After Reagan Castle had a break up with the girl he only loved, Carlie Andrews, fate had been really playful on both of them and because of some circumstances, their paths will cross once again and would fall for each other the second time... or did their love even fade away after a few months of separation? But what if someone wanted to protect Carlie from being hurt by keeping her away from him and letting her marry Karl Voucher, Carlie's childhood friend? Will the pain be worth it?