Hatchets and Carved Smiles

Toby Rogers has always had a crush on Jeff the Killer, but what would happen if Jeff the Killer actually liked Toby back?!?! An impossibility but what if it happened. When Jeff agrees to go out with Toby, Jeff's jealous ex boyfriend may not react so well to this change. Will Toby be able to handle the stress? And as if finding out your current used to date so many other pastas isnt bad, Toby's mental state is falling. Will Jeff be able to hold onto Toby, or will Toby give up the constant battle? May contain mature content. I do not own the creepypasta, just the plot. Toby x Jeff lemon