What Was Ours [PREQUEL TO WOULD YOU BE MINE]
TheGlitch13
  • Reads 2,542
  • Votes 67
  • Parts 21
  • Time 57m
  • Reads 2,542
  • Votes 67
  • Parts 21
  • Time 57m
TheGlitch13
Complete, First published Oct 16, 2016
Mature
bxbcreepypastadramagaygorehumormaskyromanceticcimaskticcitoby
Two years after Masky is sent away from the mansion, he returns...but different. What about his relationship? Where will that go? Will it end up broken and torn, or can Masky and Toby patch it up?
All Rights Reserved
bxbcreepypastadramagaygorehumormaskyromanceticcimaskticcitoby
Table of contents

21 parts

Sign up to add What Was Ours [PREQUEL TO WOULD YOU BE MINE] to your library and receive updates
or
Content Guidelines
You may also like
One Week changes everything || TobyxReader by hazelnut420
7 parts Complete Mature
Y/n encounters Toby in the most random way possible. How will their relationship grow for this first week?
Painful Love-(Ticcimask fan fiction) by TicciToby_Lover
19 parts Complete
When the new proxy, Toby, comes to live at the Slender mansion, Masky is a little happy, but still doesn't like the idea that he has to watch over him. But what happens when Toby gets into some trouble that he didn't even cause. In this story Toby's life was is worse than any other pasta, (just an FWI) also, I made Toby have a form of autism that makes it so he's very crazy and doesn't like being touched a lot. A few curses here and there. Plus some rape. Trigger warning ⚠️
What About Me? (Ticci Toby X Masky) by RIPchitaprrrr
10 parts Complete Mature
When Masky first met Toby, it was under Slendermans orders. Masky couldn't stand Toby, and resented ever having to speak with the kid. But after being forces to spend time with one another, Masky realizes that Toby isn't such a bad guy. This is just another one of those typical cliché TicciMask love stories. DISCLAIMER: I DON'T OWN ANY OF THE CHARACTERS OR PICTURES IN THE STORY.
Ticci-toby love story. by edigoosepeterson
13 parts Complete
This is about a girl named blue. Blue spent her teen years looking for toby and killing. As she was looking for toby, toby was living a normal life after running away from slender. Toby is married and win blue found out, she was not too happy about that. But if she's not happy that doesn't mean she's not gonna let toby be happy. Blue tries her best to keep toby safe and tries to win him back with her love. What will happen?. There is a lot more going on so you can find out. Enjoy. (sorry for messed up spelling. I worked on this for 2 days and only at night for like 4 or 5 hours)
Now Or Never (Ticci Toby X Eyeless Jack) by BoltTheCat
15 parts Complete Mature
It's a normal day for Toby at the Slender Mansion but when he returns from a mission things seem different, tensions rise, and changes occur. It's either now or never to figure things out and see what's going on. Warnings: Gore/Violence, Profanity, Slight sexual themes, Kidnapping, and LGBTQ/Shipping. All the Creepypasta characters mentioned in this story belong to their rightful owners, the cover art and story belongs to me.
I Like You More Than I Like Waffles by TheGlitch13
30 parts Complete Mature
After years of working together, Toby and Masky begin to have strong feelings towards each other. While Toby is accepting of his feelings, Masky continues to fight against his feelings for the ex proxy while trying to get his job done. Can Toby change Masky's mind about his feelings? Or will Masky remain the way he is and fight his feelings for Toby? I don't own any of the characters. They all go to their rightful owners.
You are my medicine (ticcimask) (Complete) by Smol_Chara
35 parts Complete
The first time Masky layed eyes on Toby, he felt a strange feeling. Over time Toby starts to fall for the man but he doesn't want to make a move on the mask man fearing he will reject his heart. I don't own any of the characters in this story.
Some secrets were meant to be shown by Myst-Star
13 parts Ongoing
Hello, this a remake of my previous book "some secrets were meant to be shown" I didn't really like where the book was going and I guess my writing skills there were really outdated so here we are. Hopefully you'll like this book, and if you do then please comment thank you very much :) ------ Description ------ Toby had always been a wreck at the mansion, that's all. Nothing fun had happened and nothing really had changed. His crush for clockwork has been weird and his relationship with the people living there hasn't been the best. He really was hoping for something to give him a little bit of excitement in his life for once. Lucky for him, life decided to listen to him and give him some one that will change his life forever. ------ Warnings: this is a ticci Toby x eyeless jack fanfic if you don't like this pairing then please leave and find something that suits you more. Thank you
The Devil's Demon [Ticci Toby X Reader] by SteveFromCorporate
12 parts Complete Mature
Sometimes life doesn't go to plan. Sometimes the people you love, don't love you back. Sometimes, you get fed up with some people and take matters into your own hands. She's baack! By she, I mean you. (Y/N). You're back. The long awaited sequel to "A Dance With The Devil" is finally here! With a whole lot more drama and more. Dedicated to all the people who were so supportive in the first book! I hope you love it. *** (Y/N) has been through one hell of a time when she first encountered the love of her life,Toby. After the death of her friends and her own near death experience, (Y/N) can finally relax in the safety of the creepypasta mansion. Or so our sassy friend (you) thinks. A year has past and (Y/N) is now 19 years old. Her year long, rocky relationship with Toby has kept her happy. But when (Y/N) hears some bittersweet news, her excitement turns to rage when she gets fed up of how indecisive Toby is. What will she do? ** All credit for the amazing cover art goes to the artist!
The One Who Saved Me ( Ticcimask love story){discontinued} by ryandeathsadboi
45 parts Complete Mature
Toby has been living in the. Slender mansion for 2 years now. He seems to be the happiest, and annoying, kid ever, but is he really? Toby is quite annoying to Masky. Masky hates him, or so he thought. warning: suicide, cursing, self-harm, and my spelling sucks. thank you all who read this, it means the world to me💜 love you all and hope you enjoy💜
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
One Week changes everything || TobyxReader cover
Painful Love-(Ticcimask fan fiction) cover
What About Me? (Ticci Toby X Masky) cover
Ticci-toby love story. cover
Now Or Never (Ticci Toby X Eyeless Jack) cover
I Like You More Than I Like Waffles cover
You are my medicine (ticcimask) (Complete) cover
Some secrets were meant to be shown cover
The Devil's Demon [Ticci Toby X Reader] cover
The One Who Saved Me ( Ticcimask love story){discontinued} cover

One Week changes everything || TobyxReader

7 parts Complete Mature

Y/n encounters Toby in the most random way possible. How will their relationship grow for this first week?

More details