The First and The Last (A Creepypasta X Reader) - CaitCat - Wattpad

The First and The Last (A Creepypasta X Reader)

Reads 268,294
Votes 7,586
Parts 19
Time 1h 51m

Reads 268,294
Votes 7,586
Parts 19
Time 1h 51m

ben creepypasta creepypastaxreader fanfiction hoody jeffthekiller jungle laughingjack masky proxies slenderman texttospeech wattys2017 xreader

This is a story about Slenderman's first proxy. Now, of course, this story must start at the beginning, when he first meets you. Set in the 1800s, you meet Slenderman after running away from some men and into the nearby forest.

     After about 200 years, when Masky, Hoodie, and Toby are his proxies, he assigns them a difficult task. A task to find this "runaway proxy" and bring her back. But when they do, they realize they've got a very, very hard decision to make, and...well, I wouldn't want to ruin the plot.


      Also, I want to thank @Taylor_loveDun for helping me out with this book!All Rights Reserved

ben creepypasta creepypastaxreader fanfiction hoody jeffthekiller jungle laughingjack masky proxies slenderman texttospeech wattys2017 xreader

Table of contents

19 parts

Sign up to add The First and The Last (A Creepypasta X Reader) to your library and receive updates

or

#131creepypasta

Content Guidelines

You may also like

I'm Just A Freak (Abandoned) by clear-quartz

||WARNING! THIS BOOK HAS BEEN ABANDONED!|| (Y/N) had always been a seemingly normal guy. Never really causing trouble, had great friends and a loving sister, but he had struggles that little to no one knew about. One day, though, that all changed with a few simple actions done by another. A/N I do not own any of the Creepypastas, art, or videos (unless said otherwise) in this story (sadly). All credit goes to the original creators.

Trapped (A Ticci Toby Story) by Geofox

***This story is told completely through Toby's POV*** My life has stopped... I was supposed to keep training. I was supposed to keep developing the skills that it took to be the slenderman's proxy. I was supposed to be there for Sally when she couldn't sleep. I was supposed to be between Jeff and Ben while they tried to show me a movie I could never sit still long enough for. I was supposed to be standing in front of Masky while he yelled at me about my carelessness. I was supposed to be there to receive Hoodie's reassuring smile. I was supposed to be with them... but I'm not. Something horrible happened to me...

Masky x reader: Behind the Mask [DISCONTINUED] by The_Pseudonymous_One

November 2018- 1st in maskyxreader (wow) -------- Some notes before we start: Yes I know that Masky is not part of creepypasta but I love creepypasta and I just want to have it in the story. - - - - - - - - - Blurb: y/n, a fearless girl who loves exploring the woods next to her and getting into trouble. One day, her and her friends stumble upon a house in the woods. But not just any house, a mansion of incredible looks. After a mysterious man attacks her friends, y/n is left to explore the mansion by herself and finds herself in an unlikely situation

The Lady in the Mask (Hoodie x Reader fanfiction by SarahMKJ

Halloween. Y/n's favorite holiday. All she has to do is put on a mask and no one will know it's her. Bullies can't find her even if she was standing in front of them. She keeps her costume secret every year to keep bullies from discovering who she is. But they aren't the only ones who are unaware. My first two creepypasta x reader books had a picture on each chapter. They are pretty time-consuming and difficult to make. If you all want me to still do them I will. Just let me know :).

Live My Life. (A CreepyPasta story) by Crazy_Mischief_Fox

(This story is major cringe for me to see with my own eyes in the year 2021, but not when I wrote it years ago so there's plenty of grammar/spelling/other mistakes that I'm not going to fix lol.) A story about a girl who finds her way into the world of Creepypastas with her friends. They train, fight, and kill just like the others. But when someone comes back from old and painful memories, there's bound to be a fight. Read on to figure out who/what happens in the story.•~ (Changed the description lol -Mischief.•~) Story cover designed and drawn by my good friend, Marshmaadow!~ 💜

You've Missed Mouthy by The_AllyGator

"Jeff, this is Mouthy. She's my proxy." Slender waves his hand at the girl. Jeff grows frustrated. "Another one! I thought you would stop gathering them after picking up Toby! How many proxies do you need?" "I currently have six on hand." Jeff's jaw drops and he starts counting on his fingers. "So, Masky, Hoody, Toby, and her. So there's still two I don't know of. Boss, why haven't you told anyone else about her or the other two?" "Jeff, I haven't told you becau-" Slender begins his explanation but the hotheaded teen interrupts. "I wouldn't be surprised if you haven't even told the other three." Jeff stands off his chair screaming at the tall man as he turns his head to the girl on the floor and she looks up to him, pausing her stitching to nod in silence.

𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢? [✔] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader} by Lesbesbean

In order to save your life, Slenderman does what he swore he'd never do - he makes you his proxy. Little did you know how much it would change your life... - - - The reader is kept gender-neutral throughout the whole story and smut chapters always have two versions (one for male and one for female anatomy). Tldr; this is a creepypasta x reader fanfic, let's not take it *too* seriously. Characters here are probably very OOC, I shaped them as I wish to create a fun story ;3

Our New Addition - A CreepyPasta Fanfiction. [DISCONTINUED] by cinnabunny08

I'm no longer working on this story. Truth be told, I don't like it. I kept telling myself that once I got it started I'd sort of warm up to it, but at this point I've given up on it. I have no motivation nor desire to continue it. I do, however, have other CreepyPasta-related story ideas. Stay tuned for those. <3

Messed up in all the right ways {proxies X reader} by mortuusrising

{C O M P L E T E D} -- An orphan girl, (y/n) (l/n) an abused and bullied girl with depression. Her life changes when she is taken to become the newest proxy, and meets the proxies. Read to find out what happens next! -- Cover by: @OliverTheHoodini -- *contains: mature language, potential triggers, abuse, and depression. (so far)* -- This is a crossover universe/alternate universe where the events of marble hornets did happen but Hoodie never died and instead of Tim (Masky) running away from the law, they both went with The operator. The operator will be Slenderman not a different entity in this story -- I am very aware that Masky and Hoodie aren't creepypasta characters, and that they have never and will never be in anyway connected to creepypasta. -- Masky and hoodie belong to THAC Ticci-Toby belongs to Kastoway (even though Kastoway doesn't care anymore) -- sorry for such a long description. But, enjoy!

It's all your fault (Masky x reader) by oxblurxo

A creepypasta and marble hornets crossover fic. <3 (Y/n) ran away from her home and went to Alabama where (F/n) lives. She meets Timothy and Brian along the way and is haunted by Slenderman. Next thing she knows is that everyone in her life is dead and she is now apart of the creepypasta family. But there is some bumps in the road that will lead to disaster. But who's fault is it? "This is all YOUR fault." Best rankings: #1/58 in marble #4/246 in marblehornets #19/306 in tim #91/1000+ in hoodie #127/1000+ in masky #580/1000+ in creepypasta WARNING!!!! CONTAINS: blood, depression, swearing, killing, secrets, cliff hangers, long ass chapters and marble hornets spoilers. If you are uncomfortable reading that kind of stuff then don't read this book at all. I DO NOT ENCOURAGE ANY OF THOSE THINGS ^^^

Hoodie x reader Friendship and Love by TazminMcPasta

Hoodie is a young teen who doesn't only work, but is Slendermans proxy. Actually his frist. Hoodies best friend is Masky. The second proxy. Toby was the last. Masky and Toby are rivals. At times Masky treats Hoodie like shit. One day Hoodie goes for a walk to the park before his killing spree. There he sees a young girl. Hoodie finds her very beautiful so he tries to learn a bit about her, but when they meet is it going to be the way Hoodie expected or not.

𝐓𝐢𝐜𝐜𝐢 𝐓𝐨𝐛𝐲 𝐱 𝐑𝐞𝐚𝐝𝐞𝐫: 𝐄𝐲𝐞𝐬 𝐎𝐟 𝐃𝐞𝐜𝐞𝐢𝐭 by aurorauxx

"I told you the night you tried to kill me; he's not your God." Sequel to An Eye For An Eye. Years after The Subordinate is closed, Y/N attempts to rebuild her life and recover from her short-lived romance with Toby. He's a changed man since becoming a proxy, with memory loss and lust for murder. Her heart still longs for him even years later. Will their relationship ever be repaired? The Slenderman is keeping an eye on them. TW: Mature themes!

