The Unforgiven (Jeff The Killer Fanfiction)
- Reads 1,693
- Votes 39
- Parts 6
Ongoing27m
Last published Sat, Oct 26, 2013
Sixteen year old, Renora Penton would love to be a One Direction obsessed, normal teenage girl. But that's not the path she was chosen for. Follow her as she comes face-to-knife with Jeff The Killer and other murderous Creepypastas. The only question is, will she actually live to tell the tale?
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Unhealthy love: Jeff the killer x reader
A lonely girl suddenly discovers her parents aren't who she thought they were when she meets a certain killer. She makes the biggest mistake by allowing that killer to enter her life and makes her question her own sanity. This is my first time writing and publishing in wattpad, I am sorry if it's not well made I will try my best. Disclaimer I don't own the images shown in the chapters as well as the creepypastas or you the only thing I own is the plot and the characters I created.Complete
They Found Me (1D)
Summer Hills isn't your average teenager. She was born to be a vampire, but she doesn't know. Her mother disappears, leaving her with her older sister, who doesn't really pay much attention to her. When she turns 18, her best friend gets her 1D tickets. She goes, but some pretty weird things happen, and she ends up meeting none other than One Direction. What will happen? (I wrote this story when I was a fetus, sorry if it offends 9/10 readers because it's so terrible)Complete
Smile For Me (Jeff The Killer X Reader)
All (Y/N) wanted to do was go home. Pretty typical right? After a move caused her parents to abruptly uproot from the beautiful city of Seattle, Washington State- She is forced to live inside a painfully, small and boring town called Greenhills, Montana. The new house is everything her parents dreamed of for their new future, including the tiny, quaint town full of friendly and kind faces. (Y/N) is forced with no options, but to go with her parents. However, (Y/N) learns the hard way, the town isn't as generously kind as it seems. After an abrupt break in leaves her to forcefully entrust her life in the hands of the infamous Jeffery Woods- or as he brags, 'Jeff The Killer'. One small agreement between the two spirals into something far larger than either of them can fix. Now scrambling for her life, not at the hands of said killer, but at an angry group hunting them down, two investigators who always seem to be a few steps behind, one very pissed off butcher's son, and a web of feelings- (Y/N) must rely not only on what little she know's about survival (and playing nurse), but also a smiling maniac who blur's the line of love and hate. His only request once its all over and they part ways? "Smile for me." ****** 18+ due to mature content. Sexual assault, self harm, mentions of alcoholic abuse, smut, mentions of mental abuse between couples, unhealthy behavioral habits, extreme mental health problems along with unhealthy ways of coping with mental, death, and much more are mentioned in this book. Read at your own risk. Slow updates. Started: (April 9th, 2021) Complete: (Feb. 14th, 2026) Revising: ??? #001 in JeffTheKiller (01/22/2026) #002 in JeffTheKiller (01/11/2026) #195 in CreepyStories #200 in CreepypastaXreader ****** None of the Creepypasta characters mentioned in this book are mine. Jeffery Woods and Jeffery Hodek belong to the rightful owners. You are your own character and belong to yourself. I own the plot, the mom and the dad.Complete
Jeff's Deadly Love
Jeff has loved this girl since he first seen her. But will she ever love a killer? And if she does will Jeff stay after he finds out her secret that may end him....?Complete
Caught In The Forest
Sixteen year-old Penny was content with her life, until the creepypastas barged in on it... *Complete*Complete
Go To Sleep {Jeff The Killer x reader}
I was playing in the front garden with my 10 year old little brother when we saw a car pulling up to the house across from ours. The family who bought the house stepped out of the car. The was a woman, a man, a little boy around my little brother's age and a boy around my age. I stared at him, he had shoulder length messy black hair, dark eyes and a pale skin tone. He noticed I was staring and looked at me. I got all warm inside as he smiled at me, I smiled back. But what I didn't know was what darkness the near future had... (I WILL BE CHANGING A COUPLE THINGS FROM THE ORIGINAL CREEPYPASTA SO THE STORY COMES BETTER AROUND, LIKE JEFF BEING 17 YEARS OLD AND LIU 10 YEARS OLD) [FANART COVER: MATTYS-ART.TUMBLR.COM]Complete
Save Me Tonight (One Direction Fanfic)
Jen was happy. She started her first year of University and was loving it. When her parents died in a freak accident she drops out. She is now 20 years old and in an abusive relationship with a man named Jonah. He took her money and the house is under his name. She is trying to earn enough money to move out and move in with one of her best friends, Cameron. One day at work, she is requested to be some "special" guests waitress. Those guests are one direction. Louis starts to take a liking to her, as she does for him. She wants him so bad but can't leave Jonah. She has to keep her past secret to Louis, but will he ever find out? Will Jonah ever find out about her sneaking around?Complete
A Touch of Insanity(A Jeff The Killer x Reader Love Story) {Discontinued}
(_Name_) is a normal girl, well as normal as a 16 soon to be 17-year-old can be. Living with a family that isn't even hers. Just one thing, she doesn't know that and what's worst everything turns upside down when Jeff tries to kill her. It's a shame though, he failed in his first try due to an...inconvenience. He tries a second time and he fails once again, why though? He hesitated in killing her. But he won't give up so easily, he will do everything and anything to break her life apart.Complete
Kidnapped by one direction{In Editing}
School..one of the worst places I could ever go to.My family:twisted , My friends: traitors , My teachers : haters but there is one I cant describe..one direction: My kidnappers. I am a 17 year year old girl and my name is Lucy Hale...welcome to my life. Lucy is trapped in a world of hell,betrayal,friendship and confusion.....because im in love with one of my kidnappers ##COMPLETED WITH SEQUEL## If s chapter is edited it was say at the top of every chapter :)Complete
My Killer Of A lover (eyeless x reader)
you're a new rookie killer, and slender takes notice of you right away. You get ready to kill the news reporter that was talking shit about you, but someone beat you to it. the one and only Jeff the killer. Jeff tries to kill you but fails. this really got Slender's attention. suddenly your taken hostage by the creepypasta group, and slender keeps talking about you secret.will you tell him? You meet EJ and for some reason you don't feel afraid when you're with him. He is basically your babysitter now. You start having feeling for him and he acts really sexual towards you. What?Complete
A lonely girl suddenly discovers her parents aren't who she thought they were when she meets a certain killer. She makes the biggest mistake by allowing that killer to enter her life and makes her question her own sanity. This is my first time writing and publishing in wattpad, I am sorry if it's not well made I will try my best. Disclaimer I don't own the images shown in the chapters as well as the creepypastas or you the only thing I own is the plot and the characters I created.
More detailsContent Guidelines