Isadore Utley thinks he has a weird name, personality, and status. He has always been the foil character to his best friend, Cole, who is the most popular guy at school. Being used to getting ignored in conversations, Isadore keeps a low expectation on everything. But he finds himself in a tricky situation when Cole's long-term girlfriend dumps him and when she tells him that she likes his best friend, which is Isadore, instead. Is this a trick or a treat?