she's a catch | benny rodriguez
- Reads 206,891
- Votes 3,510
- Parts 24
Ongoing2h 57m
Last published Thu, Dec 30, 2021
"Hey did you hit that homer?!"
The guy nodded and took off his cap.
Beautiful wavy hair came down.
Our mouths dropped.
"Y-y-your uhh-
"A girl."
Olivia Hale was an odd ball. She was bullied for being a girl who liked to play baseball. When her mom died in a car crash she moved to another town with her dad and brothers for a fresh start.
What happens when she meets a certain baseball player and falls head over heels for him?
Will he make her forget all her troubles?
Or will he give her some new problems to worry about?
[content warning: very cringe, lil cliché]
Note: This takes place before Benny and the beast
Highest ranking:
#1 sandlot
#1 benny
All Rights Reserved
#347
squints
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Stay || Benny The Jet Rodriguez
"Please don't go. We all need you... I need you." Ella Moore was visiting her grandma over the summer. She becomes fast friends sandlot boys since they all shared a passion for playing baseball. Although she had a boyfriend back in Texas, she couldn't help but fall for the best player in California, Benny Rodriguez. At the end of the summer, she's forced to choose whether to stay or go back to her life in Texas. This is based in 2021 but without corona (some characters belong to the creator of the sandlot movies) Go read pt 2 after as well! It's called "Forever Yours"Complete
The Jet and The Blaze
[Benny Rodriguez x Reader] "You know, I think red and blue go well together." ~~~~ Summer of '62 was hectic. After all, when two kids decide to want to play baseball, it seems to be the biggest joke of all time. Especially when a boy wants to play but can't, and because a girl playing baseball is simply taboo. After all, girls don't really play baseball. The boys at the sandlot didn't think Smalls could throw a ball for his life, nevertheless play baseball. But when a girl decides to challenge them and give them a run for their money... It changes things. Especially for Benny Rodriguez and the reader. ~~~~ Disclaimer: I do not own anything, not the characters, plot line, nor the songs used in this story. This is strictly for entertainment.Complete
Angels In The Outfield
A new girl moved into town and every boy fights for her attention. Benny Rodriguez, the only boy who catches the girl's eye, might win her over.Complete
Sunshine // Benny Rodriguez
"He had kissed a woman, and he had kissed her long and good." // BENNY RODRIGUEZ x OC TW: abuseComplete
You're Such a Dream to Me{Benny x reader}
{Benny "the Jet" Rodriguez x reader} This is my first story so sorry if it's kind of trashy :D I've seen many Benny Fics that are not x reader so I decided to make one myself for you guys to enjoy ~Story takes place in the 90's~ "Before you speak don't move cause I don't wanna wake up.." You moved from Manhattan, New York to California(I know the sandlot is in Utah but In this story it will be in Cali)and met this group of guys that clearly play baseball. Personally you love baseball and softball and used to play for your school. You go outside to your yard and meet both Benny and Smalls. They ask if you'd like to play with the guys and you finally agreed. You then began to catch feelings for him and you come across a situation that brings you all together. Hope you like it :) I do not own the sandlot characters Completed✅ Highest placement: #2 bennyxreader #1 bennyxreaderComplete
Phillips' Sister (Benny Rodriguez)
A girl named Rowan Phillips who was only in love with baseball. And a boy named Benny Rodriguez who shared the same love for the sport. Rowan would always bully Benny at school, tormenting him only because of her brother. After Jordan Phillips forces his sister Rowan to play a game against another team with him, Benny sees the talent Rowan has. He tries to get her on his team, but the boys are far from wanting her on their team, she is a girl after all. Something about this boy, Benny, happens to catch Rowan's eyes. She develops something forbidden out of his kindness toward her. What would her brother think?Complete
𝑚𝑖 𝑎𝑚𝑜𝑟 - 𝑏.𝑟𝑜𝑑𝑟𝑖𝑔𝑢𝑒𝑧
dylan miller is the new kid in town. she was taught how to play ball by her parents at a young age and the young girl had a natural talent. life was going good until she was forced to move away from her home and her boyfriend. dylan thought her life was over until a handsome boy that goes by the name of benjamin rodriguez invites her to the sandlot to ball with his friends. (lower case is intended) (i don't own any of the sandlot guys except for the characters i created) started- august 12th 2021 finished- august 22st 2021 edited- YES FINALLY!!Complete
Eyes On You // Benny Rodriguez
{Benny x Reader} Y/n just moved back to her hometown with her new stepbrother Scotty Smalls. He goes and plays baseball with the sandlot boys and they all make fun of him, except for one. You have to bring out your inner baseball skills and show of these boys, catching the eyes of one in particular. This story was in existence on my other account that got deleted so I had to make a new account and rewrite it on here.Complete
"Please don't go. We all need you... I need you." Ella Moore was visiting her grandma over the summer. She becomes fast friends sandlot boys since they all shared a passion for playing baseball. Although she had a boyfriend back in Texas, she couldn't help but fall for the best player in California, Benny Rodriguez. At the end of the summer, she's forced to choose whether to stay or go back to her life in Texas. This is based in 2021 but without corona (some characters belong to the creator of the sandlot movies) Go read pt 2 after as well! It's called "Forever Yours"
More detailsContent Guidelines