While visiting her cousins in Denver, Colorado, Lilly Matthews unexpectedly fell deeply in love with a boy she barely knew, Jonah Wright. But, after being harshly rejected by him, she went back home to Cheyenne, Wyoming, with her mind set that she would never make the mistake of falling for him again. Returning three years later, the tables are turned, because suddenly, Jonah is in love with Lilly, and she must decide if she will choose to love him back for a second time. But, with her cousins, friends, and his ex-girlfriend as barriers, she's not sure if falling in love with him all over again is even an option.