Broken(Masky x Reader x Hoodie) by Mr_CookiesAndMilk

"Y/N. Just say one word. Hoodie or me?" "I-I don't-..." I paused. The words wouldn't come out right. My eyes darted from Hoodie to Masky ¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿?¿? Y/N was a young girl who lived a normal life. She had everything she needed and was prepared to graduate from university and find a job, then finally start her life. But.. That would never happen She was home alone one night. Two men broke in and took her far away from her home. They took her into a world of darkness and evil. Creepypåsta's realm. A place where no human could enter without being with another creepy pasta. She was trapped there until she accepted her role as a new creepypasta member and the new proxy of Slenderman. But there are some strange things Y/N has been seeing. There are predators after her. Monsters. Things taken over with insanity and darkness. They want to devour her heart. Masky and Hoodie had been assigned to protect her at all costs. And guess what happens between the three of them? A huge love triangle that seems to be impossible to fix. "T H E Y A R E A L W A Y S W I T H U S" Mature content in this story. Part of the Dead Creepypasta series. Each book can be read alone All photos belong to someone else nothing belongs to me except for the writing Enjoy the story FIRST BOOK :)) Cough cough this will be written as a female reader

Living With The Creepypastas (Old) by VikingMetalToby

IMPORTANT: I originally wrote this back in 2018 when I was younger and an idiot and sucked badly at writing. It's all toxic fandom stereotypes in this book. You should know ahead of time that this story is gonna suck. Huge L. DESC: You're a useless outsider until you get recruited by Slenderman one night. Congrats, you get to be a proxy and live in the Slender Mansion with the creepypastas and have cliché a Creepypasta x reader life! Ughhh. !𝐒𝐓𝐎𝐑𝐘 𝐖𝐀𝐑𝐍𝐈𝐍𝐆𝐒! - Y/N, unfortunately, is the overused female lead idiot stupid. (Please feel free to treat Y/N as your preference). - Ticci Toby is 'sort of' a waffle addict. - Hoody and Masky are considered Creepypasta/Proxies. - There's TicciWork (This was old, alright?) - There's obvious excessive cursing. - There's obviously cringe (2018 trash.) - yeah #1 in boring. Now you know to run...

Masky X Reader X Hoodie by WildChild289

Alone in the forest, A runaway from your abusive ex bf, A savior named hoodie takes you to a mansion.... An outgoing guy and a cold hearted killer. 2 guys 1 heart... Who will you choose?.

To Remember: Just One Night (Hoodie x Reader) by IllusionTheProxy

#CPAWARDSSHOUTOUT (Be prepared for stupid references in each update, especially each chapters' title. And yes, this is a Creepypasta x reader book!) There's no way to sugarcoat this. You've been held hostage by psychotic killers, all because you were the popular girl going to a forbidden party location. Popularity has its downsides, pretty obvious here. Those killers, they tormented you so badly. So heartlessly. But you didn't give up. That's your problem. You don't know when to quit. Because this is just one night, one night you will always be forced to remember. (((((Hoodie x Reader)))))

Second Family [Creepypasta x Reader] by GhostyGirl666

A Creepypasta x Reader: After the murder of your (first) family you decide you have no where to go. You were a nobody who had to make quick decisions to get out of situations, which led you to meet a group of... colourful characters. You being the creative and quirky person you are decide to stick around and meet them all, family number two. ---------------------------------------------------- Hey! Credit goes to the artists! Hey! Hope you enjoy this, leave your opinions and suggestions! As you know Creepypastas are popular- sidenote. I KNOW Masky and Hoodie are from Marble Hornets... but, proxies man. Proxies. Also, we all know that Creepypasta's mean that there will be some gore, but I will put a gore warning before I speak of it. *light swearing* Thank Chu~ GhostyGirl666

Jake The Lumberjack: He Comes by Blushy_Boy

- Cover made by Mystical_Panda! - A Creepypasta story, My oc, DO NOT STEAL! His life use to almost be perfect, well, besides the fact were he was never loved by his family. But one day when his dad finally gave him the chance to show off what he could do, he screwed up. Something happened to him, he went insane, slowly, minute by minute. But when six months past by, he went full insane and did something that he might regret. But when he ran away, he ran into some people. They ended up being the Creepypasta. They become good friends, well most of them at least. But, something happened one night that led to something big. Read to figure out what happens.

