Return of The Broken- Lucifer Fanfiction
ToxicWinchester
  • Reads 48,339
  • Votes 931
  • Parts 40
  • Time 2h 7m
  • Reads 48,339
  • Votes 931
  • Parts 40
  • Time 2h 7m
ToxicWinchester
Ongoing, First published Aug 12, 2016
angelcascasifercastieldeandeanwinchesterdemonsdevilevilheavenhellloveluciferromancesamsamwinchestersatanspnsupernatural
Long before Lucifer was cast down, he was gods favorite, and was in love with an angel named Cara.

His actions tore them apart, and ended their love story in tragedy.

They stayed apart for Millenniums, but no matter what they wouldn't leave one another's mind.

When Lucifer was set free the first time by Cara's  friends Sam an Dean, she ran. 

Dean told her it was safe to come back, and she returned to them.

But, what happens when Lucifer comes back in Cas to help defeat the darkness, and Cara comes face to face with Lucifer for the first time in a while.


---------------
I DO NOT OWN SUPERNATURAL OR THE CHARACTERS, I only own Cara.

I suck at summaries, but it's really good so enjoy!
All Rights Reserved
angelcascasifercastieldeandeanwinchesterdemonsdevilevilheavenhellloveluciferromancesamsamwinchestersatanspnsupernatural
Table of contents

