Aren't You A Pretty Thing?

Dean Winchester, the new Quarterback transferred in from Lawrence, Kansas. With his good looks and charm he quickly becomes the most popular guy in school but not without a price. In order to prove himself to the rest of the team he has to get a member from the bible club to sleep with him. The catch, it has to be a guy. This simple challenge turns into a life changing event in Dean Winchesters life, one that'll change how he sees the world and himself.

(If that's not dramatic enough for you I don't know what is xD)