Rose Petals - Eyeless Jack x Reader by Afflicted-Alibis

You always wanted a way out of town and away from the trauma of your every day life, but who knew it would come to you in a blue mask? Your life was certainly troubled. You had no parents- they were stripped away from you by a faceless thing in the woods one night when you were a small child. You had a troubled friend group. You had a stressful, mind-numbing minimum wage job. You had a broken home, completed by the drunken, careless uncle who had once promised to take care of you and your siblings. It made you want to disappear. The grey man dressed in black was a surprise to you after a chaotic night at home, and it was just his luck you even found him. However, what you thought to be a strange new friend was lethal and full of old horrors, and you soon come to find that he wants to be much more than just friends. (Cover art belongs to me!) Started: 8/26/2022 First Published: 10/15/2022 Finished: [Pending]

The Devil's Demon [Ticci Toby X Reader] by SteveFromCorporate

Sometimes life doesn't go to plan. Sometimes the people you love, don't love you back. Sometimes, you get fed up with some people and take matters into your own hands. She's baack! By she, I mean you. (Y/N). You're back. The long awaited sequel to "A Dance With The Devil" is finally here! With a whole lot more drama and more. Dedicated to all the people who were so supportive in the first book! I hope you love it. *** (Y/N) has been through one hell of a time when she first encountered the love of her life,Toby. After the death of her friends and her own near death experience, (Y/N) can finally relax in the safety of the creepypasta mansion. Or so our sassy friend (you) thinks. A year has past and (Y/N) is now 19 years old. Her year long, rocky relationship with Toby has kept her happy. But when (Y/N) hears some bittersweet news, her excitement turns to rage when she gets fed up of how indecisive Toby is. What will she do? ** All credit for the amazing cover art goes to the artist!

You may also like

Slide 1 of 20

I'm Just A Freak (Abandoned) cover

Trapped (A Ticci Toby Story) cover

Masky x reader: Behind the Mask [DISCONTINUED] cover

The Lady in the Mask (Hoodie x Reader fanfiction cover

Live My Life. (A CreepyPasta story) cover

You've Missed Mouthy cover

𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢? [✔] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader} cover

Our New Addition - A CreepyPasta Fanfiction. [DISCONTINUED] cover

Messed up in all the right ways {proxies X reader} cover

It's all your fault (Masky x reader) cover

Hoodie x reader Friendship and Love cover

𝐓𝐢𝐜𝐜𝐢 𝐓𝐨𝐛𝐲 𝐱 𝐑𝐞𝐚𝐝𝐞𝐫: 𝐄𝐲𝐞𝐬 𝐎𝐟 𝐃𝐞𝐜𝐞𝐢𝐭 cover

Broken(Masky x Reader x Hoodie) cover

Living With The Creepypastas (Old) cover

Masky X Reader X Hoodie cover

To Remember: Just One Night (Hoodie x Reader) cover

Second Family [Creepypasta x Reader] cover

Jake The Lumberjack: He Comes cover

Rose Petals - Eyeless Jack x Reader cover

The Devil's Demon [Ticci Toby X Reader] cover

I'm Just A Freak (Abandoned)

||WARNING! THIS BOOK HAS BEEN ABANDONED!|| (Y/N) had always been a seemingly normal guy. Never really causing trouble, had great friends and a loving sister, but he had struggles that little to no one knew about. One day, though, that all changed with a few simple actions done by another. A/N I do not own any of the Creepypastas, art, or videos (unless said otherwise) in this story (sadly). All credit goes to the original creators.