Torn Between: TVD

After rescuing her sister from the car wreck that their parents died in, Braelyn Gilbert ran away and disappeared for over a year, leaving everyone to think that she had died along with her parents and leaving Elena, her sister, to grieve alone. After one year of absence, however, she came back, and she came back with secrets that she had hoped to keep covered; but what happens when the supernatural drama, which she had tried to keep away, begins stirring in Mystic Falls and threatens to unmask her other life, the life she lived while absent from her sister's life for a year? When Braelyn's ties to the past clash against her present, she must make a choice between what has been and what could be.

Elijah and Damon x OC
The Vampire Diaries: S1-S4