40 parts

Sign up to add Return of The Broken- Lucifer Fanfiction to your library and receive updates
or
#257heaven
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Destiny ~ Dean Winchester (love story), part two by cornylabased
48 parts Ongoing Mature
DeanxOC [AU] ~intense love story, enemies to lovers, forced proximity, trauma~ Dean is devastated, questioning himself and the whole world. When Sam explained to him what had happened with the Djinn, he was sure that he'd manage to get the "old" Angie back anyways. But after experiencing first hand that it only took her a few hours to start a new life without him, Dean decided to let her go for good. Meanwhile Angie gets a job at a secret task force after re-connecting with an old friend. He introduces her to new people and a different way of hunting. Without the trauma caused in hell, she seems happier than ever. If only she didn't feel like there was something crucial missing all of the time. When Castiel sends the Winchesters to find Angie to get her help against Lucifer, not only old but also new feelings spark. How long can Dean hide the history between him and Angie? What has all of that to do with their destiny that the angels had predicted for them?
I'm Back, Baby! by casislokisavage
31 parts Complete
Two girls, who've never known each other besides the fact that their fathers despise each other, somehow gets involved in the hunt. When Castiel sends Dean and Sam off to England, they discover the shocking truth behind their true mission. While Sherlock uncovers the truth about supernatural beings... *I do not own any of the characters from BBC Sherlock or Supernatural. Certain characters and plot lines are used and everything besides my OCs, Jean and Becky, belong to the writers and creators of Sherlock and Supernatural. Also The spn crew is actually younger with Dean as 24 and Sam is 20.* I'll try by best to update weekly but sometimes things just come up so please be patient.
You Deserve To Be Saved (Destiel) by youmeatmorgan_
21 parts Complete
"They say relationships are built on trust. So what happens when you can't trust someone, but you simply can't leave them?" Dean is a normal boy. He lives in a small town with his brother and goes to college, like any normal boy. But there's also a twist to Dean. His college years were horrible. A group of boys made it living hell and Dean found it impossible to stay alive. Just when he thought things could never improve, there's a new boy in town. And he goes to the same college as Dean. He quickly realises that this boy means something to him. Can Cas save Dean and keep him alive any longer? The answer is yes, he can. Dean and Cas soon find themselves in a very committed relationship. They'd do anything for eachother. But Cas starts doing things behind Deans back, and it's having a bad effect on him. And the tables turn. Can Dean save Cas and keep him alive any longer?
The Start Of It All (Castiel x Reader) (Discontinued) by castielxlove
9 parts Complete Mature
This is a season rewrite with the reader inserted into the story. It starts at season 4 because that's when Castiel comes in. You were adopted by Bobby Singer when you were seven years old because your parents were killed by demons and you were an only child. You've lived with him ever since and you loved it. He taught you how to shoot a gun and how to fight and also how to hunt. He never let you go on hunts, until you met Sam and Dean Winchester. After you met them, you went on every hunt with them, and they were basically brothers to you. When Dean makes a deal with a demon to save Sam, your heart is torn in pieces. You tried to stop Lilith and the hellhounds but she was stronger than you and Sam. Four months later when Dean shows up on your doorstep, you don't know what to think. Warning: Explicit content! No worse than Supernatural. I'm only using the quotes said in Supernatural and the main storyline. All credit goes to the creaters and writers of Supernatural
Star Fall / Book One (SPN Fan Fiction) by callisto_col_writes
47 parts Complete Mature
At the end of yet another successful hunt, Sam and Dean Winchester are gifted a very unexpected call for help from their beloved angel, Castiel. The job? Protecting a sketchy, wanted, highly trained, hunter on the run for their life. His instruction? "Keep them safe, and alive. No matter what the cost." Soon enough, the boys begin to unravel all the secrets, and lies. And everyone is forced to face the truth. After the acceptance settles in, a romance flourishes. But what arises after is a much larger truth. The WHOLE truth. If the boys are going to protect their new friend, and keep their word to Castiel... It would mean starting a war. • BOOK ONE / (A SPN Fan Fiction) • #1 in vanhelsing from 10/27/2020 to 2/15/2021 #1 in SPNfanfiction from 7/16/2022 to 7/22/2022 #1 in savingpeoplehuntingthings on 9/12/2022 #3 in spnfandom on 9/10/2022 to 9/15/2022 #1 in savingpeoplehuntingthings on 7/9/2024 to 7/10/2024 #2 in samanddean on 7/9/2024 to 7/11/2025 ***DISCLAIMER*** I do not own the characters created by the television show Supernatural, and other copyrighted characters -- only the ones I create myself. ***TRIGGER WARNING*** Mature content, violence, demons and spiritual/horror creatures, death, genocide, substance abuse, mental illnesses & personality disorder undertones, mature language, mentions of child neglect, mentions of psychological fear, use of combat & weapons, and very mature sexual content. (18+)
Hell's Greatest Weapon by hellsgreatestweapon
40 parts Complete
After centuries of incessant war, Reader finally managed to settle down into a normal human life; she attended medical school, bought a house, made friends that didn't make a habit of killing everything that moved. She was out of the life, out of Hell, and she was enjoying the fact. When a shattered Sam Winchester shows up on her doorstep after five years of silence from the man, however, Reader is forced to decide between delving back into the life--threatening everyone's safety in the meantime--or sacrificing the beloved Winchesters in order to keep the peace she managed to obtain. [Takes place during season 10, so there will be some spoilers] [Some swearing, fairly heavy alcohol usage throughout, violence (obviously)]
Breaking Through (A Supernatural Fanfiction) {1} by musicdreams31
23 parts Complete
(Set in Season 5) ""Guess who else just escaped Hell thanks to your brother?" Bobby replied. Dean glanced back over at Libby with wide eyes. This time her eyes widened. "I'm not him, I swear!" she shrieked. "I'm not Lucifer, I'm just his daughter."" ------------------------------ The Apocalypse is among the Winchesters and the world, putting everything they've ever known at risk. But when one girl seems to crawl out of Hell alongside Lucifer, the boys find out things that no one has ever known. After killing Lilith, Lucifer was set free, able to roam Earth like any another angel or demon. A girl came with him, one that was never mentioned in any piece of literature or lore, including the Bible itself. Elizabeth, better known as Libby, was sent to Hell just eighteen years after humanity first walked the Earth. She was believed a liability and a soldier. Her job was to keep Lucifer in check and in Hell, no one being able to pull either of them out. Despite the past of her family and being trapped in Hell for millenniums, she managed to stay pure. That is until she finds herself crawling out of the ground thousands of years later. Released from Hell alongside Lucifer, Libby went on a search for the man who had let her out; Sam Winchester. Libby's the first person that everyone should trust, but she's found that it's harder to prove herself after the stunts her father had pulled throughout the history of the universe. With angels and demons on her ass, Libby finds an alliance in Sam and Dean. The daughter of the devil has to have some friends, right? Amazing cover by @uzuriupendo
Destiel High School some Sabriel by Supernatural1806
9 parts Complete
John and chuck where really good friends back in the day but there relationship went down then a new friend and girl came in and broke there relationship piece by piece. They both didn't like John or chuck. The girl became chuck's girlfriend and the boy became chuck's friend. After 3 months of there relationship the boy and girl made out. The boy said he saw John make out with her. The boy and the girl lied to him and broke John and chuck's relationship. Chuck was to broken to talk to John and stopped talking to him. John never found out why his friend just left him. It contains self harm in one part I will have a warning same with the nsfw stuff too. The nsfw part is up now💗it me drawing in the book photo💗hope you guys like the story💗
KIDNAPPED BY SAM AND DEAN WINCHESTER by spn_lover_666
40 parts Complete
You woke up in blood. You've done it before but this time is different. Demons are lined up outside your door and the only thing keeping them out is the salt line so you decide to call in help. Sam and Dean Winchester. They come to the rescue just in time but things get complicated when they insist on keeping you safe and you're scared they'll find out the real you. So you leave them in the middle of the night and their hunt for you begins. They find you and kidnap you. You have to convince them not to kill you which may be easier than you think because Sam likes you. (The point of view switches throughout from first person to third person)
Shattered Memories. (Castiel x reader) by AstralShadows
32 parts Complete Mature
It was an ordinary night of studying when you get a call from your friend. She had met two devilishly handsome men at the bar and wanted you to come by. You had been approaching finals, you had been writing papers non stop and she wanted you to come take a break. Something about the night seemed off when you arrive. Was it because of exhaustion? This would be the night that forever changed your life. All the books and studying no longer mattered. Your life had evolved and so had you. I don't own characters, plot or anything directly related to the Supernatural show. This story is dedicated to a friend who has been asking me to make a Supernatural story for her. It's more of an AU story. I hope you enjoy this story. Comment, vote and let me know if you like it. :3 *my first supernatural fic. So hopefully it's not too shabby. I do not own the pic for the cover, nor do I know who to credit for it. If you don't like me using it, let me know.* Cover by @takemetotulsa thank you so much!
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
Destiny ~ Dean Winchester (love story), part two cover
I'm Back, Baby! cover
You Deserve To Be Saved (Destiel) cover
The Start Of It All (Castiel x Reader) (Discontinued) cover
Star Fall / Book One (SPN Fan Fiction) cover
Hell's Greatest Weapon cover
Breaking Through (A Supernatural Fanfiction) {1} cover
Destiel High School some Sabriel cover
KIDNAPPED BY SAM AND DEAN WINCHESTER cover
Shattered Memories. (Castiel x reader) cover

Destiny ~ Dean Winchester (love story), part two

48 parts Ongoing Mature

DeanxOC [AU] ~intense love story, enemies to lovers, forced proximity, trauma~ Dean is devastated, questioning himself and the whole world. When Sam explained to him what had happened with the Djinn, he was sure that he'd manage to get the "old" Angie back anyways. But after experiencing first hand that it only took her a few hours to start a new life without him, Dean decided to let her go for good. Meanwhile Angie gets a job at a secret task force after re-connecting with an old friend. He introduces her to new people and a different way of hunting. Without the trauma caused in hell, she seems happier than ever. If only she didn't feel like there was something crucial missing all of the time. When Castiel sends the Winchesters to find Angie to get her help against Lucifer, not only old but also new feelings spark. How long can Dean hide the history between him and Angie? What has all of that to do with their destiny that the angels had predicted for them?

More details