he lunges at me. He stabs my stomach and I let out a blood curdling scream. I hold my stomach and try to get out of the room.' Started: March 15th, 2021 Status: Complete! I do not own any of the creepypasta characters, artwork, or music. (I'll say if anything is mine) I'm sorry if you read this. It absolutely sucks. Tell me if you notice something wrong so I can improve! Again, sorry.

Human Again (A Jeff the Killer story) by FroggyGirl28

[Completed] " You're so annoying", he suddenly says with pity in his eyes, analyzing my face in disgust. "I prefer to be annoying than a psycho like you!" "You don't know what you're missing, silly girl. My world is a psycho one, true, but so much interesting than yours." He grabs his knife, ready to stab me at any moment. I need to find something to say. Now. "Show me then." He looks at me with surprise and incomprehension. "What?" He pulls his knife away and I know I've won. "Show me your world. In return, I'll show you mine. I'll show you all the beautiful things in it. I'll show you how to be human again." And with that, my world has never been the same anymore. ******************** The character of Jeff isn't mine. Please note that it's a story about Jeff the Killer, but without all the creepypasta thing. I tried to imagine how he'd be if he lived in our real world. Sorry for the grammar mistakes, I'm not from an English speaking country.

Mine ( Jeff the Killer × Depressed Reader) (Completed) by Indeedimawsome

You often go outside at night. Because that's when you can hide. You wear a mask to hide your pain. You don't smile. When you do it's to conceal pain from reaching out and getting ahold of the last bit of sanity you have. That is, until you meet him. He's always smiling. Even when in pain. His eyes stare into your soul without a single blink. And he holds a bloody knife to your throat. Which will only make him smile more when you start to realize, HE IS FEAR. *DOES INCLUDE ADULT CONTEXT! CUSSING MENTIONS OF RAPE AND OTHER SUBJECTS THAT MAY MAKE YOU UNCOMFORTABLE* You have been warned

Fatal Insanity (Jeff The Killer X Reader) by Majora_Drowned_BEN

You and Jeff had been best friends and neighbors since you were both little and basically grew up together, until you almost turned thirteen and moved away to a new town. Crying inside knowing you would never see him again, but that all changed a year later, when you had found out that him and his family were moving into the same town and neighborhood as you. Overall, you were happy that you could hang out with your best friend again, like old times. Though, you never expected to have feelings for him since he was your best friend, but one thing that took a turn for the worst, and the one thing that never left you the same, was that your best friend..... ~turned into a killer~

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Captured (Jeff the Killer) cover

PSYCHOTIC. (A Jeff the Killer P.O.V and Romance) cover

Those cold eyes of stone(Jeff the killer FanFiction) cover

Be His Light cover

Heart Killer (Jeff the Killer x Male! Reader) cover

You're a Sharp One (Jeff the Killer X Female! Killer! Reader) cover

'Be mine' (Jeff the Killer x Reader) cover

Human Again (A Jeff the Killer story) cover

Mine ( Jeff the Killer × Depressed Reader) (Completed) cover

Fatal Insanity (Jeff The Killer X Reader) cover

Captured (Jeff the Killer)

We fight, we break up. We kiss, we make up. We're going in circles, being chased by your demons. Sirens and flashing lights fill my life now, even though my colors are stained. You're a liar, and a lie. Something inside of me tries to cry, but no tears appear. Cuffs and knives, chains and lost lives. Tormented and loved, something doesn't seem right. Tell me now, are you glad that you've been tamed? Or, do you feel like you've been